Apr
11

Game 5: Girardi keeps balancing the lineup

By

In Spring Training, Joe Girardi said that he’d find enough at bats for Nick Swisher, who lost the right field competition — though it wasn’t really a competition — to Xavier Nady. Swish sat on the bench for the opener and Game 2, but came on strong in Games 3 and 4. To make sure that Swish continues to get at bats, especially while he’s hot, Girardi has slotted him in left field for Johnny Damon tonight.

This is the kind of balance Girardi will have to find all season. Sometimes he’ll have to go with the hot hand, but if everyone’s hitting it’s going to be a tough balance. The early indication, though, is that he knows what he’s going to do. That’s all we can ask for at this point.

Here’s the big question: if Hideki puts up another 0-for today, does he get another day off tomorrow? He has just one hit and no walks in 10 plate appearances, and that he’s hitting in the middle of the order doesn’t help his case. HIs at bats haven’t looked particularly good either, as he’s trying to pull a lot of outside pitches and has been stepping in the bucket with a frequency you’d like not to see in a major leaguer. It’s early, and I have complete faith that Hideki will come around and help the lineup. For the time being, though, it might be better to stick with the guys who are hitting, which includes Nick Swisher.

Brett Gardner gets the start again tonight, which is slightly surprising at first glance. Girardi stressed that Melky Cabrera didn’t lose the center field battle, and with a lefty on the mound it would seem a prime opportunity to get him at bats. Yet Melky is demonstrably worse as a righty hitter — .648 OPS over his career vs .725 as lefty. One has to wonder, then, how Girardi will work him into the lineup…if he does at all.

Lineup:

1. Derek Jeter, SS
2. Nick Swisher, LF Johnny Damon, LF
3. Mark Teixeira, 1B Nick Swisher, 1B
4. Hideki Matsui, DH
5. Jorge Posada, C
6. Robinson Cano, 2B
7. Xavier Nady, RF
8. Cody Ransom, 3B
9. Brett Gardner, CF

And on the mound, No. 52, Carsten Charles Sabathia

Late Update by Mike: Kat O’Brien is reported that Mark Teixeira is out of the lineup with a sore left wrist. Swisher slides in at first and Damon will man left after all. It’s probably just a precaution, he’s been driving the ball pretty well the last few days.

Categories : Game Threads

373 Comments

  1. Spaceman.Spiff says:

    I would’ve liked to see Jeter-Cano-Swisher-Tex if Tex were healthy and Damon was sitting but this works too.

  2. Drew says:

    Papelbonbon up on the ropes!

  3. El Generalissimo says:

    Not good if Tex is out a few days the lineup gets shorter and shorter… AROD WHERE ARE YOU!?

  4. zack says:

    How did Rivera not bunt there: no outs, down by 1, bottom of the 9th, runner on 2nd. Ugh

  5. LosingOurHeads says:

    Good to see Girardi is comfortable with this balancing act.

  6. Everyone on LoHud is ready to jump off a bridge. It makes my head hurt.

  7. pat says:

    This is why Angels fans are pussies. If this was Yankee Stadium the place would be absolutely rocking right now.

  8. Should the Angels pinch run for Napoli now?

  9. Steve O. says:

    There’s nothing more that I hate to see than that douchebag Papelbon celebrate.

    Here’s to hoping he doesn’t.

  10. manimal says:

    Pap blows saves in bunches, so even if he doesnt blow it today he will suck the next couple appearences

  11. Eric says:

    How has he not thrown a slider yet to Kendrick?

  12. Drew says:

    “Great confrontation here” does he mean AB? lol

  13. How many pitches can you foul back, Howie Kendrick?

  14. pat says:

    Damn, too bad, he hit that pretty well.

    • Brooklyn Ed says:

      Rivera should had bunt. if they were facing the Yanks, Mike would had Rivera bunt. WTH!!!!

  15. zack says:

    Ugh, what a wasted 9th inning, thanks for blowing your own rally Angels…

  16. Hah! That Imus commercial was pretty funny even I think that guy is gross.

  17. Mike says:

    “The New York Times says that Troy Glaus told investigators he injected himself once every four days with the steroids nandrolone and testosterone starting in November 2003 and continuing for three months.”

  18. Andy In Sunny Daytona says:

    The Lakeland Flying Tigers have a pitcher named Furbush.

    I’m so juvenile.

  19. pat says:

    Ah yes, a crappy journeyman lefty. I SMELL SHUTOUT!!

  20. Ooh, I picked the right moment to flip the channel.

    Jeter still doesn’t look very good at the plate, btw.

  21. So Kay just said Teixeira couldn’t hit right-handed. He took four swings and shut it down. That’s a bit more serious-sounding that just a sore wrist.

  22. Drew says:

    Anyone catch the ’96 home opener on YES today? It was funny seeing A young Damon and Jetes on the same field.

  23. UWS says:

    Wait, Andy Pettitte “really used to throw hard”? When?

  24. pat says:

    I really didn’t know that swisher was such a round-o. I always thought he was more svelte.

  25. Drew says:

    I <3 Swish, this years Abreu + power + defense – some hits.

  26. Mike Axisa says:

    I heart Nick Swisher.

  27. Matsui just looks flat awful at the plate right now.

  28. Get. Matsui. Out. of. the. Cleanup. Spot.

    I’m not even advocating benching him. Just…not hitting him fourth right now!

  29. Soylent Green is Sheeple says:

    damn, thought that might drop

  30. Good uniforms:

    Yankees
    Royals
    Cubs
    Orioles
    Phillies
    Nationals (as long as you exclude the ridiculous alternate unis)
    Tigers
    A’s
    Dodgers
    Reds (even though they’ve done some off the wall shit, I like the current unis, even the alternates)
    Rays (last year’s redesign was a PHENOMENAL improvement, those old duds were bottom-10 of all time)

    Bad uniforms:

    Padres (ugh)
    Blue Jays
    New Blue Sox grays
    Braves (Home whites are fine; roads and alternates suck)
    Indians
    Astros
    D-Bags
    Rangers
    Mets
    Rockies

    (Pirates would have made the list, but they apparently wisely scrapped those ghastly red vest alternates.)

  31. Drew says:

    Hip Hip!

  32. Posada has a bad shoulder?

    Since when?

  33. Signing Willie Bloomquist made sense… why, again?

  34. Mike Axisa says:

    Willie Bloomquist is an igniter.

  35. Brooklyn Ed says:

    Posada strikes again!! :D

  36. zack says:

    I love that gameday is telling me that Jorge Posada “loves to face” the changeup (really, the change? does he sit on it or something?), and pretty much every ML hitter hates the slider.

    • zack says:

      And right as I type that, he doubles on a changeup!

    • Joey says:

      it’s early in the season, I have a feeling it compiles stats as it goes, so it’ll probably be much more accurate later in the season. He probably hit a few change-ups so it assumes he likes it the best

  37. Soylent Green is Sheeple says:

    c’mon RIPPER!

  38. Joey says:

    I heart Posada. Great fantasy backup while Mauer’s on the DL

  39. Chip says:

    I missed Posada a lot

  40. Wolf Williams says:

    Speaking of ‘available to play defense,’ did anyone catch Girardi on Francesa on Friday afternoon? Francesa asked Joe G. about why the team kept Pena as the 25th player. Girardi said the expected, but then said, “He can play defense late. We were able to give Jeter two innings off (in Baltimore on Thursday).”

    Interesting that he mentioned Jeter and ‘rest’ in the same breath as mentioning Pena and “play defense late.” The coded message: We’ve reached the point where Jeter is officially a liability in a close game after the 7th inning.

    The movement of Jeter off of short is underway.

    (I’m ducking my head in preparation for vehement disagreement here…..)

  41. Steve O. says:

    Clutchiness:Jorge Posada::Gritiness:Dustin Pedroia

  42. Dammit Cano. I’m trying to beat “NY Highlanders,” and YOU’RE NOT HELPING THE FUCKING CAUSE.

  43. pat says:

    I wouldnt mind having coco crisp on our team.

  44. Chip says:

    Is it just me or does this ump have a tiny strikezone? I mean it’s going great thus far but I’m a bit concerned if CC can’t throw his fastballs for strikes again

    • Chip says:

      And the first fastball thrown right down the middle is called a ball, this could be a long game

  45. Klemy says:

    I love the intensity Swisher has. That man is in to the game.

  46. Drew says:

    2nd pitch for CC. 60 mph. nice damn gun. wtf

  47. Mike Axisa says:

    Yeah … so CC looks fine.

  48. Brooklyn Ed says:

    CC k’s his first batter.

  49. Accent Shallow says:

    Sit down, Chocolatey Breakfast Cereal!

  50. CC with his first strikeout of the year!

  51. Wolf Williams says:

    One batter, Baltimore almost forgotten….

  52. Chip says:

    That’s a horrible lead-off at-bat. It’s one thing to take some pitches but he didn’t swing at any of them and he probably could have gotten a hit on four out of five of them

  53. Mike says:

    If he threw a no-no today the media would still downplay it. If he gets rocked he’s a bust and they have to throw that pricetag in there, but it doesn’t work the other way.

  54. Eric says:

    It really bothers me the way Kay says DeJesus.

    Side Note: The Orioles are bringing it to the Rays again in the first. Break em up

  55. A.D. says:

    DeJesus scouting report: “clutch”

  56. David DeJesus looks like he’s 11 years old.

  57. Brooklyn Ed says:

    Yeah, so I’m predicting 10Ks for CC tonight.

  58. Drew says:

    CC’s so-so start go byebye

  59. What a difference a start makes!

  60. Mike says:

    TEH CC!!!11!!1!

  61. CC looking sharp.

    BTW-I soooo have the hots for the Hillside Honda babe.

  62. Chip says:

    WOW! 12 pitches, 11 fastballs and two strikeouts. He’s going to tear through them the second time around when he decides to actually throw a slider

  63. Soylent Green is Sheeple says:

    what a bust.

    only 2 strikeouts in that inning.

  64. John says:

    Si Si CC!!!

  65. Expired Milk says:

    Fastball is sitting 93-96
    Breaking pitches are hitting the spot.
    I like it I really like it.

  66. Mike Axisa says:

    ZOMG teh heating pad!!1! I don’t like change!11!

  67. Wolf Williams says:

    Will CC wear an ice pack under his shirt in July, or just eat a gallon of ice cream between innings?

  68. dkidd says:

    that hillside honda ad is creepy. it’s obvious those two are related i.e. the niece and nephew of the owner

  69. Heh. I actually have pretty scary burn marks on my abdomen and upper thighs from falling asleep with a heating pad…they’re not as bad as they were, but they’re still pretty, uh, noticeable.

  70. Accent Shallow says:

    X-Ransom-Gardner. Ugh.

  71. Mike Pop says:

    Man, just did Brett dirty.

  72. Andy In Sunny Daytona says:

    JUAN GONE!

  73. Drew says:

    Wow, the bottom of our lineup is atrocious. Brett Gardner better get his ish together or Hellooooo Melkman.

  74. Steve O. says:

    Fact: The bottom of the lineup is less potent than a manwhore.

  75. Best quote of the night re teixeira”

    “Is there anything that guys do with their left hand that makes them happy for their birthday? Something that flexes your wrist in a consistent motion?

    Can’t think of anything.” From LoHud.

  76. Alex S says:

    CC you later

  77. Kevin says:

    CC’s pants are extremely baggy.

  78. dkidd says:

    david cone is awesome

  79. Mike Pop says:

    There goes the perfect game….bust!

  80. Via Twitter, Will Carroll says an injection could be possible for Teixeira if the wrist doesn’t clear up. That’s not really a diagnosis as much as it is a statement of fact. Don’t let that color your view of it.

  81. Chazzy says:

    This ump is in squeeze mode.

  82. dkidd says:

    how smooth is cano?

  83. Rich says:

    I love pitchers who can induce GBs.

  84. CP3 says:

    I smell no hitter!

  85. Wolf Williams says:

    A solid DP is still as sweet to look at as anything on the field. Football has nothing on the double play.

  86. pitcher’s best friend.

  87. Alex S says:

    jeets

  88. Rich says:

    Jeter back to hitting LDs.

  89. Accent Shallow says:

    Why is Willie Bloomquist in RF? Yikes.

  90. Drew says:

    haha, Carter swing a big bat too.

  91. Rich says:

    Take that, Joel Sherman…

  92. “Joba drove here from Nebraska”

    . . . . . . . . .

  93. Jeter got wheels.

    Yeah, I know. That’s a shot at Jeter.

  94. Rich says:

    Kay is too into productive outs.

  95. Eric says:

    Ground balls to the right side with a runner on second makes me happy

  96. Mike says:

    Wait what….since when does Joba have a kid?

  97. Chip says:

    Wow, Yankees playing a bit of small-ball. Now let’s hope Swisher can come through

  98. Alex S says:

    SWISH!

  99. pat says:

    brian cashman.

  100. Brooklyn Ed says:

    Swisher is awesome!!!

  101. SWISH!

    Wow has this guy impressed or what?

  102. Drew says:

    Swisher>>>>The Mick

  103. Mike Axisa says:

    Hah. Willie Bloomquist.

  104. Rich says:

    Swish!

  105. Jonathan says:

    swisher > nady

  106. BigBlueAL says:

    Im still regretting not going to the Marlins-Mets game tonight, post-game concert featured Flo Rida!!!!

  107. Rich says:

    Awesome, Mat.

  108. Wolf Williams says:

    I watch Swisher go for a triple and I think, ‘Ron Cey.’

  109. Mike says:

    I love swisher.

  110. Christopher says:

    Urgh, Matsui looks awful at the plate.

  111. Mike says:

    And then there’s Matsui …

  112. Mike Axisa says:

    Nick Swisher: 11 plate appearances, 5 extra base hits

  113. Brazilian Yankee says:

    Forget the bottom of the lineup, our cleanup hitter has been horrible.

  114. Rich says:

    Po knows SLG.

  115. Jamal G. says:

    Jorge Posada is awesome.

  116. Brazilian Yankee says:

    Posada on the other hand… great!

  117. Accent Shallow says:

    It’s so nice to see this team hitting a soft-tossing lefty, as opposed to the results of the past few seasons.

  118. Wolf Williams says:

    Are we seeing the return of 2007, near-MVP Posada?

  119. VO says:

    I LOVE SWISHER, Posada aint to bad himself.

  120. ShawnT says:

    Matsui really blows!!!!
    How long till giardi puts posada and cano ahead of him
    this fels like a joe torre trust the veteran move

  121. Posada: Shoulder surgery? What’s that?

  122. Chip says:

    So, who was complaining about this lineup being too short with no A-Rod or Tex

  123. BigBlueAL says:

    Biggest reason no playoffs in 2008, no Posada.

  124. Wolf Williams says:

    Do you think Matsui looks awful and Teixeira hurt his wrist because they stayed up all night watching some of Matsui’s ‘collection?’

  125. Chip says:

    So, this might be the most inconsistent strike zone I’ve ever seen.

  126. Yankeegirl49 says:

    Im going to buy my Swisher jersey tomorrow! Maybe Ill see if they will take My matsui one as a trade in :)

  127. No hitter broken up! CC is a bust!

  128. pat says:

    CC’s hat doesn’t have enough gangster lean.

  129. BigBlueAL says:

    Amazing I live in Miami yet cant see the Marlins-Mets game because it isnt on local TV.

  130. Chip says:

    There goes the no no

  131. Rich says:

    Dealin’

  132. Drew says:

    CCya later coco

  133. pat says:

    HAh crisp was walking to the dugout before the ump even signaled.

  134. Brazilian Yankee says:

    96mph FB on the outside corner for strike 3. Beautiful.

  135. Joey says:

    Frozen Four National Championship on ESPN for anyone who cares about hockey. Pretty good game so far

  136. Oh, Ben’s gonna just LOVE this story.

    http://www.nytimes.com/2009/04.....f=baseball

    Let me guess. You’re working on it for the 10PM post.

  137. Drew says:

    C’mon Ransom! I’m confident.

  138. Christopher says:

    Nady remembers it’s a contract year.

  139. John says:

    Nady joining in on the fun

  140. Accent Shallow says:

    Cody fails to hold that for Ransom?

  141. Mike Pop says:

    Oh Cody……..

  142. Rich says:

    Kay’s fair/foul perception is in mid-season form.

  143. Thomas says:

    Conedlestick Park, so sad.

  144. BigBlueAL says:

    If anyone cares, the answer to the trivia question is Gary Gaetti.

  145. pat says:

    My guess for the trivia question is Randy Bush.

  146. Matt says:

    I’m feeling a HR for BG.

  147. Drew says:

    What the hell has happened, I thought Brett liked to walk!

  148. Rich says:

    He was safe.

  149. Drew says:

    Brett=No Grit

    • whozat says:

      More importantly, Brett=no walks.

      He’s not going to hit enough to be useful without walking.

  150. Brazilian Yankee says:

    Matsui, Ransom and Gardner, who’s worse right now?

  151. Mike Axisa says:

    The bottom of the Yanks lineups sucks as much as the middle of Royals lineup.

  152. Wolf Williams says:

    You get the feeling, watching the bottom of this lineup, that it’s a NL West batting order. That could have been the Padres batting to end that half-inning….

  153. Mike Pop says:

    For whoever was poking fun at Kay about Fordham yesterday, that just made it funnier.

  154. Chazzy says:

    What is with Gardners lower half?? Squash the bug ffs this isn’t golf, he’s just flatfooted in there lifting his back toe up.

  155. Wolf Williams says:

    I think CC just ran out of breath chasing that grounder.

  156. BigBlueAL says:

    Tomorrow could be ugly with assuming Molina playing for Posada along with whichever scrub plays 3b and CF. Plus Gil Meche is pitching who is actually a pretty good pitcher.

  157. Matt says:

    Swisher is a “servicable” OF and “underrated” 1B.

    UZR/150 in RF: 9.4
    UZR/150 in LF: 6.7
    UZR/150 at 1B: -3.5

  158. Mike Axisa says:

    Oh good grief, did Kay just do a mid-inning, on-air advertisement? Ugh.

    • pat says:

      Dude those k cups are actually pretty sweet.

    • BigBlueAL says:

      I didnt know WB Mason sold coffee. Actually it used to drive me nuts seeing the WB Mason sign on the Green Monster and at Yankee Stadium cause I had no idea what the hell they were. There isnt no WB Mason down here in Miami.

    • whozat says:

      I suspect that they sponsored strikeouts.

      Boo.

    • Thomas says:

      I would have hated the ad less if he got rid of the horrible “K” lead in.

  159. BigBlueAL says:

    CC da man!!

  160. Rich says:

    As advertised.

  161. Nathan says:

    So, odds on CC going complete game vs. 8 innings?

  162. Tom Zig says:

    Did #9 on the Royals try to trick Cano into chasing him into a run down between 1st and 2nd?