Comparing Teixeira’s Contract To Fielder’s

Pondering the three without options
Thinking About Andre Ethier
Don't hate on my MS Paint skills. (Both photos via AP)

In perhaps the most extreme case of overreaction in baseball history, the Tigers signed Prince Fielder to a nine-year, $214M contract two weeks ago after learning that Victor Martinez would miss the season with a knee problem. It’s the fourth largest contract in baseball history, and like many of you, I couldn’t help but think that Mark Teixeira eight-year, $180M contract suddenly looked a whole lot better by comparison. Fielder is the better player at the moment, but Teixeira didn’t get his contract at the moment. He signed it three years ago.

Given the enormous outlays, let’s compare the two players and their contracts. To do this, we’re going to go back in time a bit and look at the player Teixeira was when he signed his contract, because that’s more applicable when comparing these massive deals. He was 28 years old when the Yankees signed him prior to 2009, a year older than Fielder is right now. Both guys are Scott Boras clients, so that makes the comparison a little easier. With all due respect, no agent is as successful as Boras when it comes to getting top dollar.

We’re going to break the comparison into four sections: offense, baserunning, defense, and durability. The first three are self-explanatory, and durability is quite underappreciated in my opinion. If you’re giving out contracts like these, you want to be damn sure the player can stay on the field. Let’s start with the money-makers, the bats…


’06-’08 Teixeira 0.298 0.393 0.541 141 0.244 0.395 139 16.8% 11.3%
’09-’11 Fielder 0.287 0.409 0.547 155 0.260 0.403 153 18.0% 12.7%

Both players are well above average offensively, both in terms of getting on-base and launched baseballs into orbit. Teixeira was approximately 40% better than league average back in the day while Fielder is roughly 50% better than league average today, so Prince is the better hitter by a not small margin. It is worth noting that Teixeira is a switch-hitter, and back then he had a relatively small platoon split (134 wRC+ vs. RHP and 148 vs. LHP from ’06-’08). Fielder is a lefty and has shown a somewhat significant split throughout over the last three years (168 wRC vs. RHP but 119 vs. LHP). He’s the better hitter, but the switch-hitting thing is a definite plus for Tex.


’06-’08 Teixeira 4 0 100% 40% -0.8
’09-’11 Fielder 4 4 50% 19% -16.4

Baserunning is an important part of the game, but it really doesn’t have as much impact as you might think. The different between the best and worst baserunners in a given season will be something like 30 runs, and we’re talking Michael Bourn vs. Jorge Posada type of stuff. Most players are within five runs of league average (one way or the other) with few outliers.

He’s slow and he makes funny faces when he runs, but Teixeira was a pretty good baserunner once upon a time. He took the extra base 40% of the time from 2006-2008 (meaning he went first-to-third on a single, first-to-home on a double, etc.), ever so slightly above the league average (39%). Fielder is well below average on the bases, taking the extra roughly half as often as the average player (league average is 41% these days). In terms of runs created on the bases (that’s BsR), Tex was essentially league average again while Fielder was well below. We’re talking a 15 or so run difference between the two players over a three-year span, or five runs a year. None a huge difference, but a difference nonetheless.

Just ignore the stolen base stuff, neither of these guys are asked to do much of that.


’06-’08 Teixeira 17 16 21.1 3.7 14.5
’09-’11 Fielder -10.8 -15 -25.8 -11.9 -15.9

Advanced fielding metrics aren’t perfect, especially for first baseman. They are useful over large samples though, especially in conjunction with the ol’ eye test. Teixeira is a great fielder and always has been by reputation, and the numbers back that up. Fielder is the opposite, a poor defender with the reputation to match. You can quibble with the exact numbers if you want, but they pass the sniff test. A 30 or so run gap is significant, even when talking about a three-year stretch.


Games Games Started DL trips Days on DL Day-to-Days
’06-’08 Teixeira 451 440 1 37 10
’09-’11 Fielder 485 481 0 0 5

Durability is a skill to a certain extent, and like I said earlier, I think it’s underappreciated. Fielder is arguably the most durable position player in the sport right now, appearing in all but one game over the last three years and starting all but five of them. That’s pretty amazing. Teixeira missed more than five weeks with a quad strain in 2007, but otherwise he appeared in 162 and 157 games in 2006 and 2008, respectively.

This is a pretty good spot to talk about the body types, because they are important. Teixeira’s got the prototypical robot baseball player build, meaning 6-foot-3 and 220 lbs., with less body fat than I have in my left thigh. Fielder’s a portly little guy, listed on the Tigers official site at 5-foot-11 and 275 lbs. That doesn’t mean he’s out of shape — there’s a difference between being fat and being out of shape — but his body is absolutely a concern going forward. All that extra weight can lead to knee and back problems later in his career. Three years ago (and even today), no one had any reason to be concerned about Teixeira physically.

Adding up the WARs

fWAR bWAR WARP Average
’06-’08 Teixeira 15.0 16.1 12.5 14.5
’09-’11 Fielder 15.3 14.0 12.9 14.1

As far as I’m concerned, there’s no difference between 14.5 and 14.1 WAR. The various WAR models just aren’t accurate enough to get worked up over a four run difference. All this tells us is that Teixeira’s fielding and baserunning closed the gap between his offense and Fielder’s, nothing more. This is how each player performed in the three years leading up to their free agency, not an indication of how they’re likely to perform going forward. It might give you an idea of what to expect in the future, but make that assumption at your own risk.

At the end of the day, we have two very similar players in 2006-2008 Teixeira and 2009-2011 Fielder. Both guys were top ten draft picks once upon a time, both play the same position, both are young and very much in the primes of their careers, and both have provided the same amount of value in the three years leading up to their free agency. They’re both $100M+ players, no doubt about that. Going forward though, wouldn’t you rather have the switch-hitter than provides better defense and has the better body? I know I would.

In many ways, Fielder’s contract is one of Boras’ best. He got Teixeira 8/180 when both the Yankees and Red Sox were heavily involved in the bidding, but then three years later he got Fielder 9/214 with almost no big money teams in the market for the first baseman. Convincing the Tigers to sign Prince to that contract when they already had a better player with his own nine-figure contract at the same position is nothing short of player representation genius in my book.

Pondering the three without options
Thinking About Andre Ethier
  • Rich in NJ

    Nine years is a long time for a player with a sub-optimal body type, but in terms of age and skill, not many impact hitters under 30 are reaching free agency.

    • CP

      a player with a sub-optimal body type,

      That’s like saying the Titanic had a sub-optimal outcome.

      • MannyGeee

        too sooon!!!

  • JohnC

    agreed. I’d take Tex’s contract any day, especially if he is true to his word about taking the ball the other way and even bunting to try and take away that overshift. Defensively, he’s miles above Fielder

    • William

      But he’s declining. Tex, in a couple of years, will look severely overpaid. Then again, so will fielder, in about 4 Years, The moral? Don’t give out massive contracts.

  • AJavierkei Pavagawnett

    The Tigers will be lucky to get 5 or 6 years of similar-level production out of fielder, then most likely he will be DHing.

    With how you value what he does towards the end of this contract, they are probably paying $35+ mil/year for him in his prime.

    Crazy contract.

    • CJ

      That’s 5-6 years of the Yankees facing Cabrera/Fielder possibly in a 5 game ALDS with Verlander pitching twice.

      • Rey22

        Not quite. I believe a new rule was implemented that the best record in the league can now face the Wild Card team even if they are from the same league, so for the Yankees and Tigers to meet in the DS, the Yankees would have to have the best record and the Tigers would have to win the wild card, or the other way around. That or the Yankees and Tigers win their divisions but the team in the AL West has the best record and faces the wild card. Those situations seem less likely than all the other outcomes.

        • AJavierkei Pavagawnett


          The Big Papi/ Adrian Gonzalez combo had a monster year in 2011. How did the Red Sox season go again?

          The bottom line is that the besides Verlander, Cabrera, and Fielder the Tigers need 6 other position players, 4 other starters, and a DH.

          Dropping that type of cash limits what they can do going forward unless they are willing to upgrade to a Red Sox level payroll.

          Are they going to be resigning to be able to resign their young starting pitching?

          The back end of Prince’s contract will be very ugly. The question is how he does in the middle years.

  • YanksFanInBoston

    I was trying to compare this myself a couple of days ago. Thank god I found this article, made it much easier.

    After reading this, it makes me not feel as mad about Tex having an off year last year, at least by his standards. Actually makes me appreciate him a little more :)

  • MattG

    Things Tex does great as a fielder:

    * he has phenomenal, soft hands. I am very impressed at how he catches bad hops, tricky hops, and smashes, often while horizontal. Its awesome.

    * he also brings phenomenal effort, and it’s not all in the facial expressions. The guy plays first base like his newborn is napping behind him.

    Ways in which Tex is overrated as a fielder:

    * he does not have nearly the amount with which people credit him. He is a step-and-a-dive guy. Nothing wrong with that, but too many people think he is more, which irks me.

    * despite the soft hands, he is actually quite average on the balls in the dirt. I don’t understand why he sweeps his glove the way he does. If he played them like he plays hot smashes off the bat, he’d have a lot more success.

    I like the numbers the metrics produced. I do believe he contributes one win above the average on defense.

    • MattG

      * he does not have nearly the amount of range with which people credit him…

  • mike

    They also fit different purposes in the lineup – having a switch hitter helps with matchups, and makes life more difficult on the opposing manager in terms of LOOGY etc.

    Tex is a perfect guy for the Yankee middle of the order, as he can split Grandy and Cano if facing a tough lefty – even though the Yanks arent always succeptable to the L/L issue.

  • CJ

    Prince Fielder can replace Big Papi as the reason for the Yankees revolving door quest for a LOOGY.

    • Rey22

      I think Big Papi continues to replace Big Papi as the reason for the LOOGY. They’ll see him way more than Fielder.

      • RetroRob

        Ha! In that case, it probably would be cheaper (and more productive) for Cash to sign Big Papi than to continue trying to pay for bad LOOGY’s! Let’s shift the AL East LOOGY burden to Boston!

        Too bad Big Papi didn’t opt to become a free agent. The Yankees had no opening for him up until the trade of Montero.

        • AJavierkei Pavagawnett


          It would have been great to steal him from the Red Sox. Maybe next year, fiscal austerity be damned.

  • RetroRob

    There’s been a lot written over the past year about Teixeira’s pull-happy approach from the leftside. I ran across this excellent piece this morning on the Captain’s Blog (very thoughtful blog) that suggests Teixeira’s problem is not pulling the ball into the shift, but that he’s had more problems trying to go the other way with the shift. Seems counter intuitive, and I’m not exactly sure what it means, but it is interesting and worth the read.

  • dean

    One thing though is that 3 years from now I think Prince will be better than a .220 hitter vs RHP…..which you face most of the time.

  • Brian in NH

    I know that Base running on an individual level isn’t a huge impact, but if you can pack your team with enough guys that are good base runners (+5 from league average), you’ve added maybe 4-6 wins in a season on to your team versus a team of average base runners. that definitely helps in divisions with close playoff races (like the AL East and WC)

  • Doug

    I thought “the most extreme case of overreaction in baseball history” was the Yanks signing Igawa after losing out on Matsuzaka