Jorge Posada and the contusion of doom


When a Jeremy Guthrie fastball tailed in on Jorge Posada and hit him above the knee on Wednesday night, the Yanks’ catcher was clearly in pain. He walked slowly down to first base, limped awkwardly to second and eventually scored but with Curtis Granderson right behind him. He never made it back into the lineup.

Yesterday, the Yanks said Posada was day-to-day. Supposedly, he could have caught in an emergency, but the pain and swelling in the area around his fibular head was substantial. He probably won’t play this evening either, and no one is sure how long he’ll be out. Today, in his Under the Knife column, Baseball Prospectus’ Will Carroll sheds some light on the injury:

Ben Wolf … points out something about Posada getting hit by a pitch Wednesday that hadn’t occurred to me: “Was reading your latest column and saw that Posada was hit in the fibular head (I had just read knee in the general news). Even if there isn’t a fracture, there’s a risk of the injury being more of a long-term problem if he ends up with any restriction in the superior tibiofibular joint, especially considering the demands of a catcher squatting on the knee (including that joint specifically I think), not to mention any mechanistic problems he could have running. I suppose we will see.” …Posada says he could catch if it was an emergency, but it’s clear that it’s the squatting that’s the problem. We’ll see how the Yankees deal with this over the weekend, but expect Posada to miss time. At best, he could DH, but I think they’ll hold on to the retro DL move until they’re more sure.

I’m not entirely sure who Ben Wolf is but initial Google searches indicate a Ben Wolf associated with Medtronic. We can apply his views broadly to see how the Yanks treat Posada over the next few days.

For the Yankees, Jorge Posada is a key offensive piece of their puzzle. On the young season, he’s hitting .316/.400/.649, and his success makes it easy to overlook Mark Teixeira‘s struggles and A-Rod‘s recent hitless streak. With Posada out of the lineup and Cervelli in, the bottom of the order looks significantly weaker even if the team’s defense — and overall base running — improves.

The team should give Jorge some time to heal, and if he misses 15 days, it’s not the end of the world. He was on the shelf for 25 days last May, and the Yanks managed without him. Cervelli will get the bulk of the player time, and the team will bring up Chad Moeller to serve as a backup if Posada must be DL’d.

For now, it’s just a bruise, but by the end of the weekend, we’ll know more. If Jorge doesn’t see game action this weekend, I’d expect a trip to the disabled list. Even if he’s available to pinch hit or DH, the team can ill afford Ramiro Peña as their backup catcher for an extended period of time.

Categories : Injuries


  1. If Jorge does go on the DL, the cries to bring up Montero will be loud, I suspect.

    Which is of course foolish, but hey, such is life.

    (He’s not been Shiva Destroyer of Worlds in AAA yet, either.)

  2. Steve H says:

    When does his agent send out photos of the bruise, ala Brett Favruh?

  3. Jose says:

    Fun fact: The superior tibiofibular articulation takes about 20% of the total static load applied to the ankle.

    I’m really hoping the injury was localized and is minor. Any type of injury elsewhere could really cause Jorge to struggle to catch. The weight of his body would be much more difficult to appropriately distribute if the injury is any worse.

  4. Evan NYC says:

    Odds that Jones/Markakis/Weiters get drilled next week?

    • Probably slim. The Yanks don’t need to start a fight or generate suspensions. The only player on the Yanks’ shit list should be Dallas Braden right now.

      • mike c says:

        I can’t wait until he comes to YSIII, I want to see an epic meltdown

      • Evan NYC says:

        I think the veteran pitchers will know better, but if it comes down to a late inning match up I could see Joba or Robertson hitting someone for sure.

      • Guest says:

        The amazing thing about the Braden incident is, even assuming he’s right, doesn’t his ludicrous overreaction make him look like the idiot of the whole affair? I don’t think I’ve ever seen a pitcher flip out over ANYTHING to that extent, up to and including watching and styling on HR’s. Even if it is a sin, is it a screaming and yelling and throwing equipment and pretty much promising to hit a batter the next time your face him level sin? I guess it is in many people’s minds if the perpetrator is A-Rod.


    (Jose Jesus Gil, of course. I hope that’s what the middle initial J stands for. It makes my joke work better.)

  6. YankeeScribe says:

    Tex and A-Rod need to get into mid-season form NOW

  7. We should just have John Sterling catch until Jorge’s ready again.

    He’s part of the team, after all.


  8. mike c says:

    bring up ike davis

  9. So, who’s getting DFA’d to make room for Moeller?

    Albaladejo? Golson? Huffman?

    Or, the perpetually injured Chris Garcia? Can we still activate Garcia, move him to the 60-day DL, and then add Moeller?

  10. dkidd says:

    si cover jinx. the other three better watch their backs

    /weak minded’d

Leave a Reply

You may use <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> in your comment.

If this is your first time commenting on River Ave. Blues, please review the RAB Commenter Guidelines. Login for commenting features. Register for RAB.