Open Thread: Recapping Retro Week

Four Yanks on Kevin Goldstein's top 101 prospects list
Update on RAB fantasy leagues

Retro Week was so much fun that we decided to extended it one extra day. I hope you folks enjoyed it as much as all of us here did, it’s amazing how much fun it can be to look way back in the past. In case you missed anything over the last seven days, here’s a recap of all the Retro Week posts…




Once you’re done rereading all those posts, use this as your open thread. None of the hockey and basketball locals are in action, so you’re on your own tonight. Talk about whatever you like, enjoy.

Four Yanks on Kevin Goldstein's top 101 prospects list
Update on RAB fantasy leagues
  • ThatstheMelkyMesaWaysa

    What about late 90’s week

  • vin

    Great idea for a slow part of the offseason. Very enjoyable posts.

  • Nick

    retro week will be fun in 10 years when you do a thing on Colin Curtis and Juan Miranda

    • Tom Zig

      Andy Phillips, Wilson Betemit, Craig Wilson.

    • RetroRob

      …and Jesus Montero. : -)

      • Monterowasdinero

        Who is going to wear his old “retro” #63 for the Mariners.

    • Thomas Cassidy

      Matt Lawton.

  • Madefelice

    I’m disappointed no one profiled Andy Hawkins. The worst Yankee pitcher I have ever seen. Close second is Rick Rhoden.

    • Robinson Tilapia

      He did pitch a no-hitter in pinstripes. *snicker*

    • Slu

      Steve Trout is the worst Yankee pitcher I remember.

      • Robinson Tilapia

        Nothing will ever be worse than the May/Redding traveling show.

  • Brooklyn Ed

    According to the Yes Network Yankees roster, Pineda will wear #35, Kurdoa #18, and Jones #22.

    • Rey22

      Has anyone worn #35 since Moose retired? I can’t recall…

      • Brooklyn Ed

        Nope, no one has.

    • CS Yankee

      Wondering (hopefully so) that those numbers equate to;
      1) Pineda will make 35 quality starts
      2) Kuroda will win 18 games
      3) Jones will go yard 22 times

      • CS Yankee

        For clarification on Pineda that would be 32 regular season QS & 3 postseason QS (as the Yankees sweep each and every round).

        • Jesse

          Ideal scenario right there.

    • RetroRob

      Hopefully they allow someone to wear 21 again. Love Paulie, but the number is not being retired.

  • CS Yankee

    So with Oakland getting YoCep for 4/36M$ (unbelievable), they now have…
    Coco…2/14 plus option
    Seth Smith…1/2.4M$
    Josh Reddick…cheap & controlable for 5 more years
    plus 3 decent-fairly regarded prospects (Carter, Taylor & Cowgill)

    can we propose the following…
    A) Bucs get AJ & two checks (dated a year apart) for 10M$ each
    B) A’s get 1-2 role players with a possible prospect & save a couple mil on…
    c) LHB-DH/RF Seth Smith to the Yankees

    • Plank

      B is a little too vague to determine if it’s realistic.

  • brent

    I followed the yankees farm system back then and Sam Militello was THE thing. His first two years after being drafted were INSANELY good. Like sub 1.0 better than a k per ip and sub 2.0 era good. I used to complain to my dad that they hadn’t brought him up and he would say “A) he was just drafted and B) when a kid has stats like that in the minors and isn’t in the majors its because he’s a junk baller with one great pitch that minor league guys can’t figure out.”

    He was right of course but still Militello had pretty good success as a real young guy out of the gate. Got hurt in his second year AND NEVER PITCHED AGAIN. I don’t get it. Everyone gets another shot but Militello just dissapeared. I would greatly enjoy a post about what happened to him. Even his wikipedia page gives no clue other than that he coachs in college now and had a brief MiLB coaching career in the Indians system. Wha happened???

    • Robinson Tilapia

      I was shocked at seeing he’s 43 now until I realized I’ve already lived through “Dave Eiland – Pitching Coach.”

      • brent

        ha. last night I said to my wife “you know you’re old when the players you loved growing up now have kids that have already washed out of pro baseball.”

        Every year in the draft I see guys who make me feel old.

        What Delino Deshields has a KID playing pro ball?

        Don Mattinglys KID is washed up?

        etc etc.

  • brent

    And yeah Seth Smith makes perfect sense for this team now. I’d think with the roster crunch they have there that say Phelps and a RP arm should do it. Seems to me its time to move one of Phelps Warren for a useful piece.

    • Thomas Cassidy

      Seth Smith already got traded to the A’s.

      • steve (different one)

        He’s talking about the A’s roster crunch now that they have Cespedes.

    • CJ

      I like the Seth Smith idea. Maybe cash can negotiate a Pitt prospect beane likes.

      • Chuck M

        Why does everybody think the current Pirates regime is stupid? They are not going to give up a precious prospect (they can’t get free agents, prospects are all they’ve got) for AJ Burnett.

        Believe me – if they didn’t offer Maholm a contract this year (who’s a home-grown prospect with Pittsburgh roots), they’re not going to give an actual prospect for AJ. Maybe a AA longman, but that’s about it.

  • Slu

    I posted this in the Steve Howe thread, but I am going to post it again. I loved the retro series. Thanks guys. Different stuff like this is what keeps me coming back here every day. I also grew up in the 80s so that helps!

    Someone said it best in another thread. I am glad I grew up on those Yankees teams. After such a long drought, 1995 was awesome and really painful at the same time. I felt bad for Donnie since I knew it was the end. But the joy of 1996 is something I’ll never forget. It kinda made the late 80s and early 90s worth it.

    • Paul VuvuZuvella

      +1 Brutter
      The ’96 post season was my favorite post season ever! Maybe 2001 would have surpassed it if the bottom of the 9th of Game 7 had gone differently.

    • brent

      yeah. My family had season tickets from 1979 through 1995. How’s that for shitty?

      Want another fun/sad fact from those years?

      Claudell Washington had a turn as my favorite yankee.

      Another one?

      I was PSYCHED about the additon of Rick Rhoden. totally psyched. I remember telling my mets fan best friend that Rhoden was exactly what the yankees needed to get them over the hump.

  • Mike Myers

    I cant wait until AJ is on retro week in 15 years. Everyone that reads it will immediately throw up in their respective mouths.

    • Robinson Tilapia

      Yup, 15 years from now there will be an “AJ Burnett Open Thread,” except everyone will claim they only became a fan five years ago.

  • Stuck in Albany

    Sam Milletello was amazing until he got hurt. I remember when he came up and just had a feel for pitching in the big leagues. Look at his minor league numbers. The guy had incredible potential. Darn shame.

  • James

    So Sherman says the Yanks would get two “blah” prospects for AJ. What is “blah”? Top ten? Typical organizational players? Live bodies?

    Anybody care to speculate?

    Three months ago I wouldn’t have thought anybody would pay $10-13 million for AJ, but here we are, so I have no idea what kind of return to expect.

    • Thomas Cassidy

      Two people that the Pirates don’t want, but the Yankees want just so they can get at least something besides the salary relief.

      Like two DeAngelo Macks.

      • Foghirn Leghorn

        Is that a new sammich from McDonald’s?

        • Jesse

          That made me laugh.

    • CJ

      Typical Joel Sherman insight. He has no clue but “blah” will mean anyone other than Cole and Taillon (which is obvious). Top 10? Top 20? Or organizational players? like you say, Sherman doesn’t care to extend himself. I like Robbie grossman.

      • James

        Well, Heyman did say they’re non-roster players, not that that really narrows it down though…

      • STONE COLD Austin Romine

        Getting Grossman would be a big win imo.

      • Jesse

        My guess is that they’re “C” level prospects. Could be wrong, though.

    • Robinson Tilapia

      by gawd, that’s Stephen Jackson and Anthony Claggett’s music they’re playing!

      • whozat

        Yeah, guys like that are the kind of return I think we should expect. Org arms, or MAYBE a guy that throws hard, has injury problems, and can’t find the plate. And is old for his league :-)

  • Paul VuvuZuvella

    Always liked Sam. His full name was Salvatore, which is a family name. In fact, when my dad was bedridden and close to passing, I remember watching him pitch on the hospital TV with my day, who was named Sal. A special moment I won’t forget.

  • Elmgrovegnome

    Thanks for posting the card Mike. I will be looking forward to that story one day.

    I was also a huge Miletello fan. It was so crushing to have him go down and out like that when the Yankees were in dire need of pitching. That is the year that I learned to temper my enthusiasm for prospects.

  • brent

    Yeah Millitello just tore throught the lower levels. I remember keeping track of his stats in the news and being so excited at the possiblity of an actual decent young SP. I can’t for the life of me remember what the actual injury was. If anyone remembers I’d love to be reminded.

  • brent

    I actually just found a piece about it in baseball

    Added bonus was reminding me of Sam HOrn who was a STRAT o Matic BEAST for me. His card was like all K’s BBs and HRs. I ran him and Hector Villanueva into the ground to the point where my league the next year made a system that no longer allowed you to play guys without full season stats full time.

  • Reggie C.

    The Steve Howe story actually saddened me for a spell this afternoon. I only recall Howe as a tabloid fixture, but i was really too young then to follow how long Howe had fought his demons even up to that point. Didn’t realize Steve Howe died addicted. That was a tough read.

  • BrianH

    Thoughts on Dimitri Young on a minor league deal?

  • BrianH

    Thoughts on Dimitri Young on a minor league deal? Just read an espn article on him, there is never a down side to minor league deal.