May
12

Game 32 Spillover Thread II

By

One last thread for the comeback win and postgame celebration.

Categories : Game Threads

213 Comments»

  1. Andrew says:

    Vintage AJ out there tonight. He must have the most 7.2 IP, 5+ ER starts in the history of the ML’s.

  2. Mike Pop says:

    Heh.

  3. pat says:

    Niiice the good old yankees suck chant. Never gets old.

  4. Zack says:

    “Yankees suck” chant from Toronto fans, really?

  5. Accent Shallow says:

    Would it kill the Jays to trade Halladay out of the division?

    I’m so sick of having 2 out of 3 being the best-case scenario for a series with Toronto, due to him.

  6. JackC says:

    You can’t be too upset about losing to Halladay. He’s absurdly good. But it’s funny watching Burnett; his stuff is consistently filthy and yet more games than not, he finds a way to give up about 3 or 4 runs. Or 5 in this case — but that’s ‘coos, I assume, girardi’s trying not to burn out the pen on what is 98% likely a loss.

    • V says:

      And usually it’s because he beats himself, by walking a couple, then grooving one.

    • Blue Jays Daze says:

      I agree. But I can say that having watched his awesome season last year, when Burnett was pitching with contract on his mind, he was lights out and mentally tough. Now, he’s pitching for you guys the same way he pitched for TO when he signed with us: good enough to not get booed, but not good enough for his price tag.

  7. Mike Pop says:

    So, when are the Yankees going to go on a tear?

  8. Charlie says:

    AJ pretty much sucks. why was he still in there for so long?

  9. From the last thread:

    dre says:

    for you all people defending Girardis lineup
    Garnder over swisher is just plain stupid as bad as swisher may be playing he will still take more pitches and be more of a threat than Gardner.
    Cash over Cervelli maybe not stupid but not smart either. Cervelli just caught 3 games, his jitters are gone and actually got a few hits..oh and yesterday was a day off, Cash will obviously be a little nervous..so yeah not a smart move, you want the best lineup possible outthere against a pitcher like Holiday..

    It’s a 162 game season, dre. You have to give guys the occasional day off.

    Might as well give them a day off against a guy like Halladay that you’re not likely to beat even with your 1A lineup.

  10. JT says:

    I’m sick of Girardi leaving him in there too long. You need to take him out after the four pitch walk. You leave him in after the homer to see how he responds, and when he can’t throw a strike you take him out. I don’t get it.

    • Zack says:

      Take him out so you can complain to stop babying him and let him throw more then 100 pitches?

      • Thurman says:

        I don’t know, I kinda agree. It’s kinda just the right move to make once you see him throw four straight balls. Go out to the mound, accept he put up decent numbers for a night where he didn’t have his best stuff, and call it a night. No reason to leave out there to labor to throw strikes.

      • Jackson says:

        No, you take him out because of exactly what he said. He gave up a home run and a 4 pitch walk, his night is done, no one would have complained about anything.

    • Mike Pop says:

      …..cause the game was pretty much ova anyways.

    • JackC says:

      I’m no Girardi fan AT ALL, but I don’t blame him here — the game’s lost, basically. GIve the pen as few outs as possible to rest them up. Part — PART — of the reason they’ve sucked so is overwork. I think it’s smart, actually

  11. Evan says:

    Veras is like “stop fouling off all my strikes!”

  12. Orlando says:

    who the fuck knows???

  13. Drew says:

    Oh Veras…

  14. Orlando says:

    i swear i am going to swallow my tongue!!!!!!

  15. Is bringing Veras in akin to waving a white flag here?

  16. Orlando says:

    I miss Jim Kaat!!!

  17. Jamal G. says:

    Jose Reyes just got thrown out trying to stretch a double into a triple as the tying run with one out in the bottom of the eight inning. Nice job, bud.

  18. Orlando says:

    Toronto??? Seriously???

  19. touchtoneterriost says:

    Why is Burnett in the 8th when he went 7 innings and gave up 3 runs.Great we got Joba to pitch 5 innings and 12 strikeouts and the bullpen loses he’s and the next 3 starters games.

    There’s no reason for Burnett to go 8 innings.They took a solid pitching outing to a real bad game.This isn’t the ’60′s pitchers don’t go 7 innings a game.The Yankees look old.Even there young prospects act like there old.

  20. Orlando says:

    Jamal, and there are still people out there that state Reyes is better than Jeter?

  21. Orlando says:

    i just wanna scream!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

  22. They can get four runs in the ninth…

    /keeping the faith

  23. Mike Axisa says:

    Pena with a futile double.

  24. Mike Pop says:

    Brett Gardner is a pest.

  25. Voice Of Reason says:

    You are what your record says you are. Right now the Yankees record sucks and so do they.

  26. Drew says:

    You suck Gardner

  27. JackC says:

    Most teams look old against Halladay. But yes. They do look old. In all fairness to them, the only reason the do is that they ARE

    • The Artist says:

      Average age of Yankees roster-28.3
      Average age of Red Sox roster-28.4

      http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/.....r?team=nyy

      • pat says:

        O SNAP!

      • JackC says:

        A deeply misleading stat. The heart of the team, and the pitching staff, is considerably older — Jeter, A-Rod, Damon, Posada, Vs. Pedroia, Youklis, Drew, Ellsbury. True — we have Tex and they have Ortiz (who’s only 33 — but the oldest 33 I’ve seen in a while), we have Cano and they have Lowell, but the pitching is younger (with the exception of Wakefield, whose age is less important,and whose 42 years pulls the average up a bit), and I think your stat is proof that not all numbers are created equal

        • Spaceman.Spiff says:

          Yes, 28.4 was not created equally by God as 28.3, tis true.

        • The Artist says:

          No, you just want to count some guys and not count others to suit your preconceived notion. That’s the opposite of looking at the numbers and taking them wherever they lead you.

          • Charlie says:

            That stat is misleading… thats the Avg age for the 40 Man rosters.

          • JackC says:

            I disagree — I think it’s tough to look at this club game in and game out and not see that they are an older club, both on the field and in the trainer’s room. And you’re right, I don’t want to count Gardner as much in this equation as Matsui — I think it would be tough to construct a rational argument as to why you should want to — because while they’re weighted equally in your equation, to argue they’re equivalents in terms of how much they impact the games is demonstrably silly.

            The vital components of the Red Sox, to use your example, are younger than their counterparts on the Yankees. To deny that somewhat obvious truth strikes me as aggressively partisan willfulness.

            I’m not saying the Yanks are ancient, or too old to contend, but to argue that their age at key spots isn’t an issue isn’t looking at the facts, even it is looking at the numbers

            • pat says:

              Lowell-35
              Arod- 33

              Jeter-34
              Lowrie-25

              Cano-26
              Pedroia-25

              Youkilis-30
              Teixera-29

              Posada-37
              Varitek-37

              Damon-35
              Bay-30

              Melky-24
              Ellsbury-25

              Swisher-28
              Drew-33

              We’re younger at 4 positions, tied at one and older at three. Plus Lowrie sucks and is always injured

              • pat says:

                Oops, Ortiz is 33 going on 53 and Matsui is 34 with crappy knees.

                Sabathia-28
                Burnett-32
                Pettite-36
                Wang-29
                Chamberlain-23
                Hughes-22

                Beckett-28
                Lester-25
                Matsuzaka-28
                Wakefield-42
                Penny-30
                Masterson/Buccholz-24

            • The vital components of the Red Sox, to use your example, are younger than their counterparts on the Yankees. To deny that somewhat obvious truth strikes me as aggressively partisan willfulness.

              Okay, I’ll bite.

              Sox “Vital Components”
              Beckett – 28
              Lester – 25
              Matsuzaka – 28
              Wakefield – 42
              Penny – 30
              Masterson – 24
              Buchholz – 24
              Smoltz – 41
              Bowden – 22
              Papelbon – 28
              Okajima – 33
              Delcarmen – 27
              Saito – 39
              Ramon Ramirez – 27
              Hunter Jones – 25
              Bard – 23
              Varitek – 37
              Kottaras – 25
              Youkilis – 30
              Pedroia – 25
              Lowell – 35
              Lowrie – 25
              Lugo – 33
              Bay – 30
              Drew – 33
              Ellsbury – 25
              Baldelli – 27
              Ortiz – 33
              Kotsay – 33

              29 players. Average age: 29.55

              Yankees “Vital Components”
              Sabathia – 28
              Burnett – 32
              Pettitte – 36
              Wang – 29
              Joba – 23
              Hughes – 22
              Aceves – 26
              Kennedy – 24
              Mo – 39
              Bruney – 27
              Coke – 26
              Marte – 34
              Veras – 28
              Edwar – 28
              Albaladejo – 26
              Robertson – 24
              Melancon – 24
              Posada – 37
              Molina – 33
              Cervelli – 23
              Teixeira – 29
              Cano – 26
              Jeter – 34
              ARod – 33
              Peña – 23
              Damon – 35
              Swisher – 29
              Nady – 30
              Melky – 24
              Matsui – 34

              30 players. Average age: 28.88

              • Now, say we take Smoltz out (since he’s not really on the team yet) and we give Wakefield an age discount since he’s a knuckleballer and a freak of nature… we’ll call him a 30 year old instead of a 42 year old. (I think I’m being generous here.)

                If you take Smoltz out and Kennedy out and give Wakefield a discount, now your average ages are 28.71 for the Sox and 29.03 for the Yankees. We’re older, but less than a full year older.

                More drilldown, operating from those pro-Sox adjusted totals:

                Starting five v. starting five:
                Sox 28.2 (Beckett, Lester, Matsuzaka, “30 year old “Wakefield, Penny)
                Yanks 29.6 (CC, Burnett, Pettitte, Joba, Wang)

                Bullpen and extra starters/swingmen)
                Sox 27.2 (Masterson, Buchholz, Bowden, Papelbon, Okajima, Delcarmen, Saito, Ramirez, Jones, Bard)
                Yanks 27.6 (Hughes, Aceves, Mo, Bruney, Coke, Marte, Veras, Edwar, Albaladejo, Robertson, Melancon)

                Position players:
                Sox 30.0 (Varitek, Kottaras, Youkilis, Pedroia, Lowrie, Lugo, Lowell, Bay, Drew, Ellsbury, Baldelli, Ortiz, Kotsay)
                Yankees 30.0 (Posada, Molina, Cervelli, Teixeira, Cano, Jeter, ARod, Peña, Damon, Swisher, Nady, Melky, Matsui)

                Older? Hardly.

                • pat says:

                  I think we put that one to bed.

                • I wake topics up from bed and kill them, cremate them, and scatter the ashes to the four winds.

                • JackC says:

                  Interesting. If I follow your reasoning, you argue that because the 7th oldest team in baseball, the Yankees, is marginally younger on average than the 5th oldest team in baseball, the Red Sox, it follows that the Yankees have no age issues on their roster.

                  Am I correct then in assuming that you believe the Yankees have no issues with age on the roster? Ok then. It doesn’t really play out that way — or at least, it hasn’t thus far, but ok. Isn’t it a bit silly to realize on May 12th that Jeter, Matsui, Posada, Rodriguez have already missed time with injuries and argue feverishly that the Yankees aren’t old at all? How is that argument tenable?

                  I absolutely concede that, statistically, the Red Sox are more or less the same age as the Yanks, but of course that was never part of my original, seemingly benign and obvious observation that the Yankees are old. I suppose we could ascribe the Yanks endless inability to get their lineup as planned on the field at the same time this past season and 6 weeks to poor conditioning or freakishly bad luck, but that seems not very reasonable.

                • JackC says:

                  And of course, I still would argue, that we depend to a larger degree on aging players in key spots than the Red Sox do — Pedroia, Ellsbury, Youklis, Ortiz, Papelbon and Bay as compared with RIvera, Jeter, Matsui, Posada, Rodriguez and Tex. I think we can throw Cano in there, too, and it evens it out a bit. But my point was never really about the Red Sox. Of the players I mentioned, only Ortiz looks old, while Matsui, Posada, Jeter and even A-Rod seems at times so to me. Do they not ever seem so to you?

                  I am amazed that so many obviously bright and well-informed fans can be so disdainful and dismissive (almost, perhaps, defensively so at times) of the idea that the Yanks, at times, look a little rickety.

                • Come on, Jack, that’s ridiculous.

                  You were the one that brought up the Yankees vs. Red Sox comparison as being prime example of the Yankees being too old and the Yankees being demonstrably older than the Red Sox. Not us, Jack. You.

                  Now that I’ve debunked that, you want to spin and say “Oh, well, I never said the Sox were a good comparison, of course, they’re old too!” That’s hilariously pathetic.

                • JackC says:

                  Actually, if you go back and read, that’s not even vaguely true. But of course the fact that the Yanks are old in key spots is the subject of a new post this morning, and for some reason you didn’t respond with the “Red Sox are just as old.” I responded to the whoever mentioned the Red Sox (’twasn’t me, despite your curious at attempt at revisionist history on this )by saying the idea that the Sox have the same age issues as the Yanks is incorrect. I stand by that.

                • JackC says:

                  And of course, all this started because I commented the Yanks are old — which I later amended to the Yanks in too many key spots are old. And once again, no one really addresses this. Because it’s demonstrably true.

  28. cjc says:

    watching gardner makes puppies cry

  29. V says:

    Girardi needs to ‘Willie Mays Hayes’ Gardner.

    If the ball goes in the air, drop and do pushups.

  30. Charlie says:

    the magic better win tonite

  31. Aw, they’re being so nice to Tex with the MVP chant. Maybe it’ll lift his spirits a bit.

  32. bizarrojamie says:

    Baseball noob question here.
    Why are the Toronto announcers and fans all up in arms about a tipping of the hat by AJ from last year?

  33. JackC says:

    Ah Tex…who would’ve thought his .259 career mark in APril is a number we’d be THRILLED to have him reach by Memorial Day?

  34. Mike Pop says:

    Did I miss the game tonight?

  35. Jamal G. says:

    2:24?

    Anyway, anyone who complains about the Yankees in this game is being douche-esque.

  36. The Artist says:

    That’s it, I’ve had it with this team. The manager sucks, the pitching coach sucks, the GM sucks and the players all suck.

    You can all kill me for being a fair-weather fan, but I’m telling you right this very minute that I will not watch another Yankee game for the next 21 and 1/2 hours!!!

  37. Accent Shallow says:

    Please trade him to the Cardinals or something. You’re not gonna contend.

  38. cjc says:

    yay tex made contact

  39. Well…that was crappy. But, it was Roy Halladay and “Roy Halladay” is Canadaian for “Pitcher who makes your favorite team look crappy”.

  40. Charlie says:

    i think tex thinks its illegal to bat righty against a righty when your a switch hitter.

  41. Orlando says:

    I sure hope they show some balls tomorrow and play better….

  42. Blue Jays Daze says:

    Awesome game, 43,000 strong at the Dome agree! Thanks for another great one Doc.

  43. Jason Werth stole home. He’s just copying Jacoby Ellsbury who was the first person to ever steal home in a baseball game.

  44. The Artist says:

    Rats>Mice>Worms>Roaches>pond scum>Russ Salzberg.

    Sounds about right.

  45. Jamal G. says:

    I knew it! Carmen Angelini didn’t make an error tonight, that prick.

  46. Zack says:

    Atleast Wang pitched good down in AAA tonight

    http://web.minorleaguebaseball.....8;sid=t531

    • Bob Stone says:

      That’s nice but Hughes pitched well there too. We need some pitchers who can pitch well consistently at the Major League level.

      • JobaWockeeZ says:

        But at least Wang seems to be putting it back together. We need him back. When is he scheduled to come back?

        • Bob Stone says:

          The Yanks haven’t stated a set return date – depends on his progress.

          • JobaWockeeZ says:

            Oh well no need to rush.

            • Accent Shallow says:

              Depends on what we can expect from Hughes going forward. If he can manage a 4.00-4.50 ERA, they’re fine. If it’s more of what we saw against Boston and the O’s, well . . .

              (Disclaimer: am not expecting Hughes to be nearly that bad, but you have to prepare for all possibilities)

    • The Artist says:

      Wang IP 6 H 3 R 0 BB 3 SO 6
      Pitches-strikes: Wang 82-49
      Groundouts-flyouts: Wang 7-4

      Don’t like the strike ratio, the 3 walks is a bit much for AAA, and the GO/FO could be better. Think he needs another start.

      • Bob Stone says:

        Those stats say he is not ready yet for the bigs

        • The Artist says:

          They’re not bad, I just suspect they will give him one more. He shouldn’t be striking that many guys out, he’s not that type of pitcher. Could mean his ball was up.

          • Accent Shallow says:

            Eh, you’d expect his K-rate to be higher in the minors.

            His career minor-league K-rate is 7.1/9, although that includes some pre-sinker years, I believe.

      • Axl says:

        At this point…maybe the 50/50 “Which Hughes is going to show up?” gamble is a better option…but in reality…Hughes hasn’t had a good start since his first one…so I guess the odds aren’t really 50/50…or even close. They’re far worse.

        I guess you could call the Wang or Hughes start a coin toss…with the outcome seemingly looking bad either way. Even though both are capable of stellar performances…something very strange is going on where that’s just not the case…with literally any of our starters unfortunately.

  47. Mike Axisa says:

    Hah, Alex Cora is playing first for the Mets with a regular infielder’s glove.

  48. Joebrah says:

    doc halladay is good.

  49. Ok… That’s the first time I’ve seen the Keith Hernandez mustache SNY commercial… That’s pretty hilarious.

  50. Axl says:

    So when do you guys think this team will actually start playing like they’re suppose to?

    Every year we should look forward to the inconsistencies, injuries, and slow starts now? It’s been going on quite a few years now…

    They either do this on purpose…or there is something very strange going on…

  51. Accent Shallow says:

    Over/under on game threads this year with no spillover threads: set at 10.

    Taking the under.

  52. MoveBack says:

    There is no shame in being shut down by Halladay, but if either Girardi or another announcer gush over an AJ or CC start as great that results in 7+ IP and 4-5 runs, I give up. It’s an average start at best and these guys are being paid Johan Santana money.

    • Joey H. says:

      No shame? Getting shut down by anyone is shameful. In this case it’s just expected. I think they loose the games in their head before they step on the field against Doc.

  53. Joey H. says:

    Great. So now Coke is hurt? This has to be a God Damned joke already.

  54. mtrico says:

    This team is just plain bad right now.

Leave a Reply

You may use <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> in your comment.

If this is your first time commenting on River Ave. Blues, please review the RAB Commenter Guidelines. Login for commenting features. Register for RAB.