Prospect Profile: Aaron Judge

Scouting The Trade Market: Daniel Murphy
What Went Right: Joe Girardi

Aaron Judge | OF

Judge is a Northern California kid who was born in Sacramento but grew up a few miles outside Stockton in a small town called Linden. According to the internet, only about 1,800 people live in the eight or so square mile town. Judge was a three-sport star at Linden High School (baseball, basketball, football) and was twice an All-League selection in baseball. He also earned All-American honors as a senior.

Prior to the 2010 draft, Baseball America (subs. req’d) ranked Judge as the 77th best prospect available in California. He was considered a better pitching prospect at the time and was selected in the 31st round by the Athletics. Judge declined to sign and followed through on his commitment to Fresno State, where he moved off the mound and into the outfield full-time. Most colleges recruited him as a tight end but baseball was his favorite spot, so he stuck with that.

As a freshman with the Bulldogs, Judge hit .358/.437/.465 with 12 doubles, two homers, 25 walks, and 42 strikeouts in 215 plate appearances. He also went 11-for-12 in stolen base attempts. The performance earned him some hardware, including being named to the Freshman All-American and Freshman All-Conference Teams. He was also named Conference Freshman of the Year.

Judge hit .308/.453/.458 with 14 doubles, four homers (including two in one game off Stanford ace Mark Appel), 48 walks, 42 strikeouts, and 13 steals in 15 attempts in 256 plate appearances as a sophomore, helping Fresno State to the Conference Tournament title and a NCAA Regional berth. He was named to the All-Conference Tournament Team as well as the All-Conference Team for the second straight year.

After the season, Judge spent the summer with the Brewster Whitecaps of the Cape Cod League, where he hit five homers in 32 games and was named the team’s Citizenship Award winner for being a good teammate. Baseball America (subs. req’d) ranked him the sixth best prospect in the circuit. Judge was also one of eight players selected to participate in the TD Ameritrade College Baseball Homerun Derby in July, an event he won by going deep 16 times in three rounds.

Judge had his best season with the Bulldogs as a junior this past spring, hitting .369/.461/.655 with 15 doubles, 12 homers, 35 walks, 53 strikeouts, and 12 stolen bases in 14 attempts across 246 plate appearances. Fresno State disappointed overall and Judge was the best player on the team by a not small margin. Once again, he was named to the All-Conference Team.

Prior to this June’s draft, Keith Law (subs. req’d) ranked Judge as the 17th best prospect available while Baseball America had him as the eighth best prospect in California and 30th best in the draft. The Yankees grabbed him with the second of their three first round picks, the 32nd overall selection. That’s the pick they received as compensation for losing Nick Swisher to free agency. Judge signed for a slightly above-slot $1.8M — slot was just under $1.68M — the day before the July 12th signing deadline.

Pro Debut
Before he could ever play a game after signing, Judge suffered a quad strain and was shut down for the rest of the season. He was unlikely to get healthy in time to appear in any minor league games, so the club simply shut him down and decided not to push it. We’re all still waiting for that first professional at-bat.

Scouting Report
Any conversation about Judge has to start with his size. He’s listed at 6-foot-7 and 255 lbs., meaning he’s taller than every non-Frank Howard outfielder in baseball history. Most reports I’ve found compare him physically to guys like Jimmy Graham and Blake Griffin, not baseball players. Judge is a very athletic for his size and is a good runner. It’s not like he’s some big lumbering guy who waddles around in the outfield. He’s a good defender with a strong arm who played center in college but will likely wind up in right field down the road.

Judge’s offensive calling card is his huge right-handed raw power, the kind of power that allows him to hit the ball out of any part of any park. He does not always tap into during games, however, because he tends to get under the ball and not create as much loft as he should. The coaches at Fresno State worked to get him more upright in his stance, which contributed to his increased power output as a junior. The power is legitimate 30+ homer type of stuff, but there is work to be done before he carries that over into games.

Despite a relatively short swing and a disciplined approach, Judge projects to be a .250-ish hitter who strikes out in a quarter of his plate appearances, or thereabouts. He has pretty long arms (obviously) and sets his hands up high, so that power comes with quite a bit of swing-and-miss ability. If he had better contact skills and a chance to hit for more average, he’d have been a top ten pick. Judge is what he is offensively, and that’s a guy whose value at the plate will depend on his ability to tap into that power.


There is whole bunch of video of Judge at YouTube and some at as well. I can’t find video of him pitching in high school, however. That’s a shame.

2014 Outlook
I’ve always said that if you take a college hitter in the first round and are not comfortable sending him right to High Class-A in his first full professional season, you probably took the wrong guy. Judge spend three years at a major program in Fresno State and he was an everyday player as soon as he arrived on campus. Low-A Charleston would be a waste of time. He should start next year with High-A Tampa and could earn a midseason promotion to Double-A Trenton, though I don’t think it’s a slam dunk.

My Take
I love big hulking sluggers who swing for the fences and can hit the ball a mile, so Judge is right up my alley. Power in general is at a premium these days, especially right-handed power for the Yankees since Yankee Stadium helps their lefties so much. Judge has the ability to hit some dingers and he can contribute both on the bases and in the field as well — he’s not some one-dimensional slugger who will be relegated to DH by time he’s 27 or something. That’s pretty big in my opinion. There are no position concerns. The Yankees have to work with him and help him unleash that power in games so he can realize his full potential, and that potential is exciting. Judge could be a true impact player if things work out. High risk, high reward, so on and so on.

Scouting The Trade Market: Daniel Murphy
What Went Right: Joe Girardi
  • I’m One

    Based on the scouting reports, I was very excited when the Yankees drafted him. I’m anxious to see how he does in the minors and hopeful we’ll see him in the majors in a few years, preferably in a Yankees uniform, hitting homers and doing his job in the OF in a way that gets us all hot and bothered in the pants. :-)

    • Hot and bothered…in the pants

      That’s fantastic. Just fantastic.

      • I’m One

        Don’t steal it! I may use it. Give me a couple of days to think it over. Or am I too late already?

  • Bryan

    I understand shutting him down for the year due to the quad strain, but why not let him get his feet wet in Fall ball?

    • Havok9120

      That’d be throwing him into the deep end in a pretty big way. Plus we had other guys we wanted in that league.

      • Bryan

        He might be overmatched but often times you see teams put specs there just to get them a little extra work since they missed a large portion of the season. Judge i a college bat hitter and therefore further along than guys in low A and HS. He might have trouble staying afloat there, but it would at least have served to knock some of the rust off.

        Oh well. Not the biggest of gripes I really just wanted to see how he would do!

    • Frank Costanza

      Because the Yankees don’t know what the hell they’re doing!!!

  • entonces

    Nice swing. Nice report.

  • Tyrone Sharpton

    But how is he any different from a Shelley Duncan type guy? Totally see him busting

    • Havok9120

      I’m stunned. You’re usually so even-keeled and reasonable.

    • I’m One

      Seems to be a better athlete overall. But I certaninly not experienced enought to make that determination.

    • Preston

      Shelly Duncan was a terrible defender and a huge liability on the basepaths, he was a bat only prospect. Judge is a plus fielder and runner and has way more power potential.

      • OhioYanks

        Yep. He also seems pretty similar to Giancarlo (Mike) Stanton in some ways. He has way more chance to be Duncan-esque in value than Stanton-esque, but you can’t just assume that every amateur player will follow the career path of one somewhat comparable player. It’s ultimately a sample size issue.

  • Havok9120

    He’s the guy I’m most excited about from last season’s draft.

    High-A, High-A, High-A!!

    • Preston

      I’m a big fan of Judge, but he’s not that polished of a hitter. I wouldn’t be surprised to see him go to Low A and move slower than elite college bats normally do. But if he can work on his contact and tap into his power it’d be worth the wait.

    • MannyGeee

      Imma let you finish, but Eric Jagielo was the main guy from this draft.


  • Chris

    With the way minor league development has gone over the last ten years, I fully expect Judge to never amount to anything. Feels good to not have any expectations just in case he does do anything noteworthy in the bigs.

    • TWTR

      They should be getting some prospect development hits if only by accident.

      • qwerty

        They have, the hits have all but been traded away. We’ve kept all the good ones like Phil Hughes, Joba Chamberlain and Ivan Nova.

    • OhioYanks

      You know that in the last 10 years on the position player side the Yankees have developed Cano, Gardner, and AJax right? This is inexact and favors players developed in an earlier period, but that’s #13, 50, and 80 in fWAR under 29 over the past 10 years. 3 of the top 90 is exactly what you’d expect. (It’s similar on the P side, though I’m not sure how relevant that is to Judge.)

      I know people are frustrated about the results the past couple of years, but this misinformation about how they’ve done relative to the rest of the league over a longer period has got to stop.

      • OhioYanks

        It’s both misremembering the previous era and assuming the players they’ve been developing the past 5 seasons or so will not work out. I mean depending on how you define development in the last 10 years, fully half of those guys are probably still in the minors or just debuting.

    • Robinson Tilapia

      *sad trombone*

    • qwerty

      Which is precisely why I pay little attention to the lower minors. I swear fans get so excited around here and on other forums about these prospects that if you say anything that isn’t completely complimentary, even if you’re right, they go ballistic. This is the inherit risk of becoming a prospect hugger. They’re treated like girlfriends rather than as assets.

  • MannyGeee

    This just in… Aaron Judge laid down more bunts in that video than Brett Gardner did in 2013. Jus saying

    • Mitch

      Bunts suck, fyi.

  • PunkPitch

    Fingers crossed we’re not getting excited about the second coming of Dave Kingman.

    • Bryan

      That’s the risk with every single prospect ever. “Shit, I hope we avoid the next “

    • Nate

      Dave Kinsman was awesome. I’d be thrilled if he turned into that.

      • http://Riveravenueblues Marty l

        Agree, Kinsman was awesome but Kingman sucked! And was, and prolly still is, an a hole.

    • qwerty

      If the yankees turned out a Dave Kingman from their minors they’ll hail it as a huge success and be jumping up for joy. The last time the yankees had a highly touted prospect turn into something was Alfonso Soriano.

    • Get Phelps Up

      Dave Kingman had a career 115 OPS+ over 16 seasons. How is that a bad thing?

    • RetroRob

      It is highly unlikely he’ll be better than Dave Kingman, who played in the majors for 15+ years. Just saying.

  • Robinson Tilapia

    Excited about the power potential with this kid. There’s a chance he’s too much of a free swinger for sure but, hey, you wanted upside? This kid seems to have it, and then some.

  • SMK

    If he makes it to The Show, CC and Judge would make an awesome tag team during any bench-clearing brawls.

    Imagine those two coming at you with malice. Yikes!

  • Marty l

    Kinsman was awesome, but Kingman sucked. And was an a hole. Prolly stiil is.

  • Bo Knows

    Alot of movement in his set up, quiet that down, I bet the K’s drop alot

  • Wayne

    If hitting does not work out for him I hope they give him a chance to be a starting pitcher because he has the size for it !

  • VinnyH

    I’m a big Kevin Long fan and if he can work with Judge along the way, there’s hope. I like the possibilities.