Sep
17

Open Thead Overflow

By

I don’t think we’ve ever had to do this, but that 500+ comment open thread sure is taking a while to load. Keep the party going here.

Categories : Open Thread

179 Comments»

  1. Omar says:

    No Scooter?

    Anyways, while it is way too early to talk about the offseason there’s still concerns about this season to address…I’ll add my piece, if you ask me the Yankees’ priorities next season should be this in order:

    Replacing the production that Damon and Matsui gave the team: Lets face it, Damon and Matsui have exceeded expectations and their production will be missed yet not duplicated by them wherever they land. That being said there’s ways to upgrade here. My plan would be to offer Damon Arbitration or try to get him back to DH and see where that goes, then sign Matt Holliday to play LF. He may not hit as well as Damon has this season, but his improved defense would make up the difference. Plus Posada, Jeter, Cano, Cabrera, and likely Rodriguez are all likely to regress

    John Lackey: Joba Chamberlain proved this season that you can not rely on a young starter, so as much as I like Phil Hughes he can’t be relied on and neither can Chamberlain next season. Pettitte may not be back (addressed next time) and if so he’s still pretty old and may not duplicate his production next season, it sounds like Wang is finished and needs to rehab. AJ Burnett’s been bad, and the Yankees need another reliable starter (one isn’t enough), Lackey’s likely the best available…the only way they acquire someone better is by trading Jesus Montero.

    If Pettitte retires finding another starter, self explanatory.

    Finding a starter to pitch about 130 innings, my preference would be Rich Harden. Hughes is on innings limits, Chamberlain is a massive suck risk…and Harden still has filthy stuff. If everything works out well they can move him to the bullpen.

    Bring back Hinske: he’s been a pretty good bench player…and I’d like to have him back.

    • The Chambliss image is fairly iconic, no?

    • …then sign Matt Holliday to play LF. He may not hit as well as Damon has this season…

      Holliday is going to cost like 15M AAV, bare minimum. Probably 18M.

      For that kind of coin, he damn well better outhit 2009 Damon.

      • Omar says:

        Holliday for 15-18 is something I’d be cool with, Damon is flat out mashing though…it’s gonna be hard to top that.

        • If it was 15-18 for 2-3 years, hell yeah. But, he’s gonna want a 5+ deal and I don’t want the Yankees–and I don’t think they want this–to be locked in at three of four corner spots for long term deals.

    • I say no to Lackey because he wants A.J. money and he shouldn’t get that. Joba’s thrown ~145 innings of league average ball. That’s actually pretty good coming from a 23 y.o. in his first full season of starting. He’s essentially the team’s 4th starter, too, and was the 5th starter coming into this season. If Hughes was going to be expected to be the number two or number three starter next year, then, yes, go get Lackey. However, since he’s currently slotted as the 5th starter (CC/AJ/Pettitte/Joba/Hughes), getting another arm in the rotation–especially one that requires a long term commitment with lots of money–is not something I think the Yankees will look into.

      • Omar says:

        I mean…should AJ get AJ money? Lackey’s been better than Burnett over the past few seasons, so why shouldn’t he get AJ money? I’m awfully uncomfortable with Sabathia/Burnett/Pettitte/Chamberlain/Hughes going into next season. A vet in his late 30s (if he doesn’t retire), two starters with inning limits, and three starters with deep injury history.

        Yikes.

        • Lackey’s been better than Burnett over the past few seasons, so why shouldn’t he get AJ money?

          He probably should. But not from us, because we’re already giving our AJ money to AJ.

          I’m awfully uncomfortable with Sabathia/Burnett/Pettitte/Chamberlain/Hughes going into next season.

          You might be. But Lackey is a horrible overreaction to that uncomfortableness. I was awfully uncomfortable going into 2009 with Melky and Gardner in CF, and while I was ultimately proven wrong, I wanted to assuage my fears with a Mike Cameron stopgap, not with a panic trade for David DeJesus.

          • Omar says:

            Yeah, the Yankees gave AJ a contract that he hasn’t lived up to…and they have the opportunity to give a contract to someone whose averaged a +4 WAR every year he’s been healthy, and only has one injury? I mean..it’s totally unfair to him to compare him to DeJesus.

            • Okay.

              So, if you can go back in time and undo the AJ contract so he’s no longer on our books, I’m totally on board with giving 15M to Lackey.

              Until that happens, no. AJ on AJ money is an okay solution. Lackey on AJ money is an okay solution.

              Both together on AJ money is a bad idea. AJ’s presence on the Yankees precludes signing Lackey. I’d rather sit on the cash and pay Halladay, Lee, Webb, Vazquez, or Hudson the year after that if you absolutely must spend money on someone.

              • Omar says:

                I see where you’re coming from and can respect that. I wouldn’t have a problem with bringing on John Lackey…that’s just me, but waiting for Halladay or Lee seems a bit more prudent. As to Webb, aren’t the Dbacks going to let him loose? I thought I remembered him being talked about as a “Jon Lieber” type of situation.

    • Joba Chamberlain proved this season that you can not rely on a young starter…

      No, he didn’t.

      • Omar says:

        His K/BB is atrocious, and his FIP is 4.69…he’s been getting lucky. He has a tRA+ of 95, which takes into account the park and difficulty of pitching in the AL East. He was as highly touted as they come and he’s been a massive disappointment performance wise. Though, at the end of the day it’s considered a successful season if he stays healthy for the whole season **knock on wood** it’s considered a success.

        • And yet, none of his struggles “proved” that you can’t rely on a young starter.

          Moreso, even if you quibble with that, since it’s a semantic distinction, his struggles most freaking definitely did not prove that we should go pay 31 year old John Lackey any of our precious SteinbrennerBucks.

          Gigantic hells to the no on signing Lackey.

          • Omar says:

            Isn’t: “Gigantic hells to the no” the same position that we had on Burnett this time next season? Furthermore, what has Chamberlain done to instill confidence in his next season’s performance? Was it the decreased velocity? The worse breaking stuff? The declining strikeout rates? The increased walk rates? The dramatically higher LD rates? The lower groundball rates? Or was it the part where he doubled his HR rates?

            • Isn’t: “Gigantic hells to the no” the same position that we had on Burnett this time next season?

              Some of us, yes. And some of the potential reasons we were saying that gigantic hells to the no have already come to pass, to be blunt. You’re not really strengthening your case here.

              Furthermore, what has Chamberlain done to instill confidence in his next season’s performance? Was it the decreased velocity? The worse breaking stuff? The declining strikeout rates? The increased walk rates? The dramatically higher LD rates? The lower groundball rates? Or was it the part where he doubled his HR rates?

              It was the fact that A) he didn’t get hurt B) he’s still Joba Chamberlain, Pitching Prospect Extraordinare, C) he’ll be a year older D) he’ll have no effective innings limit since he’ll pitch around 170-180 IP this year, giving him a cap of 200-210.

              • Omar says:

                Burnett’s actually been a pretty big part of Yankee success…he’s completely boom or bust when it comes to his starts…he’s pitched quite a few HUGE games for the Yankees. I’ve been okay with signing him.

                As to Chamberlain…he didn’t get hurt, I agree that’s a good thing, but nothing about his performance instills confidence in me. Yeah, he’s still Joba Chamberlain…a guy who went from being a Fat Piece of Shit who threw in the mid to high 80s at UNK to one of the most electric pitchers in all of baseball. A pitcher who fell out of the first round because of grotesque injury and conditioning concerns to the number one prospect in all of baseball. He’s had a deep history of not being that great, and there’s plenty in his pedigree to give cause for concern.

    • While I don’t agree with most of what’s set forth here, I have to say, I like the presentation.

      Omar, I’ll be frank. I had a real problem with the way you composed yourself when you first showed up here. I’m glad to see your comments move to civility, and that I can disagree with them without having a conniption. This is the kind of discourse we encourage at RAB.

    • Zack says:

      Rich Harden? Yeah his filthy stuff gives him a 5.1 IP/S and an ERA of 4.09., in the NL

    • JobaWockeeZ says:

      Lackey AND Holliday?
      So you want another AJ contract with a Boras client demanding the world because of his performance in the Cards.

      Forgive me if I find the odds of that happening very slim.

      And of coruse the art of player development must come as a shock to Yankee fans when they don’t get instant gratification. He’s going to start and Hughes is going to start so get used to it now. The Yankees are not going to King Felixes and Tim Lincecums every year even if they get one.

      So let’s let the young pitchers pitch and see them progress because development is not a 2 step thing.

      Many great pitchers sucked in their first years of starting. But apparently if Joba and Hughes aren’t good now they’ll never be.

      • Omar says:

        First off, this isn’t likely…this would be my idea situation.

        Yeah, I know player development takes time, but even when guys like Buchholz struggled they still flashed good stuff and good K-rates…amidst Chamberlain’s struggles just about everything you look for in a young pitcher…Chamberlain hasn’t shown. If he would show signs of progress I wouldn’t have as big of a problem with him.

        • JobaWockeeZ says:

          Buchholz hasn’t pitched the whole year and only has 71 IP. He’s been dominant against team with weak offenses while decent to suckage against better ones.
          http://www.baseball-reference......;year=2009

          He’s had a couple good starts against good teams but it’s a small sample size so meh…

          David Price is another young guy who’s struggling. He’s only at 109 innings but he’s struggling a bit as well.
          http://www.baseball-reference......&year=

          He isn’t exactly tearing it up either.

          And we can’t say we haven’t seen progress based on almost a full year of starting. If there’s no progress for the next season and the next then there’s a problem. He’s 23 and great pitchers today sucked at his age.

          Hughes is even younger. We can’t give up on these guys just yet.

          • Omar says:

            Buchholz and Price both have a better pedigree than Chamberlain, and both have still flashed their frontline stuff…that’s what concerns me the most about Chamberlain is the weakened stuff.

            Also, where did I say give up on these guys? All I said was don’t count on them and for the love of god don’t depend on both of them in the rotation going into the season; I don’t recall mentioning trading them for a slightly above average major leaguer like a Shin Soo Choo type of player. When Chamberlain’s name was being mentioned in the Roy Halladay talks I was all for a package centered around Chamberlain…I don’t consider that “giving up” on either of them.

            • Buchholz and Price both have a better pedigree than Chamberlain

              That’s highly debatable,

              and both have still flashed their frontline stuff…

              So has Joba.

              • Omar says:

                Buchholz maybe, Price was the number one pick in the fucking draft, a highly touted prospect since high school, the number one pitching prospect in all of baseball too, here’s a list of the awards he won in college:

                Baseball America College Player of the Year
                The Golden Spikes Award
                The Roger Clemens award

                Please tell me how Chamberlain had the better pedigree, and please don’t make me defend Buchholz.

                As to “flash frontline stuff” I meant more than once every four outings.

                • Please tell me how Chamberlain had the better pedigree, and please don’t make me defend Buchholz.

                  Never said Chamberlain had the “better” pedigree. Just said he didn’t have the “worse” pedigree.

                  I’d argue that all three have the same pedigree: future aces. But all three were high draft picks with first round grades, all three have multiple plus pitches, all three are future frontline starters. Inside of that, you’re hairsplitting. Whatevs.

                  As to “flash frontline stuff” I meant more than once every four outings.

                  Yeah, but Price and Buchholz don’t do that either.

                  All three are basically the same: future aces who are works in progress. They’ve all shown enough to be given a spot in the rotation; none of them have shown enough that you can give them a spot without a backup plan. But again, that back up plan does not need to be a 15M AAV Type A free agent starter. It should be a Chad Gaudin or a Justin Duchscherer.

                • Omar says:

                  Have you watched Buchholz each time out? Dood looks sick, I hate the guy so I watch his starts to root against him. Gaudin or Duchscherer? Meh…I dunno, I don’t consider Lackey a “back up plan” more of a better option than the ones they currently have.

                  Also, pedigree is the prospect’s history. Buchholz and Price both have much better histories as a prospect than Chamberlain does. ESPECIALLY Price, there is nothing in Chamberlain’s history as an amateur that resembles David Price’s. Chamberlain had more success in one season as a Minor Leaguer, but that doesn’t erase Price’s demonstrably better history as an amateur. Also Price slamming the door on the Red Sox in G7 of the 2008 ALCS makes up some of that ground too.

            • JobaWockeeZ says:

              David Price’s best 2009 start: http://brooksbaseball.net/pfx/.....evDate=829

              Joba Chmaberlian’s best start: http://brooksbaseball.net/pfx/.....evDate=729

              Take a look at velocity. They are nearly the same in their same pitches.

              • Omar says:

                He’s shown it, just not very often…and there’s been other times that he’s pitched like he did back in Kearney. That and given his injury history, it’s cause for concern. I never said that the upside wasn’t still there, just that after this season I think it’s less likely that he reaches his ceiling than I did last year.

                • JobaWockeeZ says:

                  So do you agree Chamberlain has also flashed his frontline stuff?
                  He just hasn’t done it consistently like Buchholz and Price.

                • Omar says:

                  It’s been playing a disappearing act like David Copperfield, and it’s been not there more often than it’s been there. We’ve seen it, just not that often. Which is a cause for concern, not only has his average velocity dipped, the fastball hasn’t shown the same movement that it once did…and the Slider and Curve aren’t getting the big swings and misses that they once did.

                • Zack says:

                  If you payed attention to Price you;d see the same thing.

                  Pre ASB: 44IP 47K 9.6 K9
                  PostASB: 65.2IP 44K 6.0 K9

  2. A spillover open thread? This is definitely a new era.

  3. Tom Zig says:

    First time for everything.

  4. I don’t think we’ve ever had to do this, but that 500+ comment open thread sure is taking a while to load. Keep the party going here.

    Jesus: Normally, I don’t do this, but… [dips finger into water, turning it into wine] go ahead and keep the party going.

  5. Greg G. says:

    http://newyork.yankees.mlb.com.....8;c_id=mlb

    Just from looking at the title of the article, I was hoping for something more creative. Thumb wrestling? Beer pong?

  6. Any word on what the rookie hazing costumes will be this year?

  7. Moshe Mandel says:

    I’m betting Youkilis was not available tonight, and they brought him out on deck just to get them to pitch to Baldelli or something along those lines. If Youk was available, Tito is not that stupid.

  8. A.D. says:

    Wonder if Chad Jennings or Mike Ashmore gets the call from LoHud to interview to replace Pete Abraham

  9. The Artist says:

    “I don’t think we’ve ever had to do this, but that 10″+ thing sure is taking a while to load. Keep the party going here.”

    Are we still talking about Baseball?

  10. From the Pitt the Elder, Lord Palmerston part of the last thread:

    You don’t have to try to set me up for that, Tommie. It’s probably my favorite Simpsons exchange ever. My handle on messages boards is almost always Lord Palmerston.

  11. Charlie says:

    fate of scranton’s season is in the balance right now..

  12. Steve H says:

    Open thread overflow. The power of alex gonzalez’ (umm, trying to be nice) interesting posts shall not be underestimated.

  13. Keanu Reeves says:

    Today in religion class, I spent the entire time contemplating the Yankee farm system.

  14. Salty Buggah says:

    This is hilarious, especially for those who have taken the 1st semester of Spanish:

  15. robert skollar says:

    A lot depends on the post-season.

    But if it has a (fairly) happy ending…
    I think all 3 should be rewarding with generous 1 year deals.
    Perhaps the Yankees should overpay a bit (they do anyway) for these three…for this year and contributions to the team over the years. This will probably be last year on Yanks for each.

  16. Tom Zig says:

    Did the Yanks just flip flop CC and AJ’s starts?

  17. Tom Zig says:

    So when do you guys think we’ll clinch the division?

  18. Dela G says:

    Man i cannot wait for sunday and the JETS vs Pats.

    I laid the +7 on the jets on monday morning

    now the line is Jets +3.5 (at least is was 9pm last night)

  19. A.D. says:

    NBA Refs couldn’t reach an agreement…mistake.

  20. Johan Iz My Brohan says:

    Uhhhh damn it Wordekemper, you suck.

  21. Omar says:

    Onto the other big news of the day: Ham leaving. I view this as an extremely good thing.

    A.) We don’t have to suffer through his arrogance in his reporting and personal vendettas against several people in the organization just to read breaking news.

    B.) The press box at Fenway is likely to collapse under his weight.

    Also, one of Mike, Ben, or Joe need to get a field pass so they can get instant lineup updates as soon as the managers hand them in. While I disagree with several of the commenters here, I still like the blog.

  22. Keanu Reeves says:

    Tune into ESPN Classic immediately if you want to feel creeped out.

  23. Watching SportsCenter: Today’s game against the Tigers was the first time all year Zack Greinke had pitched in the first inning with a lead. This is his 30th start on the year.

    Great googily moogily.

  24. Johan Iz My Brohan says:

    SWB loses =(

  25. Dela G says:

    Scranton W/B just lost 3-2 in 12 innings

    they left 2 men on base with 2 outs in the bottom of the 12th :(

  26. Keanu Reeves says:

    Rats. It was a good season SWB.

  27. Salty Buggah says:

    SWB Yanks lose with runners on 2nd and 3rd and two out while being down one in the bottom of the 12th as Bernier grounded out.

  28. Johan Iz My Brohan says:

    At least next year, SWB gets some ZMac, Montero, and a little more Jackson, that’ll be something to watch.

  29. Salty Buggah says:

    Mariners walk-off celebrations are weak.

    BTW, with them going 14 innings and having to get 8.1 innings out of their, it’ll help us.

  30. “Go fuck yourselves, San Diego” was the “Moment of Zen” on The Daily Show.

  31. younguns says:

    Robinson Cano has played exceptionally well this year, both on the field & at the plate. Cano’s trade value may never get any higher than now.

    If the Yankees were to shop Cano this coming off-season, what could they possibly get in return for him? He is signed through 2011 for $10 million per year, which is affordable when you consider that he is putting up Chase Utley-type numbers this season.

    I ask this because the SF Giants were willing to trade a terrific young starter in Tim Alderson for a soon-to-be 32-year old 2B in Freddy Sanchez. Alderson won’t turn 21 until early November while Sanchez hits 32 at the end of this year.

    I’m especially intrigued at possible top-of-the-rotation prospects such as Alderson. You can still sign bats through free agency. However, other than CC, which other aces have made it onto free agency in the past 5 years while still in their prime?

  32. Kiersten says:

    I can’t respond to the Canes talk in the other thread so here goes:

    HELL YEAH!
    It’s Great to be a Miami Hurrrrricane!

    I love my school. and our football team :)

Leave a Reply

You may use <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> in your comment.

If this is your first time commenting on River Ave. Blues, please review the RAB Commenter Guidelines. Login for commenting features. Register for RAB.