Oct
08
Montero, Romine ranked the two best catchers in the FSL
ByContinuing on with their league top 20′s, Baseball America named Jesus Montero and Austin Romine the second and tenth best prospects, respectively, in the High-A Florida State League. Montero was behind only Mike Stanton of the Marlins, and the pair were the only two catchers to appear on the list. In the subscriber only scouting report, Montero was called “the toughest out in the league,” while Romine was noted as having very few weaknesses in his game.
The Eastern League comes out on Friday, so Montero might be making an encore appearance.
79 Comments»
RAB Info
The Founders
Mike Axisa, Ben Kabak, Joe Pawlikowski
Editor-In-Chief
Mike Axisa Archives | Email
Managing Editors
Ben Kabak Archives | E-mail
Joe Pawlikowski Archives | E-mail
Contributing Editor
Matthew Warden (Archives)
Technical Manager
Jay Gordon
Beloved Alumni
Larry Koestler (Archives)
Moshe Mandel (Archives)
Eric Schultz (Archives)
Subscribe to RAB by RSS
Follow @RiverAveBlues
Search RAB
Loading
Yankees News from YESNetwork.com
- Report: ND to play in Pinstripe Bowl
- Yankees re-sign Kuroda to one-year deal
- Yankees finalize deal with Kelly Johnson
- Report: Granderson signs with Mets
- Yankees welcome McCann to New York
- Yankees Minor Leaguer suspended for drug violation
- Yankees, Ellsbury agree on seven-year deal
- Yanks ink RHP Brian Gordon to Minor League deal
- Yankees announce signing of C McCann
- Yankees sign Canzler to Minor League deal
Banner Design By
Countdown to Spring Training
Just 2 months and 7 days 'til pitchers and catchers report!
Jesus has a chance to be a top 5 prospect in two separate leagues? Next level.
And some of you bastards wanted to trade him for Roy Halladay, because we “needed him” to win this World Series.
You people DISGUST ME! I FART IN YOUR GENERAL DIRECTION!
Well, I’d still make that trade if Montero was the only main piece of it. As in, no other top prospects.
Too good of a trade to pass up.
Montero is a long way from the bigs, and if does not stick at catcher he goes from being amazing prospect to above average prospect, right?
No, he’s still an amazing prospect.
He goes from excellent to just below excellent. A good way to think about it is to look at where other horrible fielding and good hitting prospects have ranked, like Ryan Braun and Matt LaPorta.
Oh, alrighty then.
Good comparison there. Thanks.
Can you imagine if they’d traded for him, and then he’d gone on to have the August he had?
http://www.baseball-reference......;year=2009
There were some BAD starts in there, against Boston and the Rays. People would have been KILLING the guy.
Did anyone notice how he never came out in the middle of an inning?
As soon as he did bad in the start of the all-star game, I knew he couldn’t handle New York.
That’s what happened when he WASNT traded from a team in utter free fall.
How depressing was that?
August is excusable. Remember how he went through those poor starts then shut us down good?
I believe anyone picking him up in August does not see this performance.
That said, Montero’s a beast. For the fans sake and for the future prospects of the club, you keep these guys. Untouchables.
Imagine if Steinbrenner hadn’t been in hot water with Howie Spira / Winfield and had traded his core prsopects for who knows who where the 1995-2001 dynasty would be?
Hands off Montero so long as he remains incredibly awesome.
Fetchez la vache!
Jesus actually played yesterday in the Instructional League and went 1-3 with a 2-run homer.
is there a link with these results?
I read it on pinstripesplus.com
That’s awesome news.
I used to think Daytona was all Pauly Shore and Dan Cortese running around places like this every day, now I just picture Andy running around in his Melvin jersey with a little pad in his hands, taking notes at instructional league games.
There are plenty of Spring Break stories. Now it’s a little of both. You have to have balance in your life. There is always drinking and sun at baseball games.
Dan Cortese
Step off, HCM.
P.S:
A dude I work with also graduated GHS in ’95.
It wasn’t my fault… You asked me for a sandwich… I make such delicious sandwiches…
(I was ’97, not ’95)
You want a rush? Drop a 16 pound ball on your toe! That’s a rush!
(My bad. You’re not old.)
Romine was noted as having very few weaknesses in his game.
Just like the 2009 New York Yankees.
http://www.hiyoooo.com
I think you mean 2009 Red Sox.
/Kruk’d
I read elsewhere that Dellin actually had both Tommy John surgery AND the ligament stabilization surgery. He now has 2 ulnar ligaments in his elbow.
More importantly, did he get ripped in 4 weeks?
Yep, and he worked with pete to get ripped.
The only thing I’d like to see out of Romine next year is an increase in walk rate.
It’s good to hear Montero and (especially) Romine are doing well. Lets hope they continue. If they do, maybe we can say goodbye to our everyday catcher. I won’t miss his “style”, attitude and selfish self-centered ego. I’m tired of his me before the team attitude, and his childish personality. We all know his defense is sub-par; his offense also is over-rated when you drill down into his stats.
Really?
Come on… You at least have to give him credit for finagling a comment about Jorge Posada into a thread about Montero/Romine and managing to keep it somewhat, if tenuously, on-topic.
his offense also is over-rated when you drill down into his stats.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v.....r_embedded (safe)
This is ridiculous on many levels.
Dare I say…batshit insane?
http://failblog.org/
If you read between the lines, you can see what he’s really saying is “I’m overreacting to a borderline HOF catcher being pissed that he’s getting benched in the playoffs and then getting crossed up twice last night”
Did Jorge fuck up yesterday in the game? Yeah. Was the timing particularly bad? Yeah. Is it an accurate portrayal of how he usually does when catching? No.
“… his offense also is over-rated when you drill down into his stats.”
How is his offense overrated? Please… Drill down.
Well, well, he only got 1 hit the other day. Ummmm yeaaaaaa
http://instantcrickets.com/
his offense also is over-rated when you drill down into his stats.
I’m going to give you a little course in offensive statistics for baseball. For the vast majority of offensive statistics, the higher the statistical value, the better you are as an offensive player. Jorge Posada has high offensive values, hence is a very good baseball player (offensively speaking).
I wonder if the timing of this post had to do with Posada’s play yesterday lol
If you are having a bad day and want to feel better about your intelligence or you just want a good laugh check out Kruk’s new article on the Red Sox-Angels series. Some journalistic genius in there.
Can you link it up for us? Navigating espn.com makes my brain cry.
http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/notebook?page=bbtn
It’s one of the worst ‘previews’ I have ever read.
Gracias.
I take it back, no gracias to you. I should know better than to read a Kruk-penned preview. What an irrelevant bunch of drivel.
“Lackey and Josh Beckett are capable of demoralizing a team, and it’s unclear whether the Angels have that shutdown pitcher to counter it.”
last i checked, lackey was on the angels, right?
If Jacoby Ellsbury gets on base. He’s going to steal.
Maybe he meant Lackey could demoralize his own team?
Seriously, though ignoring the “analysis,” and just the writing style is incredibly painful to read. They should at least have a real write formulate Kruk’s ridiculous ideas into a fluent piece.
what “analysis”? a 2-year old could have written that. and it looks like, did.
My favorite was the first paragraph. “The key for the Red Sox this time is pitching” followed by a discussion of Jacoby Ellsbury’s running game.
Work has ESPN blocked, but I’m guessing, because it’s Kruk, it’s all kinds of stupid.
The following is in the same paragraph as, and directly after, “The key for the Red Sox this time is pitching.”
The key for the Red Sox this time is pitching. Jon Lester, who opens the series, has to keep guys off base, especially the guys who can run. Jacoby Ellsbury will be a key factor against Angels starter John Lackey. If Ellsbury gets on base, he’s going to steal. He will need to use his legs to create runs. Even though Lackey struggles against Boston, he has done some pretty good things in the postseason, including when he stepped up in 2002 and the Angels won the World Series.
Okay okay, can we end the discussion about Kruk’s idiocy here? It’s horrendously off topic.
Thanks.
I wonder if Kruk wrote that in crayon on the computer monitor. The editor will off himself later today after the knowledge that this man is being paid hundreds of thousands of dollars for that drivel, festers and sores.
“Another important point the Red Sox must consider is to allow Lester to go deep in the game.”
what does this even mean? i personally think the sox will strongly “consider” it if lester in fact, pitches well.
MY favorite “lackey and Beckett are capable of demoralizing a team and its unclear if the angels have that shutdown pitcher to counter it”
He had to mean Lester. why would you say Lackey is that type of pitcher and say they dont have those types?
“Jon Lester, who opens the series, has to keep guys off base…”
This is not untrue. Kruk’s not always wrong.
http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/notebook?page=bbtn
I know Mike Stanton, and no offense to him, but Montero is the better prospect due to the fact that Stanton strikes out a REDICULOUS rates. I’m going down to Jacksonville next spring again and i will personally count how many times he strikes out. Great guy, but still super raw.
he strikeout rate in the FSL was not terrible. wasn’t until he was promoted to AA that it really spiked up.
I’ve seen first hand in AA how many times he strikes out.
and that’s why he won’t be that level’s top prospect. he was phenomenal in HiA and that’s why he’s the top dog.
But his strikeouts are coupled with absolutely great power and a good walk rate.
And a bad right field. He dropped like 3 fly balls when i was batboying for the Suns (Marlins AA affiliate)
We’re talking about his offense, not his defense, though. It’s also probably not wise to enter into a discussion about defense when saying Montero > Stanton because from what we hear, Montero’s defense isn’t all that wonderful either.
Regardless, each one of these guys has the bat to do some serious damage in AA/AAA and eventually the Majors.
Not to mention insane athleticism.
I dont understand all the talk about moving Montero to left field. isn’t left field in Yankee Stadium harder than right field? If you move to the outfield I woul think right field would make more sense.
I dont care if Montero throws out a ton of guys I would prefer him call a good game, block balls in the dirt. Not many catchers are Pudge Rodriguez or Joe Mauer. I am sure he will produce a lot more runs that he allows.
Also, i know Lucas May (quoted in SI in Mariano issue on being world champion with team USA) the absolute nicest guy you will ever meet.
You’re the man.
Thanks, but how?
Just messing with you.
Big meanie putting down the name dropper.
Heh, I know, that did feel mean. My bad.
what are the chances that Montero is higher than Stanton in the AA list because Montero’s numbers didnt decline while Stanton’s numbers other than just HR’s dropped pretty significantly when he moved up?
100%
They werent in the same AA league, Stanton was in the Southern League.
then greater than 100%
btw, the Southern league list came out and Stanton was “only” 4th, behind some guys named Heyward, Beckham, and Jennings.
See you guys at the live chat!
[...] ranking as the second best prospect in the High-A Florida State League, Jesus Montero followed that up by placing fifth in the Double-A Eastern League, according to [...]