Open Thread: Ace


Ewww. (AP Photo/Charles Krupa)

If you’re reading this site, then there’s little doubt you’re aware of the job Al Aceves did for the Yankees in 2009. He gave the team whatever they needed each time he was called upon, and was probably their most important reliever behind Mariano Rivera. Today’s a bit of an anniversary for Ace, who signed his first professional contract and joined the Blue Jays’ organization ten years ago today. He was 19 at the time. After a year in their system, the Jays sold his rights to the Yucatan Leones of the Mexican League, where he played for the next six seasons before hooking on with the Yanks. As I wrote on Friday, there hasn’t been any update to Aceves’ status this winter since he broke his collarbone in December, but he’ll find a job soon enough. He’s too good not to.

Anyways, here is your open thread for the night. The Rangers, Knicks, and Nets are all playing, so there’s plenty to keep you occupied. Talk about whatever, enjoy.

Categories : Open Thread


  1. steven says:

    he needs 2 return 2 the yanks

  2. vin says:

    Would love to see Aceves make it back to the Yankees. He was a real shot in the arm for that ’09 team. At various points, Girardi used him as a starter, as the first guy out of the pen, as a middle-reliever, as a match-up guy, and as an 8th inning guy. Versatility personified. Oh yeah, he also happend to be pretty effective too.

    • whozat says:

      People, you can’t forget that he spent all of last year out with back injuries. There are decent odds that he’s never effective again. It’s possible he never stays healthy enough to round back into major-league form :-/

      • Xstar7 says:

        Although you’re right, I’d rather take a chance on Aceves. He still has the potential to be a solid bullpen guy and this team looks better with him than without him.

        • whozat says:

          Rather than what? And is there any reason to think the Yanks wouldn’t be happy to give him a minor league deal?

          • Xstar7 says:

            I expect the Yankees (or possibly another team if the Yankees won’t bite) to sign Aceves to a minor league deal. And I’d even rather have him in the rotation than Mitre (If Aceves was healthy of course.)

      • MikeD says:

        Whozat, you’re right. Yet there’s no reason not to want to see him in Yankee camp fighting for a spot on the roster.

  3. Wil Nieves #1 Fan says:

    I love Ace. I hope he recovers and returns to the Yankees in ’09 fashion. Did I mention that I want to bear his children?

  4. squishy jello person says:

    BA prospect books getting shipped today = me happy

  5. Jerome S. says:

    Aceves, to me, is the Peyton to Mitre’s Eli.

  6. Anthony Murillo says:

    Would love to see Aceves back with the Bombers.

  7. Teh Comp Pick says:

    Alfredo Aceves, what good times we had with your 1.01 WHIP in ’09 and all. Not to mention your first name is an awesome albeit unhealthy sauce.

  8. Stratman9652 says:

    So I find it highly amusing that in today’s post about Mitre, Armando Galarraga was by far the worst of the listed stat lines and yet because of one nearly perfect game the fact that he was DFA’d and picked up by the D’backs is big shocking news.

    One game and this guy will be forever regarded as a great pitcher by people that don’t know any better. I have to laugh imagining the narratives that you would hear if the Yankees had picked him up. Then again, the media would have instantly and miraculously realized he isn’t very good.

    • Teh Comp Pick says:

      What if teh Theo picked him up !!11!

    • squishy jello person says:

      Speaking of D-Backs, I love that they said Owings will pitch AND play 1st base

    • Ed says:

      I think the 3.73 ERA / 1.192 WHIP / 121 ERA+ / 4th place ROY season 2 years ago has more to do with people’s perception of him than the near perfect game. The perfect game thing just kept him in people’s minds as he declined.

    • Josh S. says:

      One game and this guy will be forever regarded as a great pitcher by people that don’t know any better.

      Sounds eerily similar to Don Larsen – mediocre pitcher who threw the only perfect game in World Series history.

      • Pounder says:

        Don Larsen was a MUCH better pitcher than Galarraga.Booze and the allure of the social scene in NY derailed his career,He had an outstanding fastball and,when he was on top of his game,was pretty good.

  9. Teh Comp Pick says:

    How do people see this whole Carmelo Anthony thing playing out? How do people rank ‘Melo in the NBA star’osphere and is it a good move for the Knicks basketball wise (given whatever assumptions you deem necessary)?

    • mike c says:

      he wants to play for the knicks… the nuggets front office is a joke, it seems like they saw the lebron debacle and freaked out. so now he’s saying NY or bust, good for him

    • The Real JobaWockeeZ says:

      Advanced stats say his production if just above average. I call BS on that but take my opinion FWIW.

      I definitely think the Knicks should try getting him.

  10. Adam says:

    Besides, if the Ace doesn’t come back, who is going to lead the team in a rousing game of video motorcycling?

  11. tomaconda says:

    Maybe the yanks could sign Ace Ventura? Could use another ace in the rotation!

  12. mike c says:

    aceves had a great season, but I never really was that impressed by his pitching… he did get the job done though and was great. I don’t really see him coming back, his injury sounds like it was fairly severe. if the yankees wouldn’t give chien ming wang a deal I doubt they are going to go for aceves

    • If you weren’t all that impressed by Ace, you probably like throwers more than you do pitchers.

    • SodaPopinski says:

      Clavicle injuries can sound bad, but they heal fairly quickly when treated with plates and screws like he had done in December. These breaks are a very common injury for pro bike riders, and they are allowed back on the bike as soon as they can deal with the pain. This can be as soon as soon as a few weeks after injury (those guys are crazy). Assuming no complications, he’ll be back in 3-4 months- March. The biggest hurdle to overcome in rehab is the stiffness of the immobilized shoulder. Luckily for him, this was his left (non throwing) clavicle, so I’m pretty sure we’ll see him sooner rather than later.

  13. Xstar7 says:

    Does anyone else think Jay Cutler is taking way more heat than he deserves?

    • Steve H says:

      Not only that, but he doesn’t deserve any heat (other than for his play). I can’t stand the guy, but he’s taking a bunch of undeserved shit.

      • mbonzo says:

        Yup, I’m totally with you. I was really rooting against him, because I simply don’t like him, but why would you even want Cutler out there when he could barely walk? On top of that, Hanie looked better than Cutler did all game. People should be mad at Cutler for trying to play as much as he did with Hanie ready to go on the bench.

        • Zack says:

          He got destroyed behind that line all year, imagine if he had no mobility.

          I also like that Maurkic Pouncey left the game with a high ankle sprain and neither Ross Tucker or Mark Schlereth tweeted about how o-lineman only leave the field in a body bag.

    • squishy jello person says:


      And roethlesberger isn’t taking enough

      • Steve H says:

        Roethlisberger is likely a scumbag. That being said, I don’t know why Mark Sanchez gets a free pass for a similar situation in his past.

        • The Real JobaWockeeZ says:

          Because either it’s right or wrong there are people hated more on that team. Ryan and Cromarte come to mind.

        • Poopy Pants says:

          Sanchez had a sexual assault problem? Good to know.

        • mbonzo says:

          Sanchez was never charged for sexual assault, just arrested, and he denies it and says it was the worst day of his life. He just doesn’t seem like the kind of guy to do that, he’s done a lot of charity work in my area.

          Roethlisberger on the other hand has faced rape allegations twice, and although he was never formally charged the NFL thought there was enough evidence to suspend him.

          Basically, Big Ben dealt with it as an NFL player and was accused twice, Sanchez dealt with it when he was 19.

          • Steve H says:

            Roethlisberger also denied it and I’m sure it was the worst day of his life. He has also done a lot of charity work, it doesn’t speak to his guilt or innocence. The NFL thought there was enough evidence to suspend him because Roger Goodell is judge, jury and executioner. He also didn’t suspend him for sexual assault, he was essentially suspended for bringing bad light to the NFL. I don’t know if either of them are guilty, but I’m not ready to convict one and let the other off the hook.

            • mbonzo says:

              Oh I agree with you, innocent until proven guilty. The NFL’s suspension really made him look guilty though. To me, its suspicious that it happened twice, but I’m not going to call him a rapist.

              As for Sanchez, I’m completely biased because he does a lot of work in my town and the surrounding area, even though I’m a Giants fan.

          • Kiersten says:

            So it’s worse for an NFL player to rape someone than a 19 year old college player? Got it.

            • Steve H says:

              And, wouldn’t the NFL star be a bigger target for false allegations* than a 2nd string freshman QB?

              *In no way am I claiming the allegations to be false. Just that an NFL star in general, would be more vulnerable to false allegations.

            • mbonzo says:

              You’re putting words in my mouth. I said that it looks worse for Big Ben because he dealt with it while he was an NFL player twice and got suspended for it publicly. Sanchez dealt with it while he was in College and although he was suspended from that team, he returned as soon as the charges were dropped. I don’t know if anything happened, but it certainly looks worse for Roethlisberger.

          • Zack says:

            He just doesn’t seem like the kind of guy to do that, he’s done a lot of charity work in my area.


            • mbonzo says:

              It was a bit more than charity work. He befriended a kid with cancer and visited him very often. The kid was a huge Mark Sanchez fan and the first time he met him, Sanchez came when he was sleeping and he waited for him to wakeup with a signed football. It was a nice story but the kid passed away on a sunday a few weeks ago right before a game. Sanchez couldn’t come to the funeral but he paid for it all. Now he’s running some sort of charity around here. So yea, I don’t think Sanchez is a scumbag because of sexual assault allegations while he was in college. Seriously.

    • Xstar7 says:

      Check out this Fox sports article on the Cutler situation


      Some people just can’t be reasoned with

    • The Real JobaWockeeZ says:

      I fucking hate Jay Cutler. That being said all of this shit against him is ridiculous.

      • Teh Comp Pick says:

        I don’t think the shit is overwhelming, but no, I also don’t think it is deserved. He has had the insults of outsiders rebuffed by Bears leaders. My own analysis; while I don’t think it’s warranted, this is what happens when you create enemies above a replacement player(CERP), ask A-Rod. If I’m a fan of his I reserve the right to defend him, but from where I stand I say “You made your bed now sleep in it”. Bottom line, Dude has CERP’ed.

    • ZZ says:

      He probably doesn’t deserve this much criticism (likely stemming from the fact he is so disliked), but he definitely deserves to take a lot of heat.

      If you can’t gut it out in a Championship game with an injury as minor as a sprained MCL you deserved to be called out.

      • mbonzo says:

        So lets assume his knee was so bad he couldn’t plant his leg to throw. Why would you want him playing on your team in a championship game if he can’t even throw the ball?

    • bonestock94 says:

      He’s a tool, no.

    • bexarama says:

      There was an ESPN poll that asked which QB was the least likable: Cutler, Vick, or Rothelsberger*. Cutler won. That kind of said it all.

      I mean, I don’t like the guy at all, both because he seems like a jackass and because I’m a Packers fan, but he plays with diabetes and he gets sacked a billion times a year. His injury apparently wasn’t too minor. He’s tough.

      * I am sure I spelled that wrong.

      • Xstar7 says:

        REALLY? People like Michael Vick and Ben Rothlissburger better than Jay Cutler? I must be missing something. I don’t know much about Cutler but from the look of that poll he must be a real dick. He still doesn’t deserve all the shit he’s getting though. If he had stayed in the game he would have just hurt the team and his replacement almost won the game so Bears fans shouldn’t be complaining.

      • bexarama says:

        oh and also Cutler got compared to Bartman by the Chicago media, in Chicago saying someone is like Bartman is like only slightly better than calling them a Nazi

  14. Xstar7 says:

    Apparently Aceves wears the #91 in honor of Dennis Rodman. Who would have thought?

  15. mbonzo says:

    Yankees should take a gamble on Justin Duchscherer. If he’s healthy, and he’s only recovering from hip surgery at this point, he passes the better than Mitre test.

    • Teh Comp Pick says:

      Agree 100%… I get the feeling he doesn’t want in the fold, but I hope he is.

      • MikeD says:

        He hasn’t signed with any team. I think it’s simply a gap in what he wants and what teams (including the Yankees) are offering. I mean, when was his last truly healthy, full season? 2005? 2006? I’d be happy to see him in camp. Just not sure how much we could count on, especially as a starting candidate.

    • whozat says:

      They’ve expressed interest, we heard that a while ago. It’s possible the medicals don’t check out, or it might be that yeah…he just wants to play somewhere less pressurized.

  16. C-Mac says:

    So my less intelligent friends are all like “THE YANKS SHOULD SIGN PUJOLS WHEN HE’S AN FA.” And I just can’t come up with enough to say that will shut them up. I’ve even had a friend suggest moving A-Rod to RF (the cannon arm), so that Tex can shift to 3rd, and Pujols play first.

    Will this madness only get worse if the Cards don’t sign Pujols to an extension?

  17. MikeD says:

    I love the concept of the MLB Network, but it is beyond painful that I have to listen to Mitch Williams and Kevin Millar talk as if they have knowledge we should respect. They don’t.

  18. pete c says:

    Aceves has all the makings of a major league starter. 4 pitch pitcher, able to hit spots, and a pretty good temperament(see his versatility in 09). The injuries in ’10 were a major setback in his career. This guy should have been the #5 starter for the second half of 2009, and really outpitched Hughes and everyone else in spring training last year. One or two bad starts at the end were what made the difference between he and Hughes ending up in the rotation. To consider guys like Sergio Mitre and Ivan Nova and NOT consider a guy that was a legitimate force in 2009 and came very close to being a starter in 2010 is downright stupid. But then again, nothing surprises me with the Yanks this year. Sign him to a low guarantee, incentive laden contract or a minor league deal if he’ll agree to it and lets see what he can do.

  19. AndrewYF says:

    I read Steven Goldman’s chat over at BP, and he said it, and I’ve seen it been said all over the place. The meme right now about the Yankees is that they distrust their young pitchers and will never let them get a chance.

    Now, this is somewhat valid given the Chamberlain fiasco (although honestly, it’s a completely isolated case), but exactly which pitchers are they supposed to ‘trust’? They’re already all but handing their 24-year old Nova a starting gig. Phil Hughes is all of 25 in June and he’s the projected number 2 starter. Are they supposed to call up Andrew Brackman, who has pitched all of 14 games above single-A? Or David Phelps, who doesn’t project any better than Mitre? Or how about Dellin Betances or Manny Banuelos, who combined have less experience above single-A than Brackman? Wasn’t it the most recent meme that the Yankees ruined Hughes and Chamberlain by rushing them to the majors in an act of desperation? And now that they want to protect their young, undeveloped, high-ceilinged arms by leaving them in the minors, that’s a sign that they distrust their young pitchers and will never let them get a chance?

    I can’t stand the MSM. I really cannot.

Leave a Reply

You may use <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> in your comment.

If this is your first time commenting on River Ave. Blues, please review the RAB Commenter Guidelines. Login for commenting features. Register for RAB.