after spending 2 games listening to Hawk Harrelson, i afraid i MUST disagree

I dont know what it is about some of these midwest play by play guys, but i cant stand them. as an MLB.TV subscriber, when the yanks play on the road i am stuck with the home teams broadcasts, and by far the most annoying is Hawk Harrelson. The way he calls a game, calls the players by their first name like he knows them; i watch the games on mute. I worked in the Press box in Oakland last summer and I met him, he was actually a really nice guy, its just his work is awful

thought Michael Kay can get on my nerves alot, atleast he as some excitement in his voice when the opposing team does something. Hawk acts like he was just punched in the gut if any team but the white sox scores a run or makes a great play

i have to agree , i havent listened to a game on the radio in ages, i really cant stand the sterling waldman broadcast..whos idea was it to pair these 2 together and have them call baseball games? sterling never tells you what pitch is thrown and blows calls left and right , and waldman is a joke.

The next time I listen to Sterling and Waldman out of anything but absolute necessity will be the day after they finish defrosting Hell.

sterling is bad, but when it comes to Mushnick:

those in glass houses….

Mushnick criticizing Sterling is like going to the zoo and watching the oragutangs flinging poop at each other.

I’m pretty much unimpressed with the MSM. Everybody is an expert and then when the exact opposite of what the ‘expert’ said happens, nobody cares.

Seriously, Sterling is bad but Waldman is a really unbelievably terrible. The way she gushes over the players like a school kid talking about her heros is embarrassing. I wish they hadn’t let Charlie Steiner go to LA he was pretty good.

Sterling’s biggest problem is (besides: speaking French and singing show tunes too much, thinking that Jeter is a great defensive SS, hating stats, and treating Yankee players as if they are not just great, but also noble) is that his eyesight is failing him.

Waldman is a circus clown. She perseverates on phrases like “flat out hit” because she heard some scout say it, and she repeats whatever meme she heard last. She should stick to being a reporter, which she didn’t suck at.

Was that article actually published in a print newspaper? Or is it just some internet-only rubbish?

I ask because that was one of the most disjointed, poorly written things I’ve read in a while. And I grade a lot of freshman undergraduate science papers, so I know bad writing. Mushnick = F-minus.

I read that this afternoon and I completely agree. I was driving home from the gym the other day with my fiance and I was listening to the beginning of the game. Sterling goes into one of his ‘it is high…’ moments only to say that it was caught in front of the warning track. I just turned to my fiance shaking my head saying ‘i hate him, i hate him’. Yeah, that’s exactly the experience I’m looking for when I listen to the radio.

And Waldmen is just beyond horrible. Rich got it right by saying that all she does is repeat what she hears others say. Just the same cliched baseball sayings and descriptions over and over. But I disagree with Rich in saying she was a better reporter. I hated her even more because you actually had to look at her while listening to her annoying voice. And unfortunately, since Waldmen is the biggest fangurl ever, and Sterling is “the voice”, I have a feeling our kids will be listening to these joksters.

I cannot listen to Sterling. Just can’t. I’ve heard Waldman explain crap to Sterling that he should know. She’s not great but he’s just horrible. I hate Kay too but I can listen to him for the most part even if he makes me cringe a lot but Sterling is completely un-listenable.

If only Scooter could come back “There’s the throw, there’s the play at the plate…”

Now there was an announcer.

THANK YOU!!! Sterling and Waldman are really, really hard to listen to! My father and I cannot stand it. He has a synchronized homerun call for every player, Melkman delivers, Bobby Abreu is sweet as candy (that one is also very weird), An A-Bomb, etc… My girlfriend has to watch me rub my head in my hands in disgust any time the Yankees do anything positive because I can’t stand the radio call.

Hawk is the worst announcer ever. I know sterling is a bit of a homer, but Hawk takes the cake. In game 1 he was whining like a lil girl when the yanks were gettin a bunch of bloops and lucky hits. He is the only announcer i know who actually thinks hes apart of the team. He incoroporates ‘we’ as if hes somehow on the team. I cant listen to hawk call games ne more, if I have to hear one more ‘he gone’ for a strikeout i might melt down my laptop into bullets and shoot hawk in the face.

After listening to those 2 ChiSox idiots the last few days, I don’t think anyone can be as bad as them

Give me the former players who have announced for the Yankees any day. Although I don’t necessarily agree with them, I can actually learn something from Singleton, Cone, Leiter, et al, and I miss Jim Kaat. He had more baseball smarts in his pinky that Sterling, Waldman, and Kay rolled together.

Sterling is awful but Mushnik is awfuller. I am just relieved that Melky’s HR call isn’t “Melk Melk Lemonade! Round the corner fudge is made.”

When you are reduced to following the Yankees on the radio, you are not listening to a Yankee game, you’re listening to Sterling barely watch the game. The Yankees do their fans a complete disservice by having these two call games.

It’s bad enough that they are injecting Advertisements every 15 seconds, but when something happens (a bobbled ball for instance) Sterling can barely follow the play. He fumbles and stutters his way through the call and then watches the replay to actually describe it.

My guess is George likes Sterlings (and Waldmans) style and that’s why he is here. There can’t be any other honest reason that we have to put up with it.

i am forced to listen to them zas i leave work at 7 and have an hour and a half drive and its heinous/.

the reason i stopped in the first place is susan waldmen she is the worst announcer ive ever heard and should be shot on sight like scuzzlebutt.

john sterling wasnt bad when he pandied to kay way back in the day but that could also be because i was only like 10 and my iq and inteligence levele was far below what it is nbow. as it stands now, i cant stand it anywhere yes, or the radio cause michael kay is awful too. I watched the game theother day and it was only coney and singleten and it was the best called game all year. O’neill is good too. Him and cone talk baseball, the science of hitting, the science of pitching, and its funny to hear cone talk about how tupid pitch counts are

if i hear michael kay say one more time “david u pitched a perfect game out of a rain delay did you not?”

or

“david you threw 147 pitches against the mariners in that 95 game right?”

i think ill drive to the stadium to slap him around myself….

This is by no means an endorsement of Sterling and I had no real issue with this until you actually cited Phil Mushnick, who is possibly the biggest waste of you know what on earth. I really haven’t read anything he has written in close to six years. He is the lowest of all these so called sports “journalists” because he acts as if his column in the post is a pulpit. I’m tired of the media and more importantly sports writers telling me about right and wrong morally. THE WORST. John Sterling now took a step up in my opinion

Sterling/Waldman aren’t perfect, but you get used to them. Re: Phil Mushnick-it’s very easy for him to criticize everyone else’s job (he does it often), but I’d like to see him do better. Put it this way: Sterling could probably do a decent job writing a newspaper column. I doubt Mushnick could be half the announcer Sterling is, warts and all.

It was much better when it was Sterling/Steiner. Either way, Sterling is not one of the best, but still far from the worst.

I would like to open voting on the worst sports columnist. I nominate Phil Mushnick, for that drivel that he tried to pass off as a sports column.

I have to say, people who have never listened to other announcers really should take a step off criticizing John Sterling. He’s not half as bad as other guys.

Now, he’s definitely not as good as the best, Harry Kalas, Vin Scully, etc. but I have heard some pretty horrible announcers and Sterling actually kind of has a little charm.

He isn’t -that- bad of a homer… I think he’s just really impressed by baseball players, because he talks glowingly about lots of players. He doesn’t really embarass himself that much by saying stupid or racist things (which many announcers seem to do), and his anecdotes are generally relevant and quirky, and the man has a great memory for baseball, and he never misses a game.

His nicknames are campy and stupid, and the “It is high… it is far… it is… off the wall! Oh my!” calls are kind of dumb, but really not as bad as some of the drivel you have to put up with when watching mlb.tv or gameday audio. I want to kill myself every time Ron Santo talks because he’s such a whiny bitch.

As for Suzyn…. ugh.

I have actually heard this call:

“it is high, it is far, it is…caught by Derek Jeter in shallow left!”

Its unbelievable how consistently wrong he is about home-run calls. Other than that he has a sort of glorified, old baseball man mentality that I really disagree with but he is much easier to listen to than say…the guys who broadcast for the White Sox. Anyone remember a guy named Tim McCarver? Oh right he’s still working on FOX. I maintain that he is the worst on-air personality of any kind. I absolutely hate the man. On the whole, I mind John Sterling a whole lot less than I loathe Suzyn Waldman…she sucks. Basically, sports announcers are a distraction from the game, the greats are a lot of fun but there don’t seem to be a lot of new people stepping in to inherit the duties that are all that pleasant to listen to.

If there is a worse baseball announcer than John Sterling, I don’t want to know about it. I know it’s hard to believe but his home run call of non home runs is not the worse thing he does, as a matter of fact, it’s not even close.

How about the fact that he never shuts up not even for a second. How about his endless lectures on baseball strategy, his nicknames for every player, his moronic laugh. Anyone ever time him to see how long he can go without giving the score!

John doesn’t broadcast the game, he broadcasts what he thinks of the game.

The strange thing about John, he’s has never been any good. I don’t know how we got into this position in the first place. His contract has another three years to run!

I go back with the Yankees and I know what bad is, I remember when Fran Healy did the games on radio, John makes those days seem like the golden age of Yankee broadcasts.

CBS radio, deliver us from this evil. Amen.

Word is that they had to make the broadcast booth at the new Stadium twice as big as the old because Sterling has been having trouble squeezing his enormous ego through the door. Not only do I hate that clown but I hate anyone who finds him tolerable. If he was hit by a bus tomorrow I’d feel sorry for his family but rejoice for Yankee fans. That jackass and Waldman, a Red Sox fan masquerading as a Yankee announcer, should do us all a favor and just retire.

Ever since Sterling took over in the booth whats the Yanks record and how many titles do they have?

Yea, I think he’s ok.

What follows is only partially relevent to the discussion and is a bit of stream of conciousness…

The thing about Sterling is not only does his actual craft suck but so does his voice. When I hear a play-by-play guy calling a game, I want to hear a guy’s voice who either 1) smoked three packs of Marlboro Reds a day for 30 years or 2) is from the South of Midwest. The ideal candidate would have done both.

That being said, personally, I find those announcers that have a background in hockey do very well in baseball. For better or for worse, I love hearing games that Gary Thorne calls- he just has a good voice. On Sundays I used to make a trek every week from Seattle to Okanogan, WA- for those who have never been to Okanogan, WA, do not got there. The population density is 8 people per square mile- which puts it above the average population density for the stateof Alaska but below that of North Dakota.

But it is a four hour drive of absolute desolutness and one of the few things Iwould enjoy on the drive was ESPN Sunday night baseball with Gary THorne and Dave Campbell. It got to the point where I would turn the sound down on the TV when I was at home and listen to themon the radio rather than having to listen to Morgan and Miller.

In short, Sterling sucks.

sometimes you dont have a choice and since its the only broadcast of yankees games i can get..ill take waldman and sterling…also,,,they are very informative…the announcers i hate are buck and mc carver.very naltional league rooters…like the cardinals..its very obvious…ill take waldman and sterling any day over them….