Yankees quiet as 2011 trade deadline passes


This seemed unthinkable a few days/weeks/months ago, but the Yankees did not make a single move before today’s 4:00pm ET non-waiver trade deadline. Several reporters have confirmed it in case you were holding out hope that something happened under-the-radar. It’s the first time since 2002 that they didn’t make any kind of move in late-July.

The Yankees talked with the Rockies about Ubaldo Jimenez, with the Dodgers about Hiroki Kuroda, with the Astros about Wandy Rodriguez, and I’m sure many other clubs about many other players, but none of the returns justified the cost. Waiver trades can still happen in August t(hat’s how the Yankees got Chad Gaudin two seasons ago), and Wandy’s contract will certainly clear waivers. He’s not completely out of play yet. What you see is what you’re getting though, this is the team the Yankees will likely finish the season with.

Categories : Asides, Trade Deadline


  1. Cy Pettitte says:

    whatevs, i’m totally over it.

  2. Dave says:

    Pssst. It’s “quiet” and not “quite”.

  3. Jack Merridew says:

    Once Jiminez went there was no available pitcher better than Ivan Nova. Unfortunately, the MLB club doesn’t see Nova as their 4th best starter even though the numbers show he has been this season and Nova will probably be sent down again.

  4. Brian S. says:

    Not happy with Bedard to the Red Sox.

    • FIPster Doofus says:

      Same. I was perfectly content with doing nothing and then that news came over the wire. Bedard is very good if healthy. Obviously, his health is a huge question mark, but it doesn’t appear that Boston gave up much. Worthwhile gamble.

      • The Fallen Phoenix says:

        I guess Red Sox finally got their answer to Bartolo Colon? Not that this was a bad deal – depending on what the Sox gave up, it’s probably a medium-risk move to bolster what has suddenly become a rather fragile rotation.

        Seems like they were more desperate to make a move for a starting pitcher than the Yankees were, imo, given their targets.

        • Mike says:

          I wouldn’t call it desperate to trade the prospects they gave up. I never heard of them. I call it a smart move. They gave up close to nothing.

    • GT Yankee says:

      I’m so with you on this one Brian. We should have able to pull off at least a secondary trade. Choate, Thornton, Bedard. The Sox, that were already better then us now have added a tough lefty who although fragile, can be shutdown. I wouldn’t want to have to face Bedard in a playoff series at YS and now my guess is we will. After two failures with Lee and now this perhaps it’s time to “Cash Out” and give Damon O. a shot as everyone else seems to want him. Not giving up top prospects for a ? is great, but standing pat totally is unacceptable.

      • Cuso says:


      • Dropped Third Superstar says:

        You are telling me you would shudder facing Bedard in the playoffs at yankee stadium??? That would be a gift if that happened!

        • GT Yankee says:

          I’ll be sure and remind you of your post Third when we march Freddy out against them.

          • Dropped Third Superstar says:

            Yea when freddy goes out there and gives up 3 over 6-7 frames, like he has done in almost every start this year and the inconsistent bedard struggles…. remind me

          • Dave says:

            Garcia > Bedard.

            • GT Yankee says:

              Some people are really high on Kool-Aid. Anyone want me to pull Freddy’s numbers against 1st and 2nd place teams this year? Just like beating up on the O’s….it ain’t no thing.

              • Dropped Third Superstar says:

                Pull them up I’m actually curious

                • GT Yankee says:

                  Okay, as promised. Since May ’11

                  AL East
                  Boston 6/7 1.2 IP 4ER Loss
                  Boston 5/15 5.1 IP 4ER Loss
                  (Yankees in 2nd)

                  AL Central
                  Detroit 5/4 7.0 IP 4ER Loss
                  Clevland 6/12 6.2 IP 1ER Win

                  AL West
                  Texas-No Starts
                  LA Angels-No Starts

                  That’s a combined record of 1-3, 20.2 IP 13 ER
                  I believe that puts his ERA at a bit over 6.00
                  1 Quality Start

                  Any additional thoughts?

                    • GT Yankee says:

                      Is that “Small Sample Size”

                      or “Sucky Shit Sample”?

                      You’re right….we should flush those 4 games
                      Especially the two against our main rival

                    • Xstar7 says:

                      Small sample size.

                      We shouldn’t flush those 4 starts, but they also don’t mean he couldn’t possibly toss a gem against the Red Sox or Tigers on any given night (or in the playoffs.)

                    • GT Yankee says:

                      Well, I hope you are right, but unfortunately believe that will not be the case.

                      We’ll get a preview very soon

                      Saturday @ Red Sox: Freddy Garcia or Sabathia
                      Sunday @ Red Sox: Garcia or Sabathia

      • Pasqua says:

        I would face Bedard, with confidence, every day of the week. The man has not been a top-of-the-line starter for years. He’s NEVER healthy (almost literally never) and, when on the mound, has not done anything overly impressive since his days with Baltimore. No worries here.

        • GT Yankee says:

          Unlike Freddy the man has quality starts against quality teams. The fact that he is left handed for YS is a plus for reducing short porch home runs from left handed hitters

          Yes….his start yesterday sucked coming off the DL. However here’s some info prior to that:

          Month of May, 5 Earned Runs in 5 Starts!
          Month of June, 8 Earned Runs in 5 Starts!

          64.1 Innings Pitched-13 Earned Runs= 1.86 ERA
          Yeah, you’re right, that’s not at impressive

          • Pasqua says:

            First, you can do away witht he sarcasm, dude. Don’t insult my intelligence. Second, you are going to cite two months of work as a reason that he’s top flight? The man is made of glass. His lack of statistics while on the DL would back that up. Is he good when he’s pitching? Sometimes. Talented? Yup. Healthy? Never.

            • GT Yankee says:

              I wasn’t being sarcastic….just guessing you didn’t look at/see many Mariner games this year or see boxscores

              Reality is for a two month span he was one of the best lefthanded pitchers in the AL

  5. Mark says:

    Free Jesus!

  6. Midland TX says:

    The Yankees are quite what?

    I am not heartbroken over Bedard. Maybe Ed Wade needs a few days or weeks for his wounded pride to stop stinging, and then Houston will be realistic about a reasonable amount of cash or prospects to include in a W-Rod deal.

  7. Drew says:

    worst trading deadline





    • billysbartender says:

      gotta give that award to ’08. Cash traded McCutcheon and Tabata and Karstens for Xavier Nady and Craig Wilson. Then he traded Farnsworth (whom I hated but was pitching very well at the time) for a completely useless Pudge Rodriguez lookalike. The season turned for the worse and they didn’t make the playoffs for the first time since 1993.

      • Ray the Anti-Handle says:

        The Yankees never had McCutchen…

        • Andrew518 says:

          Pretty sure Ohlendorff was the other piece of the trade not McCutchen…

          also I thought this is where Damaso Marte came from, yeah I know easy to forget about him..

          Despite inacurate details I would agree that this was a pretty bad trade, but what about…


        • Thomas Cassidy says:

          They did. Daniel McCutchen.

  8. Gerald Williams (Yankee Legend) Needs a Monument says:

    Jesus walks…. it’s time! Let’s give him a shot.

  9. Ryan 407 says:

    Unreal. I hope Cashman walks at the end of the season.

  10. Granderslam says:

    Jesus better be in pinstripes….tomorrow.

    • Jack Merridew says:

      I agree. Cashman said they have been keeping him down in the event of a trade. Now there’s no reason to keep guys like him and Nova down in AAA for worse players like Cervelli and Hughes.

      • Midland TX says:

        Yes, the offense looked anemic scoring 7.5 runs a game this past series, 2nd in MLB in Runs Scored and OPS, 1st in HRs and Run Differential. With A-Rod out of the lineup. So with another infielder possibly day-to-day with a bruised finger, we definitely need an unproven C/1B/DH…tomorrow.

        • Granderslam says:

          No one said the offense is anemic. It just provides a bit of a spark down the stretch and there are no more reasons for him to play in the minors. Bring him up.

          • Midland TX says:

            The reasons are he’s awfully young for level, his recent performance hasn’t been impressive, he’s better off playing every day than riding the pine as 24th or 23rd man, and if you read between the lines with the “bored” thing then he might not have the maturity yet to handle an everyday role with the big club.

        • Jonathan says:

          Better than proven to fucking suck. And wtf does a day to day finger injury have anything to do with replacing two weaknesses with one player (right handed DH/part time C)? You’re telling me you’d rather keeping giving those guys AB’s over “unproven” Montero?

          Cervelli .295 wOBA with below average defense
          Martin .310 wOBA with good enough defense
          Posada .307 wOBA and -0.4 WAR

          • Midland TX says:

            Posada’s wOBA against righties is .348, Andruw Jones’ against lefties is .380. That’s more than adequate for DH when you mix in the regulars getting a half-day out of the field.

            Yeah, a 21-year-old with 363 lifetime PAs at AAA, and who’s OPSing .770 with 10 HRs and 77 Ks, is unproven.

            Sorry if you don’t understand the difference between a major-league player and a prospect. The reason you don’t rush him up is because you don’t have to.

        • GT Yankee says:

          Let’s call a spade a spade….they did it AGAINST THE O’s!!!!! Let’s see how we fair against the Sox and Rangers next out. To me, taking out a last place team that is 23 games back multiple times is not a great accomplishment. Please let’s not delude ourselves into thinking things are okay….They clearly are not.

          • AaronGuielWithASmile says:

            We’re only 6.5 games ahead in the wild card race.

            CLEARLY things are not okay.

            • GT Yankee says:

              So Aaron tell me

              1. Are you okay with getting the Wild Card alone? If so stop, if not not go to question

              2. As you are not okay with just the wild card, how do you feel we match up against the Rangers and the Sox for the playoffs given our trading inactivity?

              I once argued with a Braves fan who tried to tell me how successful the Braves were in the 90′s under Bobby Cox winning pennant after pennant after being favored to win the WS many of those years.

              Sorry, for some of us a “Wild Card” isn’t enough

              • JMK says:

                Wild Card means jack shit. Get to the playoffs.

                You must be tired dreaming up new ways to say the same stupid things.

              • Charlie says:

                so what is enough? a pennant and then a loss in the 1st round? ill take the wild card and a deep run any day, thank you very much.

              • Pasqua says:

                As the Wild Card system is currently constrcuted, yes, many of us are perfectly content with a Wild Card appearance. The division proves, again and again, to be virtually meaningless.

  11. Donny says:

    Fine with that… Give it a run with this team and if the pitching doesnt hold up, go get C.J. Wilson (proven AL pitcher) for nuthin’ but money…

    CC, AJ, CJ, 2 of Hughes/Nova/Betances/Banuelos/Warren etc.

  12. Gerald Williams (Yankee Legend) Needs a Monument says:

    Bedard sucks the sox can have his broken @$$

    • Wooderson says:

      fuckin A, take him

    • Jonathan says:

      Yup totally agree. I mean lefties who strike out almost a batter per inning with good walk rates are just WORTHLESS….You can say he’s a risk. You can say he’s a clubhouse cancer. You can say he won’t hold up…but one thing you can’t say is he sucks. He’s very very talented and would have been a decent addition to us and possibly put in the pen in the playoffs worst healthy case scenario.

  13. Freddy Garcia's 86 mph Heat says:

    Jesus time.

  14. Ca$hman says:

    “Damn, I didn’t know he was even available. And him, I thought they wanted more than that, so I didn’t even bother. Oh damn, I screwed the pooch on this one. Oh well, at least I have some ambien.”

  15. The Fallen Phoenix says:

    Yankees didn’t have to make a move, so this isn’t totally surprising. Contrary to popular belief, the Yankees just didn’t have any needs to fill at this deadline. Sure, rotation insurance would have been nice, but just that – nice. Aside from Jimenez, there weren’t any top-of-the-rotation starters available, and there seem to be legitimate reasons why the Yankees balked at him (asking price, medical concerns).

    Far from the worst trade deadline ever, in my opinion.

    • Wooderson says:

      this, in my opinion, is one of the best deadlines. the yankees are so rich in the farm that the right move this year was keeping them (considering the options out there). very pleased to see the new approach. jesus is coming…

    • Ryan 407 says:

      They didn’t have any needs? Stop. You’re counting on on Bartolo Colon, Freddy Garcia, Phil Hughes to give you innings, and AJ Burnett to be effective.

      • ItsATarp says:

        And ubaldo or Bedard would have zoo much more of a sure thing.

      • The Fallen Phoenix says:

        Yes, I am. Who should the Yankees have gotten for Bartolo Colon insurance? Erik Bedard? Who’s just as much – if not more – of a ticking health time bomb? Please.

        Freddy Garcia has proven that he can be effective over a full season – just look at his performance last year. He should stop being included in this “pixie dust” meme, because he’s a proven mid-rotation starter at this stage of his career.

        Burnett is what he is, which is…again, a serviceable midrotation starter.

        So, again, what did the Yankees need? An ace? They’ve got one in CC Sabathia (arguably the best pitcher in the AL this year). A no. 2 starter? Say what you want about Bartolo Colon’s health moving forward, but he’s been that this season.

        Bullpen help? Please, they have one of the best bullpens in the AL.

        Lineup help? Please, they have the second best offense in the AL, and can acquire the best hitting prospect in the AL simply by promoting him from AAA, at no cost to either the big league club or the farm system.

        Bench help? The Yankees aren’t going to win or lose the World Series on the strength of their bench.

        So, okay, what were the Yankees needs again? Remember, they still have the best run differential in the AL. Looks like the Yankees should have been shopping for luxuries, not needs, and it looks like that’s exactly what Cashman did.

        • GT Yankee says:

          We needed another lefty to shut down the left-handed bats the Sox have for playoff games at the stadium. As the Yanks will end up being the wild card C.C. would start the first game at Fenway. Gonzalez, Ortiz, Crawford and Ellsbury would be licking their chops facing one of the Yankees right-handed pitching 3rd of 4th options with the short porch in RF.

          No matter now though….at this point I don’t think we’re getting past the Rangers.

          • Midland TX says:

            This isn’t a post for River Ave. Blues but rather River Avenue Bipolar Disorder.

          • Clearly, there is no comparison. Sox are better because of their GM wearing out Cashman and the weak Girardi. We have powerhouses Noesi, Sergio Mitre(sure to return and contribute several homeruns against us), Logan who is throwing batting practice, etc. I would honestly take my chances with Banuelos vs. Boston just to throw an unknown into the mix after CC.

            Obviously people don’t want our over-hyped minor leaguers. They obviously don’t want to deal with Cashman. Hughes would have been ok if they’d have left him alone earlier as a reliever, where he shined….


        • Jonathan says:

          whistle in the dark all you want…we had plenty of needs. #2 SP, DH if they refuse to use Montero, LOOGY etc. Just because we aren’t the Astros doesn’t mean we didn’t have legitimate needs that will most likely be exposed to death in the playoffs vs legitimate offenses. I’m sure you’ve very confident with Boone Logan facing off against Crawford/Ellsbury/Ortiz/AGonz in a tied game 7. And we already have plenty of “legitimate mid rotation starters”. But when is the last time mid rotation starters are what won in the post season?

          • The Fallen Phoenix says:

            2009, with AJ Burnett and Andy Pettitte. Before that? 2008, with the crap the Phillies threw behind Cole Hamels. Before that? Yeah, I can do this for hours.

            And if Boone Logan is facing off against Crawford (lol), Ellsbury, Ortiz, and Gonzalez over CC Sabathia in Game 7, well, something probably went wrong long before that.

        • Dan from boston says:

          Your very polite with your please!!

          Good deadline for the Yankees.

          Everyone is so spoiled that they expect a big deal every year.

          We kept out farm intact and didn’t budge on unproven players(besides ubaldo who seems hurt)

          Also no matter how good some relief pitchers were out there we can’t deal a top prospect for a 1 inning guy.

          We are only going to go as far as aj burnetts pitching in te playoffs. Colon and Garcia will be fine

  16. JM says:

    Now what? I guess hope Bedard is ineffective.

    • Jimmy McNulty says:

      I’m pretty sure he will be.

    • Thomas Cassidy says:

      He has to pitch to be ineffective. He can’t stay healthy in Seattle, and Boston can’t keep pitchers healthy for some reason. It’s only a matter of time until he’s out for the season. I give him three starts.

  17. Gerald Williams (Yankee Legend) Needs a Monument says:

    We can and do win with the team we’ve got.

    • Greg says:

      Do we win the WS with this team? That’s the question.

      • Gerald Williams (Yankee Legend) Needs a Monument says:

        I honestly think they can. Our offense is strong enough to overcome mediocre pitching behind CC. Once Ubaldo was gone, there was no one left to acquire. Our bullpen is more then solid especially if Soriano remembers how to pitch. I think we need to switch out Nova and Hughes and let Jesus do some mashing from the DH spot. It could be exciting the next few years to infuse Jesus, Man Ban, and Betances into the team.

        • Wooderson says:

          the point of this deadline i think is that if we dont win it THIS YEAR!!!1111 we’re much better set up in the future with keeping the big pieces in the farm. 2009 still feels good, i’d much rather wait til 2013 or whatever and win with jesus and manbam, etc.

        • Rob S. says:

          We cannot expect our offense to carry us through playoff series against Boston or Texas.

          • Hardy says:

            Why can’t we expect that the second best offense in the majors carries the team through two series against relatively shaky rotations?

      • Gonzo says:

        Just make the playoffs and get hot. Having the “best” team doesn’t ensure a WS title.

        • Midland TX says:

          Heaven help me, I’m agreeing with you, AND quoting Torre and Jeter: “To make the playoffs, you have to be better than everyone else, and to win in the playoffs, you have to be luckier than everyone else.”

        • Jimmy McNulty says:

          Oh will you idiots stop saying this. It’s a stupid thing to say, yes, the best team doesn’t equal a World Series title. What, does that mean that a GM shouldn’t focus on fielding the best team that he can? It’s at truism, and it adds jack and shit to the conversation. The: WELL LOOK AT(x team, from x season) line is just as stupid. Situations vary from year to year, and it’s always a good idea to field the best team you can.

          • Midland TX says:

            Thanks for that rant. What was out there to improve the team that’s better than what’s in the system? Past Jimenez, not much. So you don’t mortgage the future for slimmest of chances at improvement.

            And by the way, “Shut up, fuck you, don’t mention these supporting facts” isn’t an argument.

            • Jimmy McNulty says:

              Yeah, because hoping to get lucky in the playoffs against teams that are not only superior on paper but also match up better is suuuuch a good strategy. What are we Indians fans? This is the motherfucking Yankees, anything but the best is unthinkable. The fact that fans are okay with being second or third best is a bit surprising to me. And besides, stating the: WELL LOOK AT(x team, from x season) line, is still fucking stupid. You can find plenty of instances where the best team in baseball wins the World Series, and I don’t think anyone said the best team always wins. Furthermore, when you spout off that line it’s almost like you’re saying being the best team in baseball is a bad thing, and that we should all just hope to fluke our way to a WS title, not y’know assemble the best team in baseball. Furthermore, you’re insinuating that circumstances are exactly the same with a team that was less than the best and with this year’s Yankee squad. A lot of people point to the 2010 Giants, yeah, not the best…but with pitchers like Lincecum, Cain, Madison Bumgarner, and Jonathan Sanchez…they’ll match up well with any staff. This year’s Yankee squad isn’t quite the same.

              • Gonzo says:

                You really should have read what I was responding to with my post.

              • Midland TX says:

                You keep setting up stupid straw man arguments and knocking them down with vitriol. Is it better to have “the best team on paper?” Yes. Are Halladay, Verlander, and Hernandez available at the moment? No. So, back to the original post, you don’t make a panic move–just keep doing what you’re doing and make the playoffs and hope the team heats up at the right time.

                • Jimmy McNulty says:

                  You’re the one setting up the straw man, and besides, later in the thread I praised C-$$$ for his patience this year. I’m mad they weren’t able to upgrade the team, another starter just wasn’t in the cards.

          • SDM says:

            Way to be a grade A dick with your rant, Jimmy Mc-Pessimist. Yes the yankees want to put the best team available, but how about next year? Or the year after?

            Giving away your entire farm risks that upcoming success. Pitching has been a problem for the team for over a decade, whether its an old starter about who is past his prime and about to retire, the numerous ineffective FA signings, or the trades for the hot name that does jack shit and sets the teams pitching programs back several years. Would Ubaldo make a more stable rotation this year? Yes but next year, NY will still have three question marks next year, and the year after that.

            Until they break the chain and develop their own starters, the team is never going to completely answer its rotational needs. Frankly, I can live with not winning the WS if it means there is a chance of that cycle getting broken.

            If you want to keep complaining that’s your decision, just like its my choice to tell you to shut up, nut up and believe in the team or go root for the phillies because your acting like a whiny bitch.

            • GT Yankee says:

              I really don’t want to be bitchy and I REALLY do want the Yanks to win the WS. But with that said, when we were rattling off WS wins who in our rotation besides Pettite came from our farm system that proved invaluable?

            • Jimmy McNulty says:

              Illiteracy is a wonderful thing. I don’t think I ever said that I wanted them to deal for Ubaldo. I wanted Ubaldo, sure, so did everyone else. However, with the revelation that Colorado wouldn’t have allowed a physical, and given what Cleveland surrendered for him…I’m fine with the non move. That’s a hell of a lot of talent that Cleveland let go for a power pitcher that’s lost three ticks off the heat. And stop with the “Ubaldo doesn’t make sense” argument. He’s signed long term, and a front two of CC/Ubaldo is at least a top five 1/2 punch. CJ Wilson’s a free agent next year, Cole Hamels the season after next, there’s other options for the future.

              Until they break the chain and develop their own starters, the team is never going to completely answer its rotational needs. Frankly, I can live with not winning the WS if it means there is a chance of that cycle getting broken.

              Oh wow, and I’m the pessimist. Frankly, I agree but it’s been a few weeks since I’ve brought this up. I agree, they’ve sucked at developing and evaluating pitching lately. This needs to change, but frankly I don’t know if it’s a run of awful luck with starting pitching or something structurally wrong with their program…but whatever it is, it needs to stop. One approach I’ve heard from rival fans is that since the Yankees suck with young pitching anyways, they should just trade the young prospects for established starters. I don’t know if I agree with that, but something to consider. I know TJSC is going to do his typical “THinks. No” thing if he reads this, but you are right the cycle needs to be broken, and soon.

    • Rob S. says:

      Not in late October.

  18. mbonzo says:

    Only trade I think Cashman missed out on was Edwin Jackson, not that big of a deal though considering the Yankekes have 6 starting pitchers who could out pitch him the next 2 months. I hope he’s their target this offseason though, no thanks CJ Wilson.

  19. Jon in ???JH says:

    Color me surprised. I was sure a ninja move was coming. This team can fill most of its holes simply by promoting from within, but I’d still like to see them try to work out a waiver deal for Wandy.

  20. Rey22 says:

    Wow, I expected no blockbusters, but I’m surprised by a complete lack of moves. I expected at least a decent lefty reliever for the bullpen.

    Oh well.

  21. Phife Dawg says:

    Sometimes, the best trades are the ones you don’t make.

  22. theyankeewarrior says:

    Erik Bedard. Left handed pitcher.

  23. JM says:

    Only thing that could make me happy right now is Jesus getting called up.

  24. Josh S. says:

    Jesus better be in yankee pinstripes tomorrow. Cash is done in ny. Thanks for david justice in 2000 and for CC in 09. Have fun with a 20 dollar payroll next year. No, I’m not jumping off a ledge because the yanks didn’t make a deal but pissed that we have a lame duck gm. They’ll make the playoffs still. Just don’t know if they’ll go far.

    • Mike Axisa says:

      No, I’m not jumping off a ledge because the yanks didn’t make a deal but pissed that we have a lame duck gm.

      If the Yankees had a real lame duck GM, the farm system would have been emptied in a last ditch effort to save his job.

      • Jimmy McNulty says:

        Doesn’t the lame duck GM meme follow from the Cashman wants to leave line or ownership wants him out? I’m pretty sure his track record warrants a renewal.

      • Josh S. says:

        Fair point. Lame duck was not the right terminology. Seems like he’s just a guy who wants a new job with a new boss. I’ll be extremely surprised if he’s the GM of the Yankees next season. Actually, I will be kind of disappointed if he’s still here next season. Sometimes, a change is needed. Cashman’s done a pretty good job over the past 13 years, but a changing of the guard is in order. Any chance the Yanks can pluck Ruben Amaro Jr. from the Phils?

    • pat says:

      Don’t forget Granderson and Swisher.

      Thanks Cash!!

    • 28 this year says:

      unlike you, i hope Jesus is in road greys. I believe we’re on the road so pinstripes could get him kicked out of the game for being out of uniform.

  25. Reggie C. says:

    Cashman gets his ninja status revoked. But that’s probably a good thing since any pick up that last hour would’ve smacked of desperation and wouldve reflected in the cost of prospects and cash we’d be assuming.

  26. Jack Merridew says:

    There just wasn’t a lot available after Jiminez and he had too many question marks. We’re not in too bad of shape here, 2 GB and well in front for the WC. Could be 1 GB if the White Sox hold on to their 3-2 lead.

  27. ángel says:

    We are done after the 1st round of the playoff

    • Greg says:

      If we play the Rangers, maybe, although we’ve dominated them this year, they improved their bullpen by leaps and bounds.

      • John says:

        apparently they traded for someone from baltimore that hates pitching in extremely hot temperatures. Texas right now has over 100 degrees on average daily temperature. that might come back to bit them in the ass.

      • Louis says:

        We have a better offense, and a rotation that can match up with theirs this year as well. Well be fine if we play them in the first round.

    • toad says:

      Because without Bedard it’s absolutely impossible to win three out of five against a good team.

  28. Grandy77 says:

    A lot of overreaction to Cashman not making any moves, I mean who was actually on the market that we are gutted to have missed out on? Bedard for nothing much would have been nice but the rest all involved giving up too much for a whole lot less of a sure thing.

    Bring up Jesus within the week and nobody will even mention this deadline day.

  29. Kevin G. says:

    Don’t worry, we’ll acquire top of the rotation pitchers soon. Only 15 months! Of course by that time Jeter and A-Rod will probably be in wheelchairs.

  30. pat says:

    Once Jesus puts his first homerun 20 rows deep into the RF stands people are gonna realize this kid will mash in Yankee Stadium.

    • Ryan 407 says:

      To answer you from above, I was one who wanted Jimenez. I think the Yankees were spooked by their experience with Vazquez and were probably on board with the notion that “Ubaldo is AJ part II”. The whole situation with the physical doesn’t pass a sniff test for me. He just took one to complete the trade with Cleveland. That feels like spin from the front office. If Wandy Rodriguez only cost money then I wouldn’t mind giving him a chance.

      I am not sure who else was out there. What I am sure of is that Cash had plenty of time to get creative but he didn’t want to part with basically anything of value.

  31. John says:

    You guys know they can still trade after today right?

    it says so in the blog, waiver trade deadline goes until about sept 1. After that date newly acquired players can’t be on postseason rosters.

    So we have about a month to find some waiver trades. It CAN BE DONE.

    I’m actually liking the idea of gradually adding home grown talent from the farm little by little. Remember when Cano and Wang came up? how it was a big deal to see kids from the farm? It started a trend; Cervi, Gardy, Nuney, Pena, as well as a few other fielders/pitchers that’ve come up and down from AAA and AA.

    We make the playoffs this year, whatever happens happens. I would be bashing cashman to world’s end right now if he traded away the farm to get one pitcher that probably wouldn’t hold up in New York. It’s one thing pitching here 3 times a year, its another making about half your starts here.

    • chriskeo says:

      Even after September first I believe since the Yankees have multiple guys on the DL60. Unless this is only for guys not on the 40 man.

      • John says:

        Yeah, I forget how it works with the DL60.

        I just remember like in 03 they had a few guys brought onto the team in september but were not allowed on the post season roster.

        I just know trades can still be made, albeit harder to make some with the waiver claims. But still, we can make trades.

  32. Rob S. says:

    Chad Gaudin? That’s our ray of hope? We might acquire another Chad Gaudin? I don’t know but I feel that the Yankees and Cashman really blew it. They were too singularly focused on Cliff Lee and we’re left empty handed in the offseason. They wasted money on Soriano. Now they did nothing to improve a flawed team. Bullpen? rotation? bench? Nothing? Not a single upgrade out there? I just know that this team, as currently constructed, is not built to get deep into October.

  33. Len S. says:

    I hate Cashman more than I hate The Devil.

    • Brian says:

      What did you want him to do? Trade Montero, Banuelos, Betances, & Nova for Jimenez without an MRI?

      Everyone bitches and moans that the Yanks don’t build from within. I hate to break it to you, but one pitcher isn’t going to make or break the playoffs.

  34. Greg says:

    The problem with what some of you are saying is that you are asserting that the prospects will perform. I look at Generation K and Lastings Milledge with the Mets as a warning that surefire hyped prospects dont always work out.

    • SDM says:

      one could also mention all the surefire hyped prospects that have delivered. Or how many of these “proven” players fail after being dealt.

      The point is you don’t know baseball is about as unpredictable to predict when it comes to talent evaluation as any sport. you can only trust that the right decision is made.

    • The Fallen Phoenix says:

      Look at Alex Rodriguez, Derek Jeter, and Troy Tulowitzki as exhibits that surefire hyped prospects sometimes do work out. And look at Jorge Posada, Robinson Cano, Jon Lester, Kevin Youkilis, and Ricky Romero as exhibits that mediocre prospects sometimes work out better than anyone can expect.

      There’s always going to be risk involved when you’re betting on prospects. But if you never make any bets, you’ll never reap any rewards, and you’ll continuously be forced to overpay for the AJ Burnetts, CJ Wilsons, and (yes, even the) Mark Teixeiras as they hit the free agent markets on the downswing of their careers.

    • toad says:

      Sure they don’t, but neither do players acquired in trades.

      You only need one of several prospects to work out well.

  35. wow says:

    Is calling up Banuelos to the majors considered rushing him up though? I know he’s ahead of the curve, but the guy is only 20 or 21, I think.

  36. Cecala says:

    Honestly if we didnt have such a bad record against boston this year, no one would be complaining that we need a starter or whatever. It was smart of Cash to not build a team around 1 other team.

  37. Tampa Yankee says:

    Wow… sometimes the entitlement of most Yankees fans astonishes me. Just because WE expect/want something to happen, doesn’t mean the FO is going to do something. Listen, I’m all for moving prospects but at the right price and for the right need. I’m not for trading the farm just to do something. Also, I’m sure they explored a lot of different options but in the end thought it was best to stay pat or as Sherman just said:
    #Yankees believe what have, what can get from A-Rod returning, Montero, Banuelos, Nova or Hughes in pen better than trade price for vets

  38. Tampa Yankee says:

    Wow… sometimes the entitlement of most Yankees fans astonishes me. Just because us fans expect/want something to happen, doesn’t mean the FO is going to do something. Listen, I’m all for moving prospects but at the right price and for the right need. I’m not for trading the farm just to do something. Also, I’m sure they explored a lot of different options but in the end thought it was best to stay pat or as Sherman just said:
    #Yankees believe what have, what can get from A-Rod returning, Montero, Banuelos, Nova or Hughes in pen better than trade price for vets

    • Greg says:

      Once again, I have to point to the goal of the Yankees: To win the WS. If you think we can win the WS with this cast then fine. If you dont, you should try to make a move.

      Now to be clear, I didn’t expect King Felix or Kershaw. I was expecting a low level deal for maybe a backend starter or a bench player. ‘

      And I just want to ask a general question about the WS. How often to you believe that the inferior team wins the WS? Just a general statement.

      • Freddy Garcia's 86 mph Heat says:

        “How often to you believe that the inferior team wins the WS?”

        Quite a few times…

        2010 Giants
        2006 Cards
        2004 Red Sox
        2003 Marlins
        2001 Dbacks

        to name a few.

        • Greg says:

          I dont think the 01 Dbacks were inferior. Not with Randy Johnson and Curt Schilling.

          04 Red Sox were inferior to the Yankees, but not the Cardinals in the WS.

          In terms of percentage, I would say about 20%-30%

          • Freddy Garcia's 86 mph Heat says:

            “04 Red Sox were inferior to the Yankees, but not the Cardinals in the WS.”

            It wouldn’t have mattered if the “better” team won that ALCS because the Red Sox would not advance to be better than the Cardinals.

            Just get to the playoffs. Anything can happen. We saw that last year when the Giants and Rangers got absurdly hot and the favorites, the Yankees and Phillies, stumbled.

          • Gonzo says:

            I guess it depends on your definition of inferior. The 2008 Phil’s had the 5th best record in MLB for 2008 and 2nd best in the NL. Etc…

        • Jimmy McNulty says:

          2010 Giants had the pitching to match up with any team in baseball, the 2011 Yankees do not. The 2006 Cardinals were an EXTREMELY flukey team. Hardly the example you want to use. The 2004 Red Sox were the best team in baseball, they underperformed their pythag during the season. The 2004 Yankees had an 89-73 pythag. Not only were they the best team in baseball they had a line up that can match up with any team in baseball and a pitching staff that could do the same. The 2003 Marlins got lucky with Torre letting Jeff Weaver pitch while the greatest ever got splinters in his ass. Not to mention the whole awesome pitching staff that matches up with anyone thing. The 2001 D-Backs? They had a much better pythag than the Yankees, a much better staff, and the two best pitchers in baseball. If the Yankees had CC and Doc I’m pretty sure no fans here would be complaining.

          • Gonzo says:

            “The 2003 Marlins got lucky with Torre letting Jeff Weaver pitch while the greatest ever got splinters in his ass.”

            So you’re saying teams get lucky in the playoffs?

            • Jimmy McNulty says:

              I don’t think I ever denied that luck exists in baseball…you’re the idiot that seems to think that it’s just luck. On that note, I think allowing Jeff Weaver to pitch in extras on the road, in favor of Mariano Rivera qualifies more as a “gift” than “luck.”

          • Freddy Garcia's 86 mph Heat says:

            The 2010 Giants had good pitching but needed career years from the likes of Cody Ross, Buster Posey, and Aubrey Huff to win.

            The 2006 Cards are a perfect example to why the best team does not always win it all.

            The 2004 Sox were 3 outs against the greatest closer ever from being swept. 99/100 times, the Yankees win there.

            The same about the 2006 cards can be said for the 2003 Marlins. They were not the best team, and they won.

            You do have a point about the 01 Dbacks, but still, 99/100 times, the greatest closer ever nails that down.

            • Freddy Garcia's 86 mph Heat says:

              Pat Burrell not Buster Posey

            • Gonzo says:

              He’s forgetting the Mariners had a better pythag, in 2001, than the Dbacks by 14 games.

              • The Fallen Phoenix says:

                People forget the Yankees made a pretty incredible comeback against a very, very good Oakland team in 2001 (when Zito-Mulder-Hudson were at their peaks, too), and then dismantled the team with the best regular season record in AL history.

                The playoffs really are a crapshoot because anything can happen in a short series.

                • Gonzo says:

                  That A’s team had a pythag that was 15 games better than the Yanks. They also had some studs on that team.

                  • The Fallen Phoenix says:

                    Say what you want about the AL East the last couple of years, but it still boggles the mind that 104 wins (or however many that As team had) wasn’t enough to win the West that year.

                • Jimmy McNulty says:

                  The playoffs are a crapshoot, you do your best to weight the dice and give yourself the best chance you can. I’m pretty sure if the Yankees had a rotation of Doc/CC/Felix/Kershaw entering into the playoffs and lost 80% of the fans wouldn’t have a problem with whoever put the team together.

              • Jimmy McNulty says:

                The Mariners got hosed that year, still I’m pretty sure most fans will take their chances in the playoffs with a team that had the lowest RA in the majors and the most runs scored. Shit happens, you just do your best so you can put yourself in the best position to win.

                • Gonzo says:

                  You mean fans would rather take their chances with the statistically better team. Tell me more. I am blown away by your groundbreaking logic.

            • Jimmy McNulty says:

              The 2006 Cardinals are one of the worst teams ever to win the world series. If you’re taking the “99/100 times” line of thinking, I’m sure in a simulation of the playoffs that year at least 90/100 times they don’t win the World Series…if that’s your plan, yikes. Yeah, a crappy team won the World Series, I guess we should also forget about pitchers like CC in the playoffs too, and just sign a guy like Jeff Suppan, right?

              The 2004 Sox were 3 outs against the greatest closer ever from being swept. 99/100 times, the Yankees win there.

              There’s several missteps by Torre in that series, but if you’re going with the 99/100times line of thinking, 99/100 times the Red Sox don’t even go down 0-3. So, chew on that for a bit.

      • toad says:

        How often to you believe that the inferior team wins the WS? Just a general statement

        Depends. If the teams are, say, 55-45 in any given game, which is pretty extreme, then the worse team will win the WS about 39% of the time.

        • Gonzo says:

          Take it to an even more extreme % and the one best team is 80% to win in the Division Series, then 70% to win in the Championship Series, then 60% in the World Series. That team has a 33.6% chance of winning it all.

          If they’re 70%, 60%, 55%, their odds are 23.1% to win it all.

    • Skip says:

      Agree with you!

      Ubaldo would have been nice, but the Rockies were clearly trying to screw the Yankees for that package, a la Schilling with the Diamondbacks. Just because the Indians gave up 3 of their top prospects does not mean that equals the Yankees’s top 3 prospects.

  39. bonestock94 says:

    Meh, they can have Bedard. Lets see what he looks like in a real division in a park that isn’t a pitcher’s paradise. And that’s if he can even last long enough.

    I would’ve liked a starter, but I’m not envious of any deal that went down this deadline.

  40. Ted Nelson says:

    I will join those who are not surprised at all. I would have been more surprised if they’d acquired a 7th starter, overpaid for a reliever, or found a bat better than what they have.

    • David, Jr. says:

      Well said. It isn’t so bad to have about a 96 win team with a great farm system. No need to do anything stupid.

  41. JackC says:

    Forgive my ignorance, but why is there this groundswell of belief that Jesus will be called up imminently?

    • Phife Dawg says:

      It’s past the trade deadline + Posada not hitting + Jesus raking in AAA= Profit???

      • Rob S. says:

        Jesus Montero .283, 10 HRs, 48 RBIs at AAA level? Not bad but I wouldn’t call it raking either.

      • Midland TX says:

        Posada’s wOBA against righties is .348, not spectacular but–taken together with the Jones half of the platoon–not bad enough to justify bringing up the kid till the rosters expand.

  42. Jimmy McNulty says:

    Just a few things:

    One: I’m completely fine with the way the trade deadline was handled. Ubaldo lost a lot off his fastball and to give up big prospects without a physical is just dumb, it was right of Cashman to pass. Besides, Colorado got a lot more than I would have liked to give up, and I’m still wondering why Colorado dealt him despite having him cheaply for another three and a half years. I still think that this team needs something else in the rotation and another reliever in the bullpen, but Cashman did what he should have

    Two: So, for everyone who yelled at me in the fan confidence polls of yore, saying “THIS ISN’T THE TEAM THAT THEY’LL FIELD IN AUGUST!!!!!!” Can we stop assuming a deal? Trades are contingent on two sides coming together, what’s a fair offer to one party isn’t always a fair offer to the other side.

    • Phife Dawg says:

      +1 Well said.

      For every one or two sources saying a trade is 100% surefire thing, there are 4 or 5 saying a trade is not likely.

      In other words, the trade deadline is a crap shoot, circumstances change and ANYTHING could happen.

  43. Len S. says:

    They’re gonna get smoked like a cigar by Texas in the playoffs.

    • Freddy Garcia's 86 mph Heat says:

      Remember how the Giants were the clear favorites to win it all last year?

      • Len S. says:

        The Giants starting pitching from 1-4 was amazing last year. The Yanks starting pitching is 1-???.

      • Ryan 407 says:

        Remember how the Giants had Lincecum, Cain, Sanchez, and Bumgarner in their rotation?

        • Freddy Garcia's 86 mph Heat says:

          The Phillies with Hallady, Oswalt, and Hamels were still the favorites.

          • Mike Axisa says:

            Oswalt was so absurdly good down the stretch for them last year, it’ll be tough for Lee to top that.

          • Ryan 407 says:

            That isn’t the point. The Phillies were the favorites but it wasn’t that surprising that they won the World Series pretty much on the back of their pitching. The current group of guys the Yankees have don’t come close to San Francisco and certainly not Philadelphia. Its a silly statement to make pertaining to the Yankees in the playoffs.

    • bonestock94 says:

      Their rotation isn’t scary this year.

  44. Jack Merridew says:

    Keep Nova up for now and see how Hughes does Tuesday. If Hughes struggles against another weak offense on Tuesday you cannot throw him to the wolves at Boston. Nova-Freddy-CC would then pitch the Boston series.

  45. wilcymoore27 says:

    There are too many idiots on this board who think the Yankees must do SOMETHING just because it’s the trade deadline. I’m glad Cashman stood pat. He knows better than to make a stupid trade just for the sake of making a trade.

    The Yankees have good organizational depth. Good; now they’ll be able to use it themselves.

    • Greg says:

      Can they beat Texas, Boston, San Francisco, or Philly with this depth?

      That’s all that matters.

      • bonestock94 says:

        Hold on, lemme get my crystal ball.

      • John says:

        Sometimes the wild card team gets red hot and makes a run beating the teams with the better records in the league. It’s happened for years while the Yankees were division winners with 96+ wins. Maybe, if need be, we become that type of team that wins the division/wild card and goes on a tear and will beat teams just by fate and some luck. You just never know.

      • Mike HC says:

        There wasn’t a pitcher out there that would make our chances of beating those teams demonstratively better. Jimenez was being billed as that, but his has not been that good this year with diminished stuff.

      • Mike HC says:

        I would say the worst part of the deadline was that most of our competition were able to improve at the deadline, while nothing really made sense for the Yanks.

      • Len S. says:

        I just wish I could trust either Garcia, Colon, or Burnett against Texas or Boston in the playoffs. It just seems potentially disastrous to me. Texas and Boston have some big-ass offenses.

        • Granderslam says:


        • Matt says:

          Did St. Louis think that Jeff Weaver and Jeff Suppan would carry them to a World Series title?

          This is 2011, not 2008, or 2005. These guys are finally healthy, and they are producing.

          Colon has fallen back to earth a bit, and he has still been more than solid. His stuff is just as good, but his control is a little off right now. He just came off of the DL a month ago, so he may not be in midseason form quite yet.

          Garcia is not getting “lucky,” watch him pitch. He has a nasty splitter and changes speeds very well, while throwing a lot of strikes. He may not shut down teams like Boston, but he deserves many of the numbers that he’s put up this year.

          Maybe it’s time to admit that these two are for real. They may not aces, but they are more than getting the job done, and it’s not a fluke. With the offense and bullpen to back them up, these guys may be enough to get it done if AJ and Hughes can step it up down the stretch.

          • Kevin says:

            Btw, we won all our series with Texas this year,I wonder if that counts for anything?

            • JobaWockeeZ says:

              The majority of commenters believe that a series in the regular season means nothing in the postseason. The Yankees being 1-8 against the Red Sox means nothing.

              However I am interested to see if people do a 180 and say it means a lot since the Yankees are in the dominant position.

  46. T-Long says:

    “Banuelos will start Aug. 2 at Triple-A, and yes he is in play for the #Yankees bullpen sometime later this season if all goes well” Maybe I’m just paranoid but do I see deja vu with the whole joba mess? I really hope I’m wrong about this.

  47. Mike HC says:

    The Cashman press conference was pretty good. Didn’t say anything too crazy, but he gave his honest reasoning on why he didn’t make move. In short, he liked the guys we have.

  48. Joe M says:

    I’m so glad none of you are the GM of the Yankees

    • Wooderson says:

      times like this is why i hate being a yankee fan. their fans….there’s nothing worse.

    • Death By BB Gun says:

      Word. Making a move for the sake of making one is a stupid move, and this deadline shows that Cashman has faith in the farm.

      Of course, no one ever seems to think long term, so I eagerly await the Yankees being crowned “deadline losers” by every outlet and fan within walking distance of a keyboard or phone.

      • Wooderson says:

        its not so much that, its the entitlement that they HAVE TO WIN THIS YEAR!!! even if it sets them up badly for the future. its like cmon we won 2 years ago, i like winning as much as anyone but its a lot better when we win with our guys rather than hired guns (and then watch our guys take off on other teams long after the guy we got for them is gone). im so glad to see the tide shifting.

  49. Ryan 407 says:

    Banuelos is walking five guys in AA and he earns a promotion. Yeah that makes sense.

  50. Rob S. says:

    I don’t see how Banuelos in the bullpen accomplishes anything. Yanks need starting pitching, not relief pitching.

    • Cuso says:

      lefty in the pen is probably what they’re thinking about.

      the only true and obvious hole on this team is a quality LOOGY.

      Our starting pitching, while not ‘sexy,’ is getting the job done. You rarely see one of our starters get yanked before the 5th.

      Unfortunately, 20 other teams need a LOOGY too. Nothing was available.

      Thus, it’s “possible ManBan gets a shot in the ‘pen.Not definite, but possible.

  51. Charles says:

    It’s not that I expected Cliff Lee/Kershaw/King Felix in a move, but to not pickup a Lefty or a strong bench bat that can play some D puzzles me…

  52. KenC says:

    hopefully, the jesus we all been waiting for will come soon

  53. Chris says:

    Thank god they didn’t trade anyone. Everyone in baseball seems to think highly of our prospects also which gives me hope going forward.

  54. Dropped Third Superstar says:

    Name me better players the yankees could have got then
    1. Arod
    2. Soriano
    3. Montero
    and FOR NOTHING….

    C.C, Colon, Nova/Garcia/AJ isn’t a terrible playoff rotation given how well each player has thrown this season and how great the offense and bullpen are. We loose no prospects and keep a top farm team while owning the third best record in baseball.

    Cashman made great under the radar signings he gets no credit for,

    1. Wade
    2. Garcia
    3. Colon
    4. Chaves
    5. Martin

    what reasonably priced upgrade was out there? cashman made good moves, BEFORE the deadline

  55. ItsATarp says:

    Good Job Cashman. Go window shopping and if nothing is worth the cost don’t buy anything. ManBan is moving up the ladder and Montero is getting the call soon. No need to panic to a make unnecessary moves, especially when there’s no Cliff Lee or any one of that caliber on the market.

  56. Irrational Yankees Fan says:

    I’m never watching a single Yankees game again. In fact, I’m becoming a Minnesota Twins fan out of pure spite that they didn’t make a trade.

  57. Granderslam says:

    When do the rosters expand again? (Out of pure curiosity for Romero possibility, Montero addition, and waiver pickups.)

  58. GT Yankee says:

    Has anyone noticed that Jesus hasn’t exactly been a God this year? I can’t help but wonder if he was kept down all this time because the Yanks feared his lack of forward progress exposed.

    To those who are okay with no trades taking place because “Jesus is coming”….I say I didn’t know Jesus pitches on the side!

  59. Zack D says:

    I wonder if the Sox will have a 24+1 clubhoues with Bedard now

  60. stuart a says:

    i am fine with no moves. the only move worth making was selling the farm for the King. jiminez is a huge question mark and the cost was for a sure thing, something jiminez is not.

    montero is 21 and doing quite fine at AAA. question his ability to catch but he can hit unless every scout is wrong.

  61. Januz says:

    I was switching back between the game and MLB Network, and there is no one more obnoxious than Harold Reynolds. The Yankees are not making the playoffs, was a repeated theme of his. Guess what? They are deal with it.

  62. Simon says:

    I said it last night and i’ll say it again:

    “I think people need to move on from this already. Cashman ultimately made the right choice in not going after. What’s done is done, the past is over, its time to move on. We have a great player incoming to the Bronx and his name is Jesus Montero and he should provide some help (not that we need it but we could use some). Also, we have 2 great pitchers in the farm that, although are not proven, have huge potential to be very good pitchers. We may bash Cashman for not making certain moves but he is the Yankees GM for a reason! Although we may not like that the Yankees may do (deals that are/aren’t made), there’s nothing we can do about that, as fans we just have to live with that and move on! This is the New York Yankees, the greatest franchise in sports history, nobody should be worried at all!”

    These “bridges jumpers” need to step beack and look at the bigger picture and realize it is not at all bad.

  63. stuart a says:

    sox are going for it. they better. they have really depleted there minors over the last 12 months…….

  64. stuart a says:

    yankees in years past had to overpay for marginal upgrades because they had nothing in the minors.. that is no longer the case for the uninformed the yanks have many legit prospects and quitea few at AA or higher..

    brandon laird is a legit prospect at AAA that is maybe a top 10 prospect in the system…montero is ready for the show now. nova is 9 and 4 and gets zero love…noesi is doing fine even though his role is far from defined and not ideal….I can go on and on……..

    • Dropped Third Superstar says:

      Not to mention the team has the third best record in baseball. Cash is doing something right.

  65. Mattingly's batboy says:

    When Montero hits HRs for the Yanks later this year, John Sterling can yell, “JESUS MIGHTY!!”

    Seriously, I wish Cashman would have addressed the pen a little, but thinking about it, wasn’t Hughes pretty good out of the pen a few years ago? Maybe once October hits and the Yanks go to a four-man staff for the playoffs, Hughes could operate out of the pen if he doesn’t straighten things out as a starter before then. Just a thought.

    • Jake LaMotta's Left Hook says:

      The Yankees traded with the DL for Soriano and Wade has emerged as a viable option, the pen is fine.

  66. stuart a says:

    philly did not really totally deplete there minors and there moves have not been rentals. pence is under contract for 2 more years, ibanez is gone after this season and brown will be in the outfield next year. with the phillies stupendous pitching you need only a good offense…..

    the philly starting pitching is off the scale, to have that type of staff is literally once in a lieftime so they also are all in………..

    yanks starting pitching besides CC is league avg in my opinion but there was no one on the market who could improve there staff appreciable and trading high end prospects for that makes no sense…

  67. Bob Michaels says:

    The Best trade was a Non-trade.Keeping the best talent in the farm system ready to help if needed for the stretch drive.

  68. Rainbow Connection says:

    So…does this mean Jesus will be called up tomorrow and Jorge will retire??? Please? Please?

    • Cuso says:

      Jorge sucks the life out of the roster, lol. He literally just takes up space.

      Posada is going to start getting phased out. He’s going to have to learn to become an effective PH.

  69. YankeesJunkie says:

    It appears that the Rockies were being unreasonable in not allowing the Yankees to do physical and asking for Phil Hughes on top of Jesus, Betances, and Nova. However, now that the Yankees have decided to stand pat for the deadline every day that Montero is not called up is a wasted day. Outside of June, Posada has been unacceptable as a DH and Montero can bring right handed power, pinch hitter, and catch twice a week.

    On another note it would be nice to see Noesi get some more important innings above Wade, Ayala, and Logan. However, this is not necessary just more preference than anything else.

  70. ángel says:

    Star thinking about 2012 or 2013

  71. Good move by Cash to not make a trade for a pitcher that wouldn’t have been better than Garcia/Colon. I think we’ll be fine in the playoffs.

    • A.D. says:

      If everyone holds up it should be fine on paper the number being put up by Sabathia, Colon, AJ, and Garcia will be fine for the playoffs. Sabathia and AJ are pitching pretty much to be expected, but can Garcia and Colon hold up physically and continue their performance?

      If not its more mid – 00 Yankees teams with plenty of offense and not enough pitching for the post-season

      • I’m of the belief that if Colon and Garcia can go 6 or 7 innings in the playoffs while keeping it close, you can just turn it over to Robertson/Soriano/Mo. Timely hitting and good pitching wins championships.

  72. Nathan says:

    No starter…OK, not really much out there without giving up the farm but not even a hitter to replace or platoon with Jorge?

    My faith in Cash went down about 2 points.

    • pat says:

      Lol ok. Ignore the fact that our best prospect in the minors plays the same exact position posada plays (fake C/DH). Throw in the fact that we just got Chavez back and there’s your Posada replacement.

    • Kevin D. says:

      I heard Cashman cried when he saw this. =(

  73. Brian says:

    Montero not in the lineup tonight?

  74. Adam says:

    Wow, Bedard and Lackey potentially in the same rotation. The Sox are really going for the douchiest roster in MLB.

  75. Pasqua says:

    Everyone who is concerned about the Sox acquiring Erik Bedard is cleary not familiar with Erik Bedard.

  76. Granderslam says:

    I honestly would like to see Warren soon. Warren, Montero, and possibly ManBan can make for exciting Sept/Oct.

    • YankeesJunkie says:

      While it would be nice to see Warren play in the majors I doubt that he will be called up since he has not been quite as dominant in AAA. Better to leave Warren in AAA for the rest of the year and see what he can do next year along with Noesi and Nova for starting spots on the Yankees.

  77. Naved says:

    Oh god please let it be true that Montero is getting called up.

  78. KenC says:

    does montero have the day off or is he getting called up? hes not in triple a lineup

  79. Pat D says:

    After Cashman’s performance today, well…let’s just put it this way:


  80. pat says:

    Montero has played the last 9 games in a row. Probably just getting a night off. Romine is in line for a promotion too. Things down on the farm should start to get exciting.

  81. BINNER says:

    Time will tell…if we make it to the world series, Cashaman is correct. But if we don’t, Cashman thought CC & garbage would win it/or he’s packing it in now – and he should be fired!

    • Andrew518 says:

      I just don’t see it, so many are calling for Cashman’s head, what move was he supposed to make? A token move to prove to online posters that he is “trying?” Is the team as constructed ready to contend for the WS? I’m not sure.

      But I’m equally not convinced that there was a player out there that would have changed that status. A bat off the bench doesn’t dramaticaly change the dynamic for me. Bullpen help? I would consider the bullpen a strength on this team. A top of the line starter? Who? Rockies wanted too much for Jiminez, Kuroda not available, after that there’s a bunch of middle/bottom of rotation starters…last time I checked the Yankees had too many of them to fit into their rotation.

      If your car is old and might breakdown does buying an old used car make you more confident that you’ll get to work on time?

  82. t23 says:

    Only way this is an issue is if Colon gets hurt. Like it or not our rotation will be CC/Colon/Burnett. Is bedard really better than Garcia/Nova/Hughes? Sure, but hes not a huge upgrade. There was no point trading prospects unless we can get a solid #2, Kuroda/Jimenez/Wandy were the only options there.

  83. BigBlueAL says:

    Im just as skeptical of the Yankee rotation come October as everyone else is but the fact is the Yankees pitching this season has been much better than both Boston and Texas.

    Texas will be tough and they would have homefield but w/o Cliff Lee this year I dont “fear” them. I fully expect the Yankees to beat Texas if they face them in the playoffs this season. Boston obviously have Beckett and Lester plus the best offense in baseball so yeah they will be tough and to be honest I dont expect the Yankees to be able to beat them in the ALCS if it comes down to that but it certainly is not a foregone conclusion that the Red Sox will beat them.

    • Mike says:

      I agree. Other than C.C. I’m not really too confident against Boston’s lineup.

    • YankeeJosh says:

      Also it’s not a sure thing the Red Sox get o the ALCS. It’s not impossible to imagine the Tigers with Verlander going twice in a 5 game series finding a way to beat Boston. Yankees could wind up playing the Tigers in the ALCS without Verlander until game 3.

      Can the Yankees get to and win the World Series this year? Absolutely. Are they the favorites? No. But no trade would have made them the favorites short of getting a Kershaw or Hernandez who weren’t available. And who knows, perhaps one of them will be in the next year or so and the Yankees now can use their prospects to try and get them.

  84. Jimmer says:

    y would cashman care bout making a deal he’s leaving after this season anyways haren and lee will bite us in the ass for years

  85. Kevin says:

    Seattle backstabbed us in the Lee deal. There was NOTHING Cashman could have done in that case. After that, Lee made it clear where he wanted to play, and nothing Cashman,CC or anyone else said was going to change his mind.
    Haren is a gaffe, no doubt about that but do people really want to gut our farm system for question marks?

  86. Hall and Nokes says:

    Where does Montero bat on Tuesday

Leave a Reply

You may use <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> in your comment.

If this is your first time commenting on River Ave. Blues, please review the RAB Commenter Guidelines. Login for commenting features. Register for RAB.