What Happened To All Those Draft Picks? Part Two

Hot Stove Open Thread
Top Prospects Of Decade

Yesterday we took a look at what happened to the draft picks the Yankees forfeited as free agent compensation from 1979 to 1985, and today we’ll continue the series by looking at the picks surrendered between 1986 and 1991. Remember to let me know if there’s any missing/incorrect info in any of the posts in this series.

1986 First Round Pick
Free Agent: Al Holland, LHP
Forfeited Pick: Terry Carr, OF (Angels)
Looking to upgrade their bullpen, the Yankees imported Holland from the Angels, who had a 2.72 ERA in eight previous seasons in the big leagues. Unfortunately, he didn’t produce as expected, putting up a 6.32 ERA in 47 innings in pinstripes. As compensation for losing Holland, the Angels received the 25th overall pick in the 1986 draft, and used it to selected Maryland high school outfielder Terry Carr. Carr never made it out of A-ball, retiring from baseball in 1990 with a .217 AVG and a .284 SLG in 1,510 career minor league plate appearances.

The Halos also received a supplemental first round pick, taking Texas high school righty Daryl Green 28th overall. Like Carr, Green never made it out of A-ball, and was out of the game by 1992 after posting a 4.09 ERA in 105 starts and 68 relief appearances.

1987 First Round Pick
Free Agent: Gary Ward, 1B/OF
Forfeited Pick: Bill Haselman, C (Rangers)
The Yanks brought in Ward off a five year stretch in which he hit .289-.338-.452 with 88 homers and two All Star appearances, though he slumped to a .242-.297-.362 batting line with just 20 homers in a little more than two years in pinstripes. He was cut in late April of 1989. The Yankees sent their first round pick to the Rangers as compensation, and they took UCLA backstop Bill Haselman 23rd overall. Haselman lasted 13 seasons in the big leagues as a backup with the Rangers, Mariners, Red Sox, Rangers (again), Tigers, Rangers (yet again), and Red Sox (again). He retired as a .259-.311-.409 hitter with 47 homers in 1,747 career plate appearances.

The Rangers also received a supplemental first round pick, and used it to take University of Texas righty Mark Petkovsek 29th overall. He bounced around with the Rangers, Pirates, Cardinals, Angels, and Rangers (again) for nine years, putting up a 4.73 ERA  and a 358-222 K/BB ratio in 41 starts and 349 relief appearances.

1987 Second Round Pick
Free Agent: Rick Cerone, C
Forfeited Pick: Curt Krippner, RHP (Brewers)
Two years after trading him to Atlanta for Brian Fisher, the Yankees brought Cerone back as a free agent in 1987 for the second of three stints in the Bronx. He hit .243-.320-.335 with four homers in 327 plate appearances before signing with the Red Sox in the offseason. As compensation for losing Cerone, the Yankees sent the 55th overall pick to Milwaukee, which they used to take University of Texas righthander Curt Krippner. He played four season in the Brewers’ system, putting up a 4.54 ERA with a 374-207 K/BB ratio in 60 starts and seven relief appearances. Krippner was out of baseball by 1992, and didn’t make it out of A-ball.

1988 First Round Pick
Free Agent: Jack Clark, 1B
Forfeited Pick: John Ericks, RHP (Cardinals)
Clark came to the Yankees fresh off a season in which he hit .286-.459-.597 with 35 homers for the Cardinals, earning a spot on the All Star Team and finishing behind only Andre Dawson and Ozzie Smith in the NL MVP race. Clark was productive in his one year with the Yanks, though not as productive as he had been in years past. He hit .242-.381-.433 with 27 homers, and was traded to the Padres in the offseason for a package of three young players.

Meanwhile, the Cardinals received the 22nd overall pick for losing Clark, taking University of Illinois righty John Ericks. He spent seven years in the minors before reaching the big leagues with the Pirates, making 22 starts and 25 relief appearances with a 4.78 ERA and a 132-73 K/BB ratio over the course of three years. With their supplemental first round pick, the Cards took University of Richmond outfielder Brian Jordan 30th overall. Jordan hit .282-.333-.455 with 184 homers in a 15 season big league career.

1988 Second Round Pick
Free Agent: Jose Cruz, OF
Forfeited Pick: Dave Silvestri, SS (Astros)
Signed at the end of his long and extremely productive career, Cruz hit just .200-.273-.263 in 88 plate appearances with the Yanks before being released in late-July. For signing Cruz, the Yankees send the 52nd overall pick to Houston as compensation, and watched the Astros take University of Missouri shortstop Dave Silvestri.

Silvestri was dealt to the Yankees in a minor trade prior to the 1990 season, and made his big league debut with them in 1992. He hit just .192-.315-.411 in parts of three seasons in the Bronx before being traded to Montreal for a minor leaguer. Silvestri managed to last eight years in the big leagues as a utility player, hitting .202-.315-.310 with stops in four different cities after being traded by the Yanks.

1988 Third Round Pick
Free Agent: John Candelaria, LHP
Forfeited Pick: Derrick Warren, OF (Mets)
A longtime Pirate, Candelaria joined the Yankees in 1988 and made 30 starts (and 17 relief appearances) with a 3.80 ERA and a 158-35 K/BB ratio. He was shipped to Montreal during the 1989 season for Mike Blowers. With the 79th overall pick that they received as compensation for losing Candelaria, the Mets draft Florida high school outfielder Derrick Warren. Warren played just one year in the minors – for the Mariners in 1992 – and hit .139-.271-.194 in just 28 games. I have no idea what happened in between.

1989 First Round Pick
Free Agent: Steve Sax, 2B
Forfeited Pick: Kiki Jones, RHP (Dodgers)
After a Rookie of the Year award and an eight year stint with the Dodgers, Sax came to the Bronx for three years and hit .294-.342-.376 with 19 homers. He made the All Star Team twice, and was eventually traded to the White Sox for Melido Perez and two young pitchers named Domingo Jean and Bob Wickman. The Dodgers received the 15th overall pick in the 1989 draft as compensation, which they used to take Florida high school righty Kiki Jones. Jones spent five years in the minors, compiling a 3.74 ERA in 53 starts. He was out of the game for four years before making a brief comeback in the Devil Rays system that saw him post a 5.55 ERA in eight starts and 15 relief appearances.

Los Angeles also received a supplemental first round pick, taking University of Florida righthander Jamie McAndrew 28th overall. McAndrew appeared in eight games (two starts) for the Brewers in the mid-90’s, putting up a 5.98 ERA with a 27-35 K/BB ratio.

1990 Second Round Pick
Free Agent: Pascual Perez, RHP
Forfeited Pick: Tavo Alvarez, RHP (Expos)
Perez started just 17 games in two seasons with the Yankees, though he posted a 2.87 ERA with a 53-27 K/BB ratio when he did pitch. As compensation for losing him, the Expos received the 50th overall pick, using it to take righty Tavo Alvarez out of an Arizona high school. After steadily climbing the ladder, Alvarez reached the big leagues with Montreal in 1995, posting a 5.40 ERA in a short Major League career that lasted just 13 starts and six relief appearances.

With the supplemental first round pick they received, the Expos selected Indiana high school southpaw Ben Van Ryan, who played for four teams despite making just 26 relief appearances (5.74 ERA) in the big leagues.

1991 Second Round Pick
Free Agent: Steve Farr, RHP
Forfeited Pick: Ryan Long, 3B (Royals)
The Yankees got three productive years out of Farr, a longtime Royals’ reliever. In 159 games over three seasons in pinstripes, Farr pitched to a 2.56 ERA with a 136-67 K/BB ratio. The Yanks forfeited the 45th overall pick to Kansas City to sign him, and they used it to take Texas high school third baseman Ryan Long. Long spent ten seasons in the minors, hitting .260-.295-.415 with 104 homers for three different organizations. He reached the big leagues briefly with the Royals in 1997, picking up two hits in nine at-bats.

Kansas City also received a supplemental first round pick, taking North Carolina high school righty Jason Pruitt 30th overall. Pruitt spend just two seasons in the Royals’ system, compiling a 5.01 ERA and a 75-97 K/BB ratio in 32 starts and four relief appearances.

Baseball-Reference.com’s Amateur Draft Database was an invaluable reference tool for this series.

Hot Stove Open Thread
Top Prospects Of Decade
  • Hughesus Cristo

    They couldn’t have made worse FA acquisitions if they tried.

    • KeithK

      Yeah. The forfeited and supplemental picks almost all turned into nothing but the list of free agents signed during this period just makes me cringe.

    • http://twitter.com/tsjc68 tommiesmithjohncarlos a/k/a Archimedes Torquemada

      Pascual Perez and Steve Sax were both solid FA acquisitions.

      • http://www.livingwithballs.com Living with Balls

        No wonder they sucked in the 80s…

        • http://twitter.com/tsjc68 tommiesmithjohncarlos a/k/a Archimedes Torquemada

          FACT: The Yankees won more games in the 1980’s than any other team in baseball.

          • Stevie V.

            Amazingly enough…That’s actually a fact, and one that most people wouldn’t believe.
            However, from 1980-1989 the Yankees won 854 games. Detroit was second in that span with 839.

            And somehow the Seattle Mariners haven’t contracted yet with only 673 wins in that 10 year span.

      • J.R.

        Till Sax had his run in with the law…

        • Sam

          The law won?

        • Nigel Bangs

          almost as tragic as ken griffey’s grotesquely swollen jaw.

          • coolerking

            I believe he suffered from Gigantisism.

            Saxy boy never did know when to keep his mouth shut.

  • DH=Dime a dozen

    this list sucks on so many levels

  • A.D.

    All that and the main regret player directly drafted was Brian Jordan.

  • http://twitter.com/tsjc68 tommiesmithjohncarlos a/k/a Archimedes Torquemada

    Officer Eddie: (reading Steve Sax’s license) Well well, Steve Sax, from New York City.
    Officer Lou: I heard some guy got killed in New York City and they never solved the case. But you wouldn’t know anything about that now, would you, Steve?
    (Lou and Eddie laugh)
    Steve Sax: But there are hundreds of unsolved murders in New York City.
    Officer Lou: You don’t know when to keep your mouth shut, do you, Saxxy Boy?

    • DH=Dime a dozen
      • http://twitter.com/tsjc68 tommiesmithjohncarlos a/k/a Archimedes Torquemada

        Burns: You there, Strawberry! Go hit a homer.
        Strawberry: Sure thing, skip!
        (Strawberry crushes a mammoth homer)
        Burns: (to Smithers) See there? I told him to do that.

  • A.D.

    87 a lot more options that proved to be better:

    Albert Belle
    Derek Bell
    Pete Harnisch
    Travis Fryman
    Todd Hundley

    • http://twitter.com/tsjc68 tommiesmithjohncarlos a/k/a Archimedes Torquemada

      Derek Bell

      Ah, yes… “Operation Shutdown”. Good times.

      • A.D.

        Shame Bagwell wasn’t drafted in 87, could have been all 3 “Killer B’s”

  • Steve H

    Candelaria made 30 starts…….and 17 relief appearances. Awesome. And only 21 years ago!

    • A.D.

      Its over 2 seasons.

      88: 24 starts 1 relief appearance
      89: 6 Starts, 4 relief appearances with the Yankees. 12 Relief appearances after being shipped to the Expos

      • Steve H

        Consider my parade rained on

    • http://twitter.com/tsjc68 tommiesmithjohncarlos a/k/a Archimedes Torquemada

      My strongest childhood memory of John Candelaria wasn’t on the field.

      It was actually being supremely frustrated that I had like a billion of these: http://www.nonohitters.com/images/candelariacard.jpg

      Every pack I opened… BAM, another Candelaria. They must have printed 700 billion Candelaria cards that year.

  • Rose

    1988 First Round Pick
    Free Agent: Jack Clark, 1B
    Forfeited Pick: John Ericks, RHP (Cardinals)

    For a second I thought that said MEL Clark…

    Ranch Wilder: [flinging the stats book and pamphlet the assistant offers him aside, after Clark’s first two pitches fail miserably] I’m checking to see if Dan Prince pulled a muscle during his warmup tosses. There has to be some reason why Knox would make such a radical change. I have personally checked the stats, sports fans, and Mel Clark has not started a game in this decade.

    • http://twitter.com/tsjc68 tommiesmithjohncarlos a/k/a Archimedes Torquemada

      I literally have no clue who the hell Ranch Wilder, Mel Clark, or Dan Prince are, or what you’re quoting.

      • Jake

        Angels in the Outfield.

        • DH=Dime a dozen

          I loved that movie. In my opinion it was one of the best kids baseball movies ever. great job by Disney and Tony Danza and Christopher Loyd were great.

    • vin


  • vin

    What are the odds of so many 1st and Supplemental round draft picks amounting to so little. Out of 15 picks (by my count), there’s 1 good major league player, 2 average ML players, and 12 scrap heap guys.

    • Slu

      I know it is super simplistic and non-scientific, but it does seem as if these draft picks are being over-valued these days.

  • DH=Dime a dozen

    I still cant believe the chi-sox actually traded for Juan Pierre. Even if L.A. picked up the entire tab I wouldn’t take him. He is putrid.. If Pierre was dealt I can only imagine what we could get for Melky” I like da women” Cabrera.

    • JGS

      Carlos Quentin?

      • DH=Dime a dozen

        i wish

    • larryf

      Nyjer Morgan?

  • Daniel

    I remember the 1988 off season and my 14 year old self being absolutely fascinated that we signed 3 Free agents that year, all with the initials JC…

    I still love quirky things like that but that one always stuck with me.

  • Pittsburgh Pinstripes

    Derek Bell is universally despised in Pittsburgh. Brian Fisher was a dud. Candelaria was talented, but a total goofball. Nyjer Morgan is a good guy, but useless to the Yankees. Terry Carr was really hot, back n the day. Oh wait, that was Terri Garr. Never mind.

  • Pingback: What Happened To All Those Draft Picks? Part Four | River Avenue Blues

  • Pingback: Imagining Frank Thomas as a Yankee | River Avenue Blues