The David Purcey Band-Aid

Report: Noesi up to replace Ayala
Plotting the rotation going forward

The Yankees were dealt a double bullpen whammy yesterday, as Pedro Feliciano suffered a setback with his strained rotator cuff and Luis Ayala hit the disabled list with a strained lat. It appears as though Hector Noesi will get the call for now primarily because the Yankees aren’t exactly brimming with call-up candidates at the moment. Both Andrew Brackman and Steve Garrison made minor league starts last night, and so they’ll be unavailable for a few days. Ryan Pope is on the minor league disabled list himself. That leaves Andy Sisco and George Kontos along with the rehabbing Mark Prior. This is where David Purcey comes into play.

(AP Photo/The Canadian Press,Nathan Denette)

Purcey, an out-of-options lefty reliever, was designated for assignment by the Blue Jays yesterday, effectively ending a six-plus year relationship. They selected him in the first round of the 2004 draft out of Oklahoma (a year after the Yankees took him as a draft-eligible sophomore in the 17th round), but Purcey climbed the ladder slowly because of various minor injuries. He made his big league debut as a starter in 2008, but has since moved to the bullpen full-time. Toronto expects to trade Purcey, and they should be able to find a taker since he’s left-handed and on the right side of 30 (he turns 29 in about a week). Given the Yankees’ bullpen situation at the moment, he does make sense for them.

Purcey passes the eye test; he’s a 6-foot-4, 240 lb. left-hander that sits around 93 mph with his fastball and occasionally touches 95. Just about three out of every four pitches he throws is a fastball, and he’s since scrapped the curveball he used as a starter and replaced it with a sweepy slider. That pitch has helped him rack up just about eight strikeouts for every nine innings pitches as a big leaguer. He’s done well against lefties since moving to the bullpen, striking out more than one out of every five batters with a ground ball rate close to 50%, limiting them to a .287 wOBA. That’s not great, but we’re talking about the 25th man on the roster remember, the low-leverage lefty specialist.

The problem with Purcey has been and always will be throwing strikes. He’s unintentionally walked 4.58 batters per nine innings his career, 4.46 as a reliever, and 5.61 against lefties. If he was perfect, the Jays wouldn’t have cut him. The Yankees would obviously be banking on Larry Rothschild and Mike Harkey ironing enough things out so that Purcey becomes usable in a game that’s remotely close, something Ayala really isn’t. The Yankees and Blue Jays haven’t made a trade in a long time (last one was Raul Mondesi), but we’re not exactly talking about a Roy Halladay here. Trade talks for a spare part between division opponents shouldn’t be that difficult, especially since Toronto has no leverage because they have to move Purcey within the next week or lose him on waivers for nothing. Whatever they get is a bonus, and that bonus will likely be some Single-A prospect no one will miss.

Remember, not everyone on the roster has to be here for the long haul. I’m looking at Purcey as a short-term solution that will eventually be displaced by Feliciano or whoever comes back next, just a guy to fill a spot and eat some unimportant inning from time to time. Think Billy Traber or Jim Brower or Brett Tomko. He’s just a band-aid in my eyes, a big, hard-throwing, left-handed band-aid that could even surprise us and prove useful in one of the most insignificant roles imaginable.

Report: Noesi up to replace Ayala
Plotting the rotation going forward
  • Monteroisdinero

    Sounds like you could substitute the words “Boone Logan” for alot of Purcey’s description above.

  • Yank the Frank

    MLB Trade Rumors also have the Astro’s in the mix. I would think Toronto would want to make a deal outside of their division if they can. He does not seem like a make or break guy anyway.

  • Fair Weather Freddy

    I remember Yanks originally drafted Purcey in the 17th round out of H.S but didn’t sign him.

    • tommiesmithjohncarlos a/k/a Ridiculous Upside the Elder

      (psssst… it’s noted in the article)

      • Fair Weather Freddy

        (psssst) I only read the headline.

  • Matt :: Sec110

    Yeah, I was thinking the same when I saw he was DFA…what’s the risk? Plus if feliciano is out for a while, you might as well try and catch lightning in a bottle.

  • RL

    Not sure if they killed, him, his injury killed him, or his mental make up killed him. While the Yankees’ decision to move him back and forth between reliever/starter/reliever and inning limits and sending mixed signals to him may have contributed to him not achieving the potential we were all led to believe he had/has, I don’t think any of us can legitimately and difinitievely state it was them.

    • RL

      Reply fail. This was meant for the Noesi call up thread. Don’t know why this happens occassionally to some of us.

  • Smallz

    As long as we dont have to cut anyone from the 40 man it sounds like a good move to me, if it works out you could probably just cut Ayala

    • Rick in Boston

      You can’t DFA Ayala if he’s on the DL. Maybe somebody gets shifted to the 60-day DL to open up a spot.

      • Smallz

        I meant when hes healthy if Purcey actually pitches well

  • tommiesmithjohncarlos a/k/a Ridiculous Upside the Elder

    Cash considerations and a fringy guy, like Vazquez/Parraz/Pendleton/Kontos, something of that ilk?

    Or maybe Russo, since he’d probably need to get DFAd to open a spot for Purcey anyway?

  • Hurling Darvish

    Pass. He’s not much of an upgrade over Logan, and not worth the roster spot. Also, Toronto will try to get us to overpay for him.

    Some teams may perceive him as a potential starter, since he’s not a career LOOGY, which may increase the demand/cost of acquiring him.

    • tommiesmithjohncarlos a/k/a Ridiculous Upside the Elder

      Some teams may perceive him as a potential starter… which may increase the demand/cost of acquiring him.

      Maybe the Red Sox should trade for him. He’d probably be an upgrade on Matsuzaka and Lackey.

  • Gonzo

    What no posts about the “he’s better than _____” test?

    • Slu

      At this point I think anyone is better than Logan.

    • Cuso

      “_____” is better than what we have.

  • Cuso

    The 25th man on the Yankees roster will never be a pitcher.

    It will always be Eduamiro Penez

  • A-Rod’s Wingman

    Do it now. If it’s like some piece of crap for Purcey then obviously do it, Boone Logan was able to pull out a good year last year maybe it will be David Purcey this year. Relievers are volatile, bad relievers have good years and good relievers have bad years. Shit happens.

  • RealFan

    A lefthander who can’t get the ball over the plate. What a joke. This is the Yankees and not the Mets.

  • http://na ANSKY

    Purcey can get out lefties… Logan can’t get anyone out. Last year was a fluke… Anytime the Braves give up on a pitcher…rest assured he is probably done.