Past Trade Review: David Justice


The Yankees were coming off two straight World Championships in 2000, however their offense was lacking compared to the past few seasons. Both Tino Martinez and Paul O’Neill were in the middle of their worst offensive seasons with the team, which hurt considerably in the lefthanded power department.

In need of a long ball threat, GM Brian Cashman tried to acquire Sammy Sosa from the Cubs and Juan Gonzalez from the Rangers, however nothing came to fruition. He then turned to Indians’ GM John Hart, who was looking to move the aging David Justice to free up a lineup spot for a pair of up-and-coming mashers named Russell Branyan and Richie Sexson. About a month before the trade deadline, the two sides completed the following deal…

Yankees Received
OF David Justice

Indians Received
RHP Jake Westbrook
RHP Zach Day
OF Ricky Ledee

At the time of the deal, Justice was hitting .265-.361-.582 for the Indians, whacking 21 homers in 68 games. However, he had slumped to .283-.386-.476 in the two prior seasons, and there was concern that a precipitous fall from grace was imminent.

Westbrook, then just 22-years-old and just six months removed from being acquired in the Hideki Irabu trade, appeared in just three games for the Yanks, allowing ten runs and 19 baserunners in 6.2 IP. He bounced back and forth between Triple-A and the majors for the next two years, and didn’t settle into a full-time role with the Indians until 2003. After taking over a rotation spot in mid-July of that year, Westbrook ran off a 13 start stretch in which he posted a 4.14 ERA. His peripherals weren’t good (34 K, 34 BB in 71.2 IP), but Cleveland’s days as a powerhouse were over, and they were looking for any young contributors they could find.

During his first six-plus years in the majors, Westbrook posted a perfectly league average 100 ERA+ in 130 starts and 40 relief appearances, chipping in close to 900 innings. The Indians gave him a big contract extension (three years, $33M) before he could reach free agency, however the team only gets credit for his first six years of control in the trade because that’s all they acquired. They negotiated the extension on their own after the fact. During those years of team control, Westbrook was worth 8.2 wins over a replacement level pitcher.

The 22-year-old Day was the Yanks’ fifth round pick in 1996, and at the time of the trade he had a 2.56 ERA with a 147-46 K/BB ratio in 119.2 IP split between Low-A Greensboro and High-A Tampa. He was one of the team’s better pitching prospects, and Cleveland sent him right to Double-A after the trade. Day never appeared in a single game with the Indians, who instead traded to the Expos straight up for Milton Bradley at the 2001 trade deadline. As you probably figured, Day contributed zero wins over replacement to Cleveland’s cause, though Bradley certainly helped.

Ledee, a 25-year-old platoon outfielder for the Bombers, was hitting .241-.332-.419 with seven homers at the time of the swap. His time with the Indians would be short lived though, as they flipped him to Texas for David Segui a month later. I remember hearing at the time of the trade that Ledee was the first player in history to play for three different teams that won their division the previous season in one year. He contributed just one-tenth of a win over replacement to the Indians’ cause.

As for Justice, he was everything the Yanks could have hoped for and then some. In the first four weeks after the deal, he hit .347-.449-.653 with six homers, and his final line with the Yanks in 2000 was .305-.391-.585 with 20 bombs. All told, Justice was a .286-.377-.584 hitter that season, clubbing a career high 41 homers.

His hot hitting carried into the playoffs, when he hit a solo homer off Kevin Appier in Game Five of the ALDS, pushing the Yanks further out ahead of the A’s and eventually sending them home. Justice completely torched the Mariners in the ALCS, picking up eight RBI in the six games. His three run homer off Arthur Rhodes in the 7th inning of Game Six turned a 4-3 deficit into a 6-4 lead, and the Yanks would eventually hold on for a trip to their third consecutive World Series. His efforts won him ALCS MVP honors, and a few weeks later the Yankees were World Champions.

That fall from grace happened the next season, when Justice hit just .241-.333-.430 with a then-career low 18 homers in 2001. The Yankees did get back to the World Series, though Justice was traded across town to the Mets for Robin Ventura after the season. In his year and a half in pinstripes, Justice provided the Yanks with 3.5 wins over replacement, almost all of which came during the second half of 2000.

Here’s a round up of the WAR data…

As you can see, Cleveland’s haul in the trade was more than twice as valuable as Justice was for the Yanks, almost exclusively thanks to Westbrook. However, just like the Chuck Knoblauch trade, the Yankees got exactly what they wanted out of the deal in the World Series victory.

There we times during the mid-2000′s that the Yankees could have really used an innings eater like Jake Westbrook in their rotation, but I wouldn’t have traded that Subway Series win for it. This one is another win-win; the Indians got six years of a league average big league starter plus more, and the Yanks got another championship. Both sides would do this one over time after time.

Photo Credit: Jeff Zelevansky, AP

Categories : Days of Yore


  1. As you can see, Cleveland’s haul in the trade was more than twice as valuable as Justice was for the Yanks, almost exclusively thanks to Westbrook.

    And, when you add in Milton Bradley for Zach Day, which is probably fair, it becomes a landslide. Day wasn’t a 0.0 because he sucked. he was a 0.0 because he was flipped in a prospect-for-prospect trade. Without Day, they never get Bradley, and Bradley was effective back in the day before he got fat, drunk, and stupid.

  2. gc says:

    Ahhh, Arthur Rhodes. I actually remember being very excited when they brought him in to face Justice. It was one of those instances when I just knew something very good would happen. He CREAMED that pitch!

  3. Steve H says:

    One of my most vivid memories of the Justice era was during a game at Fenway. IIRC, Tino was batting with Justice on deck. The crowd was extremely quiet, then someone yelled out from the stands, as clear as can be, “Hey Tino, Justice beats his wife!!!” That became a fun catchphrase for a few years.

  4. awesome.

    can’t wait fo the glenallen hill one haha

  5. Bo says:

    Without Justice they dont win the 2000 title. A great trade.

  6. Rick in Boston says:

    Including Justice, only four Yankees with 200 AB’s OPS+’d greater than 100. Of course, those four were pretty darn good: Posada (139), Jeter (128), Feared Williams (140). That offense was a whole lot of meh.

  7. Wow! I was just thinking about this trade from 10 years ago. Thanks for the analysis, RAB!

    • DP says:

      I was reminded of the infamous Jon Miller call of Mike Lowell’s fourth homer in a row against the Yankees on Sunday Night Baseball. That dinkus of a pitcher who allowed four homers in a row against the Red Sox was Chase Wright.

      I was just thinking about the highlights of the Red Sox 2007 season. Thanks for the analysis, Lenny!

      • bexarama says:

        a. This might have been probably the worst regular season game ever. I blame ESPN.
        b. Aaagh remember when ESPN played the clip of those home runs when the Yankees were ahead by three in that Sabathia vs. Beckett game in late August at Fenway? ESPN >:(

  8. Brian says:

    I was looking at the 2000 Yanks baseball reference page while I read this. Am I the only one who forgot that Glenallen Hill played for that team? Or that he hit .333/.378/.735 in 143 PA? WTF?

    • mike says:

      GA Hill went bezerk (as i recall) in August, but really cooled off down the stretch, and his cooling off combined with the need to get Canseco some at-bats really put ice on him

  9. mike says:

    I always thought the best part of the trade for Justice was the fact the Yanks made a move a full month before the trade deadline, really getting an additional month’s production from Justice because of their ability to eat some $ – it would have cost prospects either way.

    I always remembered in the late 80′s-early 90′s when the Yanks played the A’s, whenever there was an incident, the Yanks would come out of the dougout and the Canseco/ McGwire/ Dave Henderson/ Steinbeck/ Parker etc would be physically intimidating, especially when seeing it in person- and I always wished for a little retribution once the Yanks had those giants like Hill and Canseco toward the end of the year.

  10. vinny-b says:

    Justice carried the yankeees on his back for weeks at at time following the trade. Without him, the Yankees don’t win the World Series. And possibly, don’t win the division.

    anyone who doesn’t know, either isn’t a NYY fan, or is very young.

    to date, the David Justice trade is the best one Brian Cashman ever made.


  11. Ted Nelson says:

    Haven’t read all the other comments, but how can you not include Bradley’s wins? I also disagree with not adding the Westbrook wins after the extension: they could not have signed him to an extension were he not under their control in the first place.

  12. [...] of another bat and another starting pitcher, and Brian Cashman addressed the first issue when he acquired David Justice from the Indians in late-June. Just about three weeks before the trade deadline, Cashman addressed the need for a [...]

  13. [...] Westbrook’s pinstriped career lasted all of six months and 6.2 innings (13.50 ERA); he was traded to the Indians that June for David Justice. Lilly stuck around a little longer, throwing a total of 205.1 IP (4.65 [...]

  14. [...] his batting line sitting at .241/.332/.419 in late-June, the Yankees traded Ledee to the Indians as part of a package for David Justice, who rode into the Bronx on a white horse to save the offense and guide the team to its third [...]

Leave a Reply

You may use <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> in your comment.

If this is your first time commenting on River Ave. Blues, please review the RAB Commenter Guidelines. Login for commenting features. Register for RAB.