A.J. Burnett’s Five Best Starts As A Yankee

Mariano's last waltz
Yanks place four on Baseball America's Top 100 Prospects List
(Jed Jacobsohn/Getty Images)

The Yankees said goodbye to A.J. Burnett over the weekend, eating a big chunk of the $33M left on his contract in order to send him to the Pirates. He seemed like a nice enough guy but was one of the most frustrating pitchers to watch that I’ve ever seen, and while we appreciate his contributions to the 2009 World Championship, none of us are going to lose sleep over his departure. It’s just the way it is.

A.J. did have some fine moments as a Yankee, though over the last two seasons the team had a knack for giving him zero run support whenever he did throw a gem. Of the 12 times he threw at least seven innings and gave up no more than two runs since the start of 2010, the Yankees lost four times. That’s just not supposed to happen with this offense and bullpen. Anyway, we’re going to look back at Burnett’s five greatest starts as a Yankee using a simple metric called Game Score. Wikipedia has the nuts and bolts, if you’re interested. Fifty is an average Game Score, and the highest ever recorded was Kerry Wood’s 20-strikeout game (105). Anything above 75 or so is pretty stellar.

Game Two of the 2009 World Series does not make this list; it was the eighth best start of Burnett’s three years in the Bronx with a Game Score of 72. That said, it was easily his biggest moment as a Yankee given the pressure and everything riding on that game. As you’ll notice, four of Burnett’s five best games came back in 2009, which isn’t surprising given how awful he’s been over the last two years.

5. July 27th, 2009 @ Rays (box) (video) (RAB recap)
Pitching Line: 7 IP, 2 H, 1 R, 0 ER, 2 BB, 5 K, 114 pitches
Game Score: 74

The Yankees were in cruise control by this point of the season, already well on their way to clinching the AL East title in late-July. The lineup gave Burnett an early three-run cushion by starting the second inning with a single, a double, and a triple off Jamie Shields, allowing their right-hander to pitch around baserunners in the first (walk), second (walk), and third (single) innings. A.J. was perfect in the fourth and fifth before allowing a run to score on an Evan Longoria ground ball double play in the sixth.

The Phils – Coke and Hughes – were both unavailable that night, so the bullpen was pretty thin. Joe Girardi sent Burnett back out for seventh with his pitch count already over the century mark, but he got three outs on just ten pitches. He gave up only two ground ball singles (one towards third and the other between first and second), though he did allow one other baserunner when B.J. Upton reached base on a wild pitch following a strikeout. The offense blew things open late and the Yanks sailed to an easy win.

4. April 14th, 2009 @ Rays (box) (video) (RAB recap)
Pitching Line: 8 IP, 3 H, 2 R, 2 ER, 1 BB, 9 K, 103 pitches
Game Score: 76

(Al Messerschmidt/Getty Images)

If you remember, the rotation was a bit of a mess early in 2009. CC Sabathia’s career in New York was off to a slow start, Chien-Ming Wang was both dreadful and injured, and Joba Chamberlain was still figuring things out as a starter. Burnett and Andy Pettitte were the only reliable arms Girardi had at the time. In his second ever start as a Yankee, Burnett was tasked with going deep into the game because the bullpen had taken the pounding the previous two days. Things got so bad that Nick Swisher had to throw an inning the night before.

A.J. was simply unhittable, at least for the first six innings. He retired 18 of the first 19 men he faced, the lone exception being a one out walk to Pat Burrell in the second. Four of his seven strikeouts up to that point were called on fastballs, a pitch he had working on night. When he was spotting the heat on the corners, it was a thing of beauty. The Rays opened the seventh with three straight singles, but Burnett stopped the bleeding with a fly ball, a strikeout, and by picking Carlos Pena off first. He started the eighth at just 93 pitches, then sat the Rays down in order on ten pitches to end his night. Only seven of the 27 men he faced managed to hit the ball out of the infield.

3. August 7th, 2009 vs. Red Sox (box) (video) (RAB recaps)
Pitching Line: 7.2 IP, 1 H, 0 R, 0 ER, 6 BB, 6 K, 118 pitches
Game Score: 77

You all remember this game, this was the 15-inning walk-off win against the Sox. The very first batter of the game — Jacoby Ellsbury — lined a single to center, and that was all Boston got against Burnett. Four of the six walks were “strategic” walks as Joe likes to say, meaning A.J. pitched around guys (Dustin Pedroia and Kevin Youkilis specifically) at times when they could have done some serious damage. I like to call it the worst great game as ever, as both Burnett and Josh Beckett always seemed to be on the edge of disaster but never caved.

After a hectic first inning (the single and a pair of walks), only five of the final 22 batters Burnett faced managed to hit the ball out of the infield. He exited the game with two outs in the eighth after walking Ellsbury on four pitches, clearly fatigued after seven stressful innings. The game was barely more than halfway over by then, but for the first time as a Yankee, Burnett did exactly what the team was paying him to do: beat the Red Sox.

2. April 29th, 2010 @ Orioles (box) (video) (RAB recap)
Pitching Line: 8 IP, 3 H, 0 R, 0 ER, 1 BB, 4 K, 116 pitches
Game Score: 79

This game was all about Robinson Cano, who was in the middle of his coming out party as an MVP-caliber player. He went 3-for-4 with a double and two homers, raising his early-season batting line to .407/.444/.790. Burnett made Robbie’s production stand up on the run prevention side of things, throwing strikes (77 of 116 pitches were strikes, 66.4%) and getting both grounders and lazy fly balls with his fastball and curve. Only two batters made it as far as second base in his eight innings, and A.J. retired the last eight men he faced.

The key to the game was strike one. Burnett threw a first pitch strike to 21 of the 28 men he faced (75%), well above his career average (57.6%) and the league average (58.8%). After starting the first two batters of the game off with a 1-0 count, he went 0-1 on 19 of the final 26 batters. Once behind in the count, the O’s couldn’t sit fastball and had no chance against the hook. The strikeout total isn’t sexy, but Burnett was overwhelming that night.

1. June 27th, 2009 @ Mets (box) (RAB recap)
Pitching Line: 7 IP, 1 H, 0 R, 0 ER, 3 BB, 10 K, 108 pitches
Game Score: 82

The amazing thing about this game is that I don’t remember it at all. Not one tiny bit. I remember the following game — that’s when Francisco Rodriguez walked Mariano Rivera with the bases loaded to force in the go-ahead run in the ninth — but this game? Forget it, nothing.

At the time, the Mets were completely ravaged by injury. The only three current big leaguers in their starting lineup were David Wright, Daniel Murphy, and Brian Schneider, and Wright’s protection was Ryan Church and Gary Sheffield. That’s not to take away from what Burnett did, because it was a dominating performance, but my goodness. The Mets never had a chance.

A.J. carried a no-hitter through five before Alex Cora led off the sixth with a single, and two of his three walks came in the span of three batters in the second inning. Of the 25 batters he faced, five hit the ball out of the infield. Five. Burnett was in the middle of his best run as a Yankee, an eleven start stretch from late-May to late-July in which he held hitters to a .209/.316/.308 batting line with a 2.08 ERA in 69.1 IP. We would see glimpses of that A.J. from time to time, but never a sustained period of dominance like that again.

Mariano's last waltz
Yanks place four on Baseball America's Top 100 Prospects List
  • Mike Myers

    This makes me feel even better about the salary dump. His best starts were all in 09 and one in 10 against the terrible O’s.

  • Paul VuvuZuvella

    Great article Mike. Thanks for the memories A.J.

  • Plank

    Please don’t post the obvious companion piece to this one. I won’t even mention it’s subject.

    • http://twitter.com/tjamato TJ

      I’d actually love to read that story but I’m a total masochist.

    • Havok9120

      Me too.

      Bring teh payne!!

    • Plank


  • Max

    The first one on this list is my favorite. Good game, but also that awesome action slide on the grounder that got past him is just fantastic. I remember watching the highlights of that game the next day with my jaw on the floor.

  • joek

    Its funny to read the comments on the recaps from those games

  • JoeyA

    Funny, Mets fans probably remember it like it was yesterday, as that fanbase tends to focus more on the negative than the positive, at least in recent memory.

    Most of my friends are Mets fans who have a Napolean complex re: the Yankees like I’ve never seen.

    Even Metsblog writer Matt Cerrone was tweeting earlier today that he, as a Mets fan, can’t wait for Mo to retire so we, as Yankee fans, can experience the misery that is a normal ML closer.

    I subsequently reminded Mr. Cerrone that the Yankees 7th inning pitcher is better than anyone they have in their bullpen.

  • David Ortiz’s Dealer

    I think AJ can turn it around, good AJ was pretty good, just bad AJ was pretty bad, you never heard about him not working or anything. Thanks for 2009.

  • Al

    “I let a few too many people tinker with me, maybe,” Burnett said. “When you let that happen, you start doubting yourself sometimes. You wonder, ‘Am I doing it right? Is this how it’s supposed to feel?’ and things like that. In ’09, nobody messed with me. I was able to do what I wanted to do on the mound, whether it was turn around, close my eyes and pitch upside down. Then you have a few bad games and you start changing and listening.”

    Yankees should send Rothschild to the same island as Dave Eiland was shipped to. How dare they tinker with AJ? Dont they remember what he did in 09 without any tinkering?
    I bet Pittsburgh’s pitching coach is stoked to have heard this rant.
    He has been gone one day and already starting his whining.

  • Sam

    I wonder what the best start of ’11 was for aj

  • Robinson Tilapia

    Good AJ is always an awesome sight. I hope there’s still some bullets left for him in Pittsburgh.

  • Kiko Jones

    It still feels bad to pay someone $20m to pitch for another team…anyway, he got a ring, we got some thrilling moments and hopefully he rebounds out in Pittsburgh.