Yanks’ 30th round pick, #920 overall


With their 30th round pick, the Yanks selected Ben McMahan, C, Bishop Moore HS (Fl.)

Scouting Report: Known as a defense first catcher, McMahan also has a potent bat and runs very well for a catcher. His defense is Gold Glove caliber, and he could blossom into a .280-.350-.420 hitter. He’s a strong student and committed to Florida. Here’s his scouting video.

My Take: Great pick. Let’s hope they keep him away from the Gators.

Outlook: If they sign him, we won’t see him in any games until 2009 because it’ll likely go don to the wire. He could survive a full season assignment next year based on his defense alone.

Categories : Draft


  1. Lanny says:

    A strong student and he chooses Florida??

    Now that doesn’t make much sense

  2. Mike A. says:

    Damn yo, McMahan got down the line from the right side in ~4.5 seconds in his scouting video. That’s insanely fast for a catcher.

  3. Joey says:

    Gilespie just drilled one out. First pitch too.

  4. Lanny says:

    Im guessing this is one of the few sign ability guys from Day 2.

  5. Miles Roche says:

    Mike, if you would comprise a Top Prospects List of the Yankees draftees (only) thus far, who would make out the top 5?

  6. Jamal G. says:

    Chris Britton pulled a rib cage muscle warming up in the bullpen yesterday afternoon, was put on the DL and Dan Giese was recalled to Scranton. Got this just this second from Michael Kay on his radio show.

    • Mike N (Stamford, CT) says:

      I guess that is why Girardi hates fat relievers…

    • Joey says:

      Girardi must be smoking his victory cigar right about now. He got fatty out with out having to send Britton down himself.

      Do you think Giese will be used as a reliever or is here to follow Joba still as the long man?

  7. Jamal G. says:

    Adam Westmoreland, was that the same Westmoreland everyone was talking about or was it that oher one drafted yesterday?

  8. Anthony says:

    What’s with Boston taking ten million high school arms?

  9. Reggie C says:

    Red Sox are loading up on insurance plans if they can’t sign Casey Kelly. At least that’s how i hope it plays out. If they sign Meyer , the red sox draft automatically vaults over the Yankees.

    This Westmoreland kid is a major signability issue. But it sorta reminds me of their Lars Anderson pick. And they managed to sign him.

    • Lanny says:

      No way the Sox take Kelly in Rd 1 if he wouldnt sign.

    • Mike A. says:

      Westmoreland, Meyer and Marquis are going to take well over a million dollars each to sign, Marquis and Meyer over $2M. They won’t sign them all, more than likely just one (probably Westmoreland).

      • Reggie C says:

        Mike A,
        Don’t forget to add Ricky Oropesa to that list. What the Red Sox is doing is mind-boggling if their goal is to sign 1 of these 4 kids. Its the Oropesa pick that sorta reminds me of the Lars Anderson pick. California kid with plus raw power but who swings and misses alot too.

        Could it be that the Sox know they aren’t players for Yorman Rodriguez?? Yanks haven’t drafted 1 impact bat. Do you guys think signing Yorman would make up for it?

        • Mike A. says:

          Corban Joseph and Chris Smith are potential impact bats. I have no idea who Y-Rod is, sorry.

          • Jamal G. says:

            Y-Rod is one of the big names (probably second behind Michael Inoa) for this upcoming July 2nd IFA signing period. He is an OF from Venezuela, said to have grades of 70s on the 20-80 scouting scale in the speed and power department.

  10. Lanny says:

    Who are the international free agents we should keep an eye on for July 2?

    • Mike A. says:

      No idea, I don’t worry about those guys until they sign. There’s too much BS on the net about those guys. It’s like that there’s so little info available about them, that whatever little bit we know gets extrapolated out and the hype because immense.

    • The Fallen Phoenix says:

      The two I keep reading the most about are Michael Inoa, a tall 16 year-old flamethrower who some say is the next Felix Hernandez, and Yorman Rodriguez, who supposedly grades at or above a 70 in speed and power.

      • Reggie C says:

        I agree with Mike A. — there is alot of BS out there. That’s why i’m iffy on Inoa. Look at what happened with Salcedo. Indians pulled that offer on the mounting evidence that this kid is NOT his listed age. Salcedo is an old name .. .ahem .. he’s not a hot property anymore.

        Maybe the book on Y-Rod is more accurate. Venezuelan baseball pple keep better records. Jesus Montero turned out well (so far)…

        Go with Y-Rod.

      • Lanny says:

        Isn’t Salcedo supposed to run like Mantle, throw like Mays, hit like Williams, and have the grace of Joe D???


        I’ll have to check out Inoa and Yorman. Sound like top 10 guys to me.

  11. Jamal G. says:

    Get this guys, you remember the recent crane crash in NYC? Well, Ryan Church being a class act offered some aid to the widow of one of the victims but she refused it because “Don [Leo, her husband] was a die-hard Yankee fan,” [Janine] Belcastro said in a statement. “It would not respect his memory if he accepted this.”


    I don’t know what to say, like seriously.

  12. The Fallen Phoenix says:

    …did the Yankees just drop out of the draft?

  13. Mike A. says:

    Did they seriously just drop out???

  14. The Fallen Phoenix says:

    In the 36th round? Really? What the Hell just happened? Technical difficulties? Too lazy to just throw their last few picks on the signability guys just so no one else can take a flier on them? This is mind-boggling.

    • Anthony says:

      Looks like it could bbe technical difficulties, because the tracker skipped over their number, instead of putting Cleveland there.

  15. Jamal G. says:

    Expect audio from a conference call between Gerrit Cole, Damon Oppenheimer and NYY beat writers “close to game time” from PeteAbe’s blog.


  16. Jamal G. says:

    They didn’t drop out, I heard them call in a pick. I’m not going crazy…

  17. Lanny says:

    They wouldnt drop out. Right??

  18. The Fallen Phoenix says:

    From NYYFans:

    “No they didn’t, they took Chris Dwyer from the Salisbury School in Connecticut…

    Dwyer is a signability pick. Clemson recruit…”

    Thank God.

    • Mike A. says:

      Phew, glad they didn’t drop out. Dwyer’s got a HUGE arm. 92-93 with a hammer breaking ball. He’ll be a DES in 2 years, so he has a little extra incentive to go to the school. Going to be a very tough sign.

  19. The Fallen Phoenix says:

    And they just selected Justin Harper, RHP from Yavahai.

  20. Lanny says:

    I assume you guys will be doing a nice sized review of the selections.

  21. J-Gao says:

    Whew, I was looking at the Draft Tracker, and thought WTF?!?!

    I might be the only one, but this draft is somewhat disappointing. They passed up on a lot of signability guys that I would’ve liked to see an attempt at.

    Guys like Gose, Meyer, Shreve, Seaton, Melville, Landers, H-Martinez, Jordan Danks -Gose went in the 50′s (still would’ve liked him more than Bleich), but the rest either went late 100′s, 200′s, and even 500′s.

    Maronde better not fall through either.

  22. Mike A. says:

    The D-Backs just drafted Jesse Orosco. The Cards also took Scott Boras’ son Shane a round or two ago.

    • Joey says:

      is he represented by daddy Boras or does Scott only accept good players and turns down his sons request? Because if there is one person in the world I could see doing that it’s Scott

  23. NYFan50 says:

    Dumb question, but what does DES stand for?

  24. J-Gao says:

    Draft-eligible sophomore

  25. Mike A. says:

    Good grief, did they really just take a 5th year senior? Why not just sign him as an UFA tomorrow?

  26. NC Saint says:

    Why doesn’t the greatest baseball player of all time, Pat Venditte, get his own post?

    We better sign him this time. I’m not sure I can live through the disappointment all over again.

    • Mike A. says:

      I’ve posted enough on Venditte, plus I’ve kinda burnt out. He’s a senior, so it’s either sign and give this baseball thing a shot, or get a real job.

  27. Mike A. says:

    Dammit, Angels grabbed Roach right before the Yanks’ pick.

  28. Joey says:

    Buster’s little brother PH now. Freshman.

  29. L says:

    Is it just me or have the Yanks taken a lot of ss?

  30. J-Gao says:

    Why has no one drafted Nick Maronde yet?

  31. Jamal G. says:

    That’s the second time the Angels have taken a damn great prospect right before us.

  32. Mike A. says:

    Sam Mende, I know that name … might be a signability guy, can’t remember.

  33. Jamal G. says:

    Coco Crisp, Jon Lester and Sean casey have been suspended by MLB for 7, 5 and 3 games respectively.

    • Jamal G. says:

      It seems the incident between Kevin Youkilis and Manny Ramirez started because Youk was mad that Manny did not put up for his teammates during the fight. It seems Manny walked away from the fracas after the bullpen guys came in and Youk got into it with Manny over that.

    • Mike A. says:

      Coco called the Rays a bunch of little girls after the game last night.

    • L says:

      music to my ears…possibly the best thing to hear all day (although Hawkins suspended 3 games ranks up there…don’t want to see that guy come out of the bullpen and blow more games)

    • Sciorsci says:

      How did Jon Lester manage to avoid a suspension? Yankees pitchers throw up and in, fail to actually hit the batter, and twice got suspended. Lester hits two Rays – the two guys most prominently involved in the fight who were not ejected – and gets neither ejected or suspended? WTF?

      And I think Coco’s deserving of even more than 7 games. He knew it was coming – he asked for it, literally, after his hard slide into Iwamura – and it wasn’t like it was upstairs; he had to know he was going to get hit, and he got it in the thigh, which, all things considered, is not so bad. If he’d have just gone on down to 1B, the score would have been settled. Instead, he had to overreact to a HBP that he knew he was going to get.

      I have to say, I actually admire the fire that the Rays are playing with this year.

      • Sciorsci says:

        Forget it – just saw Lester in the suspension list. I’m an idiot, as usual.

      • JT says:

        Madden is a freakin hypocrit. They break our catchers wrist, in spring training no less, and act like its no big deal. I’m glad they got into that brawl yesterday. I hope they get whats coming from them.

        Except I hope nothing happens to crawford, he’s on my fantasy team.

  34. L says:

    why do the mets follow slot? they are a big market team…throw some money into the draft perhaps?

  35. L says:

    did the angels opt out of the draft already?

  36. Mike A. says:

    Clint Preisendorfer? No way. Holy crap moly. That just made my day. Haha.

  37. L says:

    Who has the biggest scouting department in mlb? Red Sox? Yankees? Do you know?

    • Jamal G. says:

      Peter Gammons is so all knowing that he has the knowledge of how many scouts each and every single organization employs. Therefore he was able to make this statement yesterday “The Red Sox employ more scouts than anybody else in baseball”.

      I don’t like that man. Adam Foster from Project Prospect is right, he is too old for TV. The man can not speak a clear, legible sentence and his homerism is just embarassing now.

  38. Joey says:


  39. Sciorsci says:

    Maronde’s off the board to Oakland. Think Billy Beane’s just keeping him away from the big markets who might have thrown some money at him?

  40. Anthony says:

    No chance Oakland signs him right?

    • Sciorsci says:

      Kind of a smart move by Beane. He can’t play the signability game like the big markets, but he can use those picks to play keep-away. I wonder if any of the big markets had any intention at all of taking him late – if so, why let him get THAT late into the draft. I was actually wondering if some slot team might use a pick on him just to keep him out of the big market systems. I didn’t expect it to be Oakland though, because of the value they place on their draft picks.

  41. Mike A. says:

    Oh well. Maybe we’ll be lucky and get Maronde with our first round pick in 2011.

  42. J-Gao says:

    Did the A’s just get Maronde?
    It says John Maronde – I thought it was Nick – but the school’s right?

  43. Jamal G. says:

    San Diego drops out after this pick.

  44. Mike A. says:

    Summers is a nice pick, low-90′s and a ton of power in his bat. Better off going to college and playing in a two-way role.

  45. Jamal G. says:

    Can’t criticize the Yankees because of their recent draft history and the fact that we do not know as much as the Yankees do about these players. Still would have been nice to have Tim Melville, Jamie Mallard, Nick Maronde and Danny Webb.

    Steve Phillips said that the Manny/Youk ordeal isn’t as little as other ESPN analysts are making it out to be. Finally, some sensible ESPN commentary.

  46. Joey says:

    has Dicharry gone yet?

  47. Joey says:

    Taylor Hightower went 1277 to Colorado

  48. Andy in Sunny Daytona Beach says:

    Has Summers ever heard of weight transfer?

  49. Jamal G. says:

    Chris Dwyer (the pick that suffered technical difficulties) seems to be a very, very sexy name. Sweet.


  50. L says:

    On the draft thing on mlb.com venditte is listd as a rhp…will he be switch pitcher in pro or will he be allowed to pitch with both arms

  51. Andy in Sunny Daytona Beach says:

    I guess the Padres draft specialist wanted to beat traffic in Orlando,

  52. Mike A. says:

    The Jays took some kid named Nate Nelson from Worchester State a few rounds ago. He’s 6’6″, 300 lbs. Here’s his picture:


    I, for one, am terrified. Let’s hope he never makes the bigs.

    • Jamal G. says:

      There is nothing that would please me more than seeing Curt SChilling hit this kid with a Fastball. Oh man!

      • Mike A. says:

        He seems like the kind of guy that would refer to himself in the third person.

        “Nate Nelson doesn’t like that you hit Nate Nelson with a fastball. You made Nate Nelson angry.”

    • Joey says:

      I’m with you, I will not fuck with the Jays anymore! And just think, if baseball doesn’t work out he can go bar hopping with those drunk Canadians

  53. Joey says:

    Thank God only a few more rounds. I don’t know how much more of this I can stand in 2 days :-) Mike, if I ever meet you in some random Chipotle in NY you have to tell me so I can buy you a beer and burrito (btw you’ll never find me n a Chipotle and maybe twice a year in NY)

  54. Jamal G. says:

    What is the more common misconception, Steve Phillips trading away Scott Kazmir or Adam Dunn being a bad baseball player?

  55. Lanny says:

    How can Steve Phillips analyze a baseball draft? Does he have scouting reports of most players? Has he seen them play? How does he know what certain teams were targeting? This isn’t the NBA or the NFL. And even in those leagues you need 3 years before you grade a teams draft. MLB you need 5.

  56. Jamal G. says:

    Which is the more common misconception, Steve Phillips trading away Scott Kazmir or Adam Dunn being a bad baseball player?

  57. Andy in Sunny Daytona Beach says:

    This is pretty much the “Future PE Teacher” portion of the draft.

  58. Mike A. says:

    The Phils just drafted Giovany Soto.

  59. Andy in Sunny Daytona Beach says:

    Giovany Soto – 6’4″ 150? lbs. Wow.

  60. Big B says:

    Any good sports bars near Park Slope that I can catch tonight’s game at?

    • Mike A. says:

      Man, you’re late by like, 5 minutes. I could have asked Ben, he lives around there.

      • Big B says:

        Ahh, I just moved there from the UES and am hoping to find a local place…. Nice job on blogging the draft by the way.

    • Jamal G. says:

      Hey I was over there just a couple days ago. They have a fantastic Thai food restaurant, just a couple blocks down from the F-Train station. Believe it is called Thai Rice Kingdom.

      As to your question, sorry, no idea.

  61. Mike A. says:

    What the hell, the Pirates have grabbed a bunch of signability guys. They’re not going to try and actually do something right, are they?

    • Lanny says:

      My theory? The Pirates are going to prove a point here and not sign any of them.

      How pissed would ever exec that got a call from Coonelly be if he overpays for 5 guys?

      Doesnt make sense. He has to have some people still at MLB headquarters. He ran their porgram for yrs!

      • Sciorsci says:

        Interesting theory, but it does make you wonder if a small market team really benefits from proving a point. I mean, if they’re not going to pay their established players, and they’re not going to acquire veteran free agents, they can only improve their team through the draft. If they waste too many picks trying to prove their point, they only end up being a martyr for the current system. Point proven? Maybe, but at what expense?

  62. Andy in Sunny Daytona Beach says:

    Arizona just drafted the Maggi. How unfair.

  63. Mike A. says:

    Did they just pick a kid from Fairleigh Dickinson? Wow, I didn’t know they had a baseball team.

  64. Andy in Sunny Daytona Beach says:

    White Sox just drafted a guy who is listed at 5’5″. How tall is he really?

  65. Mike A. says:

    Rob Scahill’s a nice pick, he’s got a real live arm. DES, so he’ll be a tough sign.

  66. J-Gao says:

    Patrick White – he’s the football player, right?
    Can teams draft any random person, even if they don’t play baseball?

    • Mike A. says:

      Yes, but the team has request a Commisioner’s number for him so they can draft. You can’t be drafted unless you’re in MLB’s database.

      • J-Gao says:

        Oh, I’d like to see a team draft a guy like Derrick Rose or Michael Beasley just for the fun of it.

        And then sign him away from basketball with a huge contract. :)

  67. The Fallen Phoenix says:

    In response to the Pirates question: they have some damned good organizational minds running things over there, now. It’s going to take a couple of years to completely turn their system around, but management is definitely on the right track; resisted selling low on their few valuable trade assets (like Jason Bay) over the winter, and have had a solid draft all things considered.

Leave a Reply

You may use <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> in your comment.

If this is your first time commenting on River Ave. Blues, please review the RAB Commenter Guidelines. Login for commenting features. Register for RAB.