Apr
03
Which team would you choose?
ByWe usually leave matters like this to Mike, but I saw Scranton’s Opening Day roster, and I couldn’t resist.
| Phil Hughes | SP | Zach Duke |
|---|---|---|
| Tyler Clippard | SP | Ian Snell |
| Ross Ohlendorf | SP | Paul Maholm |
| Matt DeSalvo | SP | Tom Gorzelanny |
| Steven Jackson | SP | Tony Armas, Jr. |
| Chris Britton | SP | Solomon Torres |
| T.J. Beam | SP | Matt Capps |
| Colter Bean | SP | Damaso Marte |
| Justin Pope | SP | Jonah Bayliss |
| Charlie Manning | SP | Juan Perez |
| Ben Kozlowski | SP | Jon Wadin |
| Raul Chavez | C | Ronny Paulino |
| Eric Duncan | 1B | Adam LaRoche |
| Chris Basak | 2B | Jose Castillo |
| Alberto Gonzalez | SS | Jack Wilson |
| Andy Phillips | 3B | Freddie Sanchez |
| Kevin Reese | LF | Jason Bay |
| Kevin Thompson | CF | Chris Duffy |
| Bronson Sardinha | RF | Xavier Nady |
It may net me a worse record this year, but overall, I’m taking the team on the left. As much as I like Duke, Gorzelanny, and Capps, Scranton’s rotation has a much higher ceiling.
I would have done this comparison with the Nationals…but that would have been a slam dunk.
Google+
7 Comments»
Keep up with RAB
Yankees News from YESNetwork.com
- Gardner lifts Yanks to win in rain-shortened game
- Yankees place Kelly Johnson on 15-day DL
- Headley shines in debut with walk-off hit in 14th
- Brian Cashman relieved to finish a "long journey" towards acquiring Chase Headley
- Yankees acquire 3B Headley in trade with Padres
- Yankees Postgame Notebook: 'This one hurts a little bit'
- Yankees complete sweep with walk-off win
- Yankees sign 26 of 39 draft picks before deadline
- McCarthy quiets Reds in Yanks' 7-1 win
- Yankees react to news of Sabathia's season-ending knee surgery
Banner Design By
The Eric Jagielo Watch
Masthead
The Founders
Mike Axisa, Ben Kabak, Joe Pawlikowski
Editor-In-Chief
Mike Axisa Archives | Email
Managing Editors
Ben Kabak Archives | E-mail
Joe Pawlikowski Archives | E-mail
Technical Manager
Jay Gordon
Beloved Alumni
Larry Koestler (Archives)
Moshe Mandel (Archives)
Eric Schultz (Archives)
Matthew Warden (Archives)
Well, I’d definitely take Bay and Capps over Reese and Beam, but after that, I dunno…
Paulino over Chavez, definitely. Gorzelanny over DeSalvo, though you could tinker with the rotation order and the Yanks would win 5-0. Sanchez over Phillips (though there’s no guarantee that Phillips starts at third).
However, Gonzalez over Wilson, in my opinion, is a no-brainer. Guaranteed the Attorney General would outhit Wilson this season.
I don’t know…
I think I would take the team on the right long term.
I think the Marlins’ ’05 firesale netted more talent than the team on the left and I think a similiar strategy would improve the Pirates (or at least would have improved them this off-season). You build around Bay and Duke, and you do to Ian Snell what the Fish did to Josh Beckett.
[...] P. of River Ave. Blues looks at the Yankees AAA roster and the Pirates major league club side by side. Guess who [...]
Hey RAB people…
I was thinking along these lines over at COH and I think it’s close. The Pirates win because they have the best established Major League talent. You have Bay and LaRoche as proven MLB commodities, FAR better than any of the offensive players on the Yankees side. Paulino is also much better than Chavez. The rest is fairly debatable, but the rotation is probably a knockout for the Yankees. Phil Hughes should be much better than Duke (as good as he may end up being) and the other players are no worse than equal.
Over 162 games, I’d give the Pirates an 89-73 (.550) record. I projected 4.2 runs scored versus 3.8 allowed and did the Pythag. No scientific basis for that. I just thought that the Pirates offense is better than the Yankees by a wider margin that the pitching advantage for the Yankees. Neither team is good enough to score a lot of runs versus the other, so 4.2 vs. 3.8 is the guess.
Good to see you around these parts, Mike. I’m enjoying your work at Baseball Prospectus (when’s the next article coming?).
The rotation was the main reason for the comparison. The only wild card in there is Gorzelanny, and even if I think he’s better than Clippard, it’s still 4-1, Scranton.
Anyone else taking Kevin Thompson at least as a wash with Chris Duffy?
Andy Phillips played third? Or DH?
Also that’s a helluva lot of starting pitchers. I know Cashman has been stockpiling, but I am against an 11-man rotation.