Fan Confidence Poll: February 3rd, 2014


2013 Season: 85-77 (637 RS, 671 RA, 77-85 pythag. record), didn’t qualify for playoffs

Top stories from last week:

Please take a second to answer the poll below and give us an idea of how confident you are in the team. You can view the interactive Fan Confidence Graph anytime via the nav bar above, or by clicking here. Thanks in advance for voting.

Given the team's current roster construction, farm system, management, etc., how confident are you in the Yankees' overall future?

Categories : Open Thread


  1. The Great Gonzo says:

    With the giant gaping hole at 3B, I am most surprised that Mustelier doesn’t at least get a look in Tampa. Seemed like this would be the ideal time to take all the infielders to camp to see what sticks. But, in fairness to the club, he sucked it up in grand fashion in 2013.

    Regardless, the Tanaka haze has not worn off yet, and guys like Drew still being unemployed offer the chance of him being signed under market value…

    So we go 8 today.

  2. BrianMcCannon says:

    I’ll go with 7 given the addition of Tanaka and relative inactivity within the division.

  3. Jorge Steinbrenner says:

    7.5 rounded up is an 8. Not a finished product, by any stretch, but I do believe that both patience could wind up being a virtue here with strenghtening the team before Opening Day and that the team has done a good job overall with the cards presented to them.

    I’d have concerns about this team, but I’d go to the battle with them feeling good about things if I had to right now.

  4. Peyton Manning says:

    Sign Drew and Jimenez

    • Jorge Steinbrenner says:


      • CS Yankee says:

        Are you referring to his game last night or that is a troll comment?

        He has a decent point on those players…i don’t see either happening. I don’t want Drew and Jimenez is a wildcard, which we have one of those with Pineda…hard to drop 40M$ on a wildcard when they just dropped 175M$ on a foreign wild card.

        • The Great Gonzo says:

          You seriously cannot compare Ubaldo and Tanaka, can you? Even if you take the bodies of work out of it, just in terms of sheer upside…

          Someone can go ahead and bookmark this, I don’t want to be reminded of this in 3 years, but its not out of the question. CS is right, wildcards and all.

          • CS Yankee says:

            I was just having fun comparing O:S to the SB, but boy did the threads below go crazy.

            I’m not a Drew fan, him or his bro, he didn’t want to be a NYY…fine. He might be the best available, but it isn’t what i would like to add.

            Jimenez is a WC as he can be great, average or Hughes-like. To me, a clear WC which I would be fine with if we didn’t sign a bigger WC (which I’m fine with). I do believe that Jimenez was the best bet to have a big year out of the domestic choices (Santana, Garza, Arroyo, etc), but Tanaka is the better, but far more costly, bet.

            • RetroRob says:

              Right. Ubaldo has great ability, but he’s never had command. He did have a nice finish to 2013, just like he had a nice first half in 2011 (or was it 2010?). So he has shown he can pull it together for a few starts at a time, but never for a season.

              Wild card. Intriguing wild card, but a wild card nonetheless.

        • Jorge Steinbrenner says:

          It’s probably the same commenter, under a different screen name, trying to shove this down our throat again.

          There’s a valid argument to be made for both. I’m ambivalent on Drew and lean no on Jimenez, but I wouldn’t necessarily argue too strongly against either.

          • Jim Is A (Bored) Peckerhead says:

            You should have gone with “It was a joke”, because Operation Shutdown is exactly what happened last night.

            • Jorge Steinbrenner says:


            • Amelia says:

              Oooooooohhhhhhhhh people who nobody cares about might not respond to people who nobody cares about. You and your buddies are such TOUGH GUYS! Hmmmmphh!!

              Spare me this shit man. You and your idiot make believe buddy Jorge along with several others take this blog way to damn seriously. Get out of mom’s basement and enjoy life.

              • Jorge Steinbrenner says:

                Ten internet dollars this is the original commenter.

                My mother lives in South Florida. Sea level. No basements. I moved out when I was 20 and currently have a better job than you’ve ever had in your life, live in a better neighborhood you’ll ever live in, and built a happier family than you’ll ever have.

                I can multitask very well. One hand’s on RAB. One’s evaluating paperwork. You don’t even want to know what the third hand is doing.


              • Jim Is A (Bored) Peckerhead says:

                Hahahaha at least give me credit where credit is due.

                You should have said “Stop commenting on RAB and get back to work”.

              • Jim Is A (Bored) Peckerhead says:

                Did you miss that I was making a Super Bowl joke and not even remotely talking about the Yankees, RAB, or anything even remotely pertinent to anything?

              • jjyank says:

                Question: How many handles have you used to say the same things to the same people?

                And which one here lives in his mom’s basement again? Right. You.

              • jjyank says:

                “You and your idiot make believe buddy Jorge along with several others take this blog way to damn seriously.”

                …says the guy getting all hot and bothered over nothing. Maybe take your own advice there buddy.

              • Macho Man "Randy Levine" says:

                Are you having life issues we should know about? We are a group that is interested in helping others out, believe it or not.

  5. Frank says:

    5. Still alot of ?s (BP, infield) despite spending nearly a 1/2 billion dollars. Minor league system is not very good with no position player(s)who can contribute now if needed (maybe Zoilo).

  6. Farewell Mo says:

    6. Definite holes in BP and infield but they did as well as could have possibly been expected this offseason

    I’d be a 7 though if they invited Mustelier to ST.

  7. Algernon Blackwood says:

    Nice to see the site back online. This weekend was like a bad flashback to the internet of 1998.

  8. I'm One says:

    7. Looking forward to Spring Training, a reasonably healthy team, good production from Teix, Jeter, CC and the new aquisitions and a bounce back from the prospects. Then I’ll be much closer to a 10.

  9. BamBamMusings says:

    Wanna know why the Yankees have no youngsters? Cause we the fans, aren’t happy unless we give out exorbitant contracts to replacement level or over-the-hill free agents at every spot on the roster.

    • Jorge Steinbrenner says:

      The funny thing about that is that, again, this is the same exact complaint fans had about the team in the 80′s and in the previous decade.

      It also, seemingly, goes hand in hand with fan expectation that “championship or bust” be taken as literally as can be.

      It’s why such a big section of casual Yankee fans are completely insufferable.

      • Jorge Steinbrenner says:

        (Not describing you directly. More of a general comment.)

      • BamBamMusings says:

        But really, how much difference will there be between a major question mark in Ubaldo (who had 6 good starts down the stretch against the worst AL teams VS 3 declining seasons) and a Phelps or Pineda?

        How large a gap is there from an average fielder average bat Drew to a Roberts + Ryan + Johnson combo?

        Are these type of players really impacting fan confidence?

        • Jorge Steinbrenner says:

          Agree wholeheartedly.

          I’d like to increase depth here. Drew passes for name recognition right now because…..by God, I have no clue why he’s suddenly seen as a household name.

          • Farewell Mo says:

            In all fairness, if you look up Drew’s numbers you’d see he can easily and reasonably be expected to be somewhere between a 3-4 WAR player which is more than the entire 4 man infield is projected to be worth at this point

            He’s really not just some name of the month or shiny new toy. He’s likely add 2-3 wins to this team which could be crucial.

            I’m not in the camp of “we must have him or Cashman Sux” but as Mike has stated many times, his signing would make perfect sense.

            • Jorge Steinbrenner says:

              Yes, and I think you’re still representing the bullish view on Drew.

              Like I said, I wouldn’t be upset to see him walk through the door. I just think he’s being quite overvalued here. We hear just as many comments thinking Kelly Johnson will hit .240 with 18 HR’s this season.

              • Farewell Mo says:

                Possibly but Look at Drew’s stats

                2010: 4.7 WAR
                2011: 1.7 WAR in half a season
                2012-recovering from a major ankle injury
                2013: 3.4 WAR

                I don’t think it’s unreasonable to expect him to have a 3-4 WAR season in 2014.

                • Jim Is A (Bored) Peckerhead says:

                  Shhhh. Drew is borderline replacement level…

                  • Farewell Mo says:

                    Plus he’s still only 30 years old and another year removed from a devastating ankle injury. As a lefty batter in YS3, he could be a steal at the 3/$40-45 range

                    Why does everyone think he’s so much worse than he really is?

                    • Jim Is A (Bored) Peckerhead says:

                      There are plenty of actual reasons not to want to sign him.

                      He’s replacement level isn’t one of them!

                • Jorge Steinbrenner says:

                  They’re having a much better discussion on him than I’m going to invest in having right now below. :)

            • BamBamMusings says:

              I disagree. Not only did he fade down he stretch. He became a platoon player who couldn’t get a base hit in the playoffs if he were getting pitched underhand. But that’s not it, we are interested in bringing him in to switch his position (the biggest strength he has) and assume he’ll be just as good at a completely new position @ 3B or 2B. You’re kidding yourself if you think there’s a 4 WAR in that experiment…

              • Jim Is A (Bored) Peckerhead says:

                Yeah, a 132 wrc+ in august and september is really fading down the stretch.

                If we’re going to start judging people on single playoff appearances, then how about 2007 when he was amazing? I can’t believe we’re still obsessed with small sample sizes.

                • BamBamMusings says:

                  3 year average is a small sample size? And again, he is not being evaluated as a SS option. We are looking at him from a position switch. So any increased value you placed on him due to defense, needs to be retracted.

                  • Jim Is A (Bored) Peckerhead says:

                    80 at bats.

                    Dude, tell me where you see that he’d be switching positions permanently. At MOST it’s a 1 year switch, and he’ll inherit SS next year.

                    You said he faded down the stretch, funny how you have no response to that and chose to ignore it.

                    • BamBamMusings says:

                      So you have insider info that DJ is retiring? Whatever your plans may be for him, he is not supplanting Jeter, nor is he better defensively than Ryan! Therefore, he is not coming here to play SS.

                      The playoffs were the stretch. He looked like the worst player on the field easily!

    • Lets go Yankees says:

      the grades should be a bit higher. we did land 4 of the top 6 FA this year.

      • JGYank says:

        But we also lost the best FA/best 2b in the game, a #3 starter, the greatest closer of all time, and a LOOGY. Hopefully Tanaka replaces Pettitte and Robertson can replace Mo but our pen and infield still has questions from the losses. But overall I think we improved especially in the outfield.

        • Lets go Yankees says:

          yeah but almost 50% of the grades are at 6 or lower. thats crazy when a team signs 4 of the top 5 or 6 free agents! retirements happen. nothing we can do about that. cano is the only knock on the offseason. and you can even make a case that letting him walk i/o matching the crazy 10 year contract he got was the right thing to do. so i dont see why the confidence level should be 6 or lower for half of the fans?

          • JGYank says:

            It’s not half the fans, it’s about 20-25% who are probably disappointed after last year and are concerned about the holes, inury history, and age of the roster.

            • Lets go Yankees says:

              23 + 13 + 5 + 3 + 2 = 46%

              1 (no confidence)

              • JGYank says:

                There’s nothing wrong with being a 5 or 6. 4 or 3 is low, and 1 or 2 is just ridiculous. I just threw a percentage range out there.

                If you’re in the 5-8 range IMO it’s reasonable.

      • Ethan says:

        I don’t think the grades are too low. I think they’re reasonable accurate. The Infield has just too many question marks. The rotation is average. I think anyone voting over 8 is insane, especially if you consider beyond next year.

        Yes they brought in a lot of players but they performed so poorly last year I’m still not convinced they are a playoff team.

        • BamBamMusings says:

          ** The Infield has just too many question marks. ** –> Sign 3 players to IF depth and there are too many Q?

          ** The rotation is average. ** Have 3 possible # 1 or 2 SPs and the rotation is average?

          ** they performed so poorly last year** –> 87 win team

          Perfect example of a spoiled fanbase! Every team has question marks. You cant just throw big money at whatever is sitting out there to address question marks.

          • Ethan says:

            Just because you have a lot of INF depth does not mean there aren’t question marks. Who knows what Jeter can do? Roberts is almost a lock for an injury by May, Johnson will be helpful but nothing amazing. Mike said Cano alone could like out-WAR the entire Yankee infield this season. That’s problematic.

            CC, Tanaka and Nova have a lot to prove. If they all pan out, amazing! But I’m skeptical. Tanaka will likely be a 4 ERA guy this year. Nova is a total question mark, same with CC. Again, many question marks there.

            85 win team. But their Pythag record was much worse. They definitely played above their heads last year. If they can do it again, that would be awesome but not likely.

            Bullpen will probably be significantly worse unless a few signings are made before opening day which is looking less and less likely.

            For me there are just too many Ifs to give this team an 8. I’m sitting at a 6. If they all work out (highly unlikely) that would be awesome but you just can’t count on that.

            • Jorge Steinbrenner says:

              “Just because you have a lot of INF depth does not mean there aren’t question marks.”

              Of course this is true, but depth is going to help mitigate that a bit. More depth means more competition and more options for the team. I actually do think we stand a better chance of not having an Alberto Gonzalez at third base by May, even if the starting options aren’t thrilling.

              Don’t get caught up on numbers. Two different people will vote a 5 and an 8 for the same reasons. This isn’t scientific.

    • The Great Gonzo says:

      Because we, the fans, don’t realize that for every team that makes a successful rebuild look so easy, there are 10 teams who don’t get it right and miss the playoffs in significantly weaker divisions. Of course, when I say “we”…

      Also, “Yankees have no youngsters” =/= “give out exorbitant contracts to replacement level or over-the-hill free agents”… Those two things are so incredibly mutually exclusive, its not even funny. If you trade a youngster for over the hill players, which only applies to ICHIRO on our 25 man roster, then you have an argument. But there are no successful teams out there, save for the Cardinals, who churn out quality minor leaguers year over year and still compete year over year.

      And the Cards do it in a markedly weaker division. They might be Orioles caliber in the AL East. Who’s to say.

      Go cheer for the Mets if you want to see Youngsters at every position. Enjoy the Lucas Duda era. We’ll be here…

      • BamBamMusings says:

        Its not even about churning out youngsters as much as it is chasing borderline replacement level FAs!

        • Jim Is A (Bored) Peckerhead says:

          This year? Who’s a borderline replacement level FA?

          If you’re still harping on last year, fine, but man, that is NOT a trend. That was a pretty unique offseason with unique circumstances surrounding age and injury. Did we handle it well? Nope, definitely not, but it’s not like signing Vernon Wells is an annual custom.

          • BamBamMusings says:

            Borderline are the Drews and Ubaldos of the world.

            The only impact player left on FA is Cruz and we have no room for him. I dont see why we are even talking about signing all of these other guys?

            • Jim Is A (Bored) Peckerhead says:

              Drew is not borderline replacement level. Not when healthy.

              I hate that I have to keep defending a guy who I don’t want to sign.

              • The Great Gonzo says:

                THIS. I still think its inevitable, but man…

              • BamBamMusings says:

                OK lets take a look at his numbers over the last 3 seasons shall we?

                He averages:
                244 BA
                315 OBP
                10 HR or 400 SLG

                Post season averages last 2 years w Oak + Bos
                150 BA
                230 OBP
                290 SLG


                Any defensive grades you want to apply will be a complete guess since he’s only played SS and he will not supplant Ryan defensively there.

                So how exactly is he such a good player?

                • Jim Is A (Bored) Peckerhead says:

                  I’m excited that you shifted your argument away from “Borderline Replacement Level”, because that’s what I was responding to.

                  You, not me, are the one who used the “Replacement Level” term.

                  So here.

                  Last 3 non-injury shortened seasons:

                  4.7 WAR: defense: 15.4 RAR
                  1.7 WAR: defense: 8 RAR
                  3.4 WAR: defense: 10.9 RAR

                  If you want to argue the injury thing, be my guest. That’s partially why I don’t want to sign him.

                  But if you’re going to go into the SABR world, you should probably look things up before you comment.

                  • lou says:

                    You guys do know the just about the entire Yankees infield is “replacements”

                    • Jim Is A (Bored) Peckerhead says:

                      OK if you’re not going to read any of the conversation and jump in late, I guess it makes sense that your comment would have nothing to do with what we’re talking about.

              • RetroRob says:

                People confuse replacement level players with league average players, but there is a huge difference. A team of replacement level players wins maybe 46?, 47?, 48 games over the course of full season. They’re pretty bad. Drew is most certainly not replacement level.

                As a hitter, Drew’s bat has played at league average, but that’s not a bad thing since he is a SS. A league average hitter at SS is not a bad things at all.

                I am not on board with saying he’s a 3-4 WAR player, though. He once did have a 4.7 WAR season, but that was back in 2010 and is a bit of a UFO season and we pre injury. Looking at his entire career since 2006, there is nothing there that would guarantee he’ll be a 3-4 WAR player. I think that’s his ceiling. That WAR is also driven off some kind defensive metrics that many evaluators do not believe.

                He’d be nice to have at a nice price. Don’t love him, especially with those home/road Fenway splits. Still have questions about him.

                I’m with you. I don’t really want them to sign him unless it is at a good price and especially contract length. Yet those calling him replacement level are off base.

            • LK says:

              I can’t imagine how a baseball fan could think Nelson Cruz is better than Stephen Drew in the year 2014.

              And I don’t even think Drew’s *that* good, he’s just much better than the dumpster fire that’s currently passing as the Yankee infield. Cruz, though? He hasn’t topped 2 WAR since 2010, which is also the year he turned 30. He’ll hit you 25 bombs and do literally nothing else.

      • Jim Is A (Bored) Peckerhead says:

        I kinda doubt the Cardinals would be Orioles caliber in the AL East.

        • The Great Gonzo says:

          OK, bad example. But would they be, as they are constructed now, a top level AL East team? I highly doubt it. They win 85 playing year in and year out in the AL East, which would lead most teams (including the Holy Grail of Player Development Cardinals) to spend some money and prospects to shore up those last 3-5 wins.

          I hypothesize that the Cardinals are what they are because they can compete in that Division year in and year out without having to spend a ton of money to get pushed over the edge. They become dirty pillars of the FA & Trade business in baseball if they have to deal with the pressures of a tighter division.

          • Jim Is A (Bored) Peckerhead says:

            I mean the NL central as presently constructed isn’t shitty, though. 2000-2011 or so, yeah. Even so, the just seem to have really good ownership, and those arms they keep churning out would be good whether they’re in the NL Central, AL East, or the All-Universe division.

            • The Great Gonzo says:

              Its nwhere near the strongest division over the past decade though. 2013 there were legit teams there, but historically, they are not even the strongest division in the NL.

              Valid point about their pitching though, can’t touch it. Can’t knock it.

      • Lets go Yankees says:

        what does it have to do with cheering for the mets? you’re saying since they dont have a good minor league system, they have’to run out the check book and outbid themselves in a weak market for below average players?

        if you want to spend your money, spend it on the top talent. not on the crap that no other team in the league wants. just because we still have question marks, doesnt mean we have holes!

        • Jim Is A (Bored) Peckerhead says:

          Dafuk? A weak market? What the fuck have you been watching?

        • Jorge Steinbrenner says:

          For every commenter saying what you’re saying, there’s people advocating multiple years and double-digit AAV for guys like Omar Infante and Stephen Drew. Hell, I’ll raise my hand and say guilty as charged on Infante for a couple of days there.

          No one can deny there are holes. The issue is whether we should be so hard pressed to fill those holes with future problems.

          I understand the issue as to lack of young players ready to go right now. I also think we sometimes expect a candy store in which we go in and say “hey, we need a third baseman,” and a surefire 22 year-old All-Star appears in front of us. No one has that.

          I’m not even sure if I’m agreeing or disagreeing with you here.

          • The Great Gonzo says:

            And also, the Yankees spent the money on the TOP CATCHER, 2 of the 3 TOP OUTFIELDERS, and the TOP STARTING PITCHER. OK, they didn’t signed Drew, Balfour, or Cano, but those were the TOP GUYS in their respective positions.

            Actually, I agree with Jorge, I am not sure what side you’re on right now.

        • The Great Gonzo says:

          Could you kindly define ‘weak market’ and ‘below average’?

    • The Big City of Dreams says:

      Wanna know why the Yankees have no youngsters?


      The have youngsters but turning them into even solid major league players seems to be harder than they thought it would be.

      • Jorge Steinbrenner says:

        It’s hard for everyone. We remember the successes but always forget that 26 year-old bouncing around the waiver wire who was once someone else’s first-rounder. There’s plenty of them. Hey look, there goes Lars Anderson.

        • The Big City of Dreams says:

          True the success are remembered more but that goes for everything. I think when it comes to ppl being down on the farm it always goes back to The Big 3. If those guys don’t struggle as much as they did it’s a completely different story.

          • Jim Is A (Bored) Peckerhead says:

            ManBan is NOT DEAD, PEOPLE.

            • The Great Gonzo says:

              Cashman failed by not wrapping his elbow in Tommy John proof bubble-wrap

            • The Big City of Dreams says:

              True he’s not dead and I’m still a believer in him but I think the concern is the missing a couple of seasons due to injury and his size is something ppl have always commented on. TJS is not the end but I think some ppl wonder if it’s just a sign of things to come.

              • Jorge Steinbrenner says:

                I’m more concerned about two years away, but I know the talent is there.

                • The Big City of Dreams says:

                  Hopefully they can reap the reward of having that talent develop. They need a couple of these guys to make an impact.

              • Jim Is A (Bored) Peckerhead says:

                I think we all know why people are concerned.

                If you want to assume the worst, you’re free to.

                And I’m free to call you short-sighted and pessimistic.

                • The Big City of Dreams says:

                  That’s fine. I’d rather them show me first then just blindly believe that it’ll work out. The Yankees have been down this road before.

          • Jorge Steinbrenner says:

            I think we read too much into single-A numbers as well.

            This is why I love Chad Jennings’s “talk to me when they’re doing it in AA” take on things.

            • RetroRob says:

              Yup. That’s why I am not getting excited about Gosuke Katoh. He his well in rookie ball, the same league another teenager — DBJ — destroyed after signing, and since has been eaten alive by low A ball pitchers.

              Carry it up into A ball and I’ll start to be intrigued. AA ball, then I’m excited!

              • Jorge Steinbrenner says:

                I don’t even think about Katoh other than being glad he’s there.

                I pay slight attention to Jagelio because he’s supposed to be the fast riser.

                The road is just too long.

  10. Masahiro Dinero says:


    I’ll trend higher once I see Jeter and Tex on the field, lower if they can’t hack it.

  11. CS Yankee says:

    A big fat eight!

    SP, C & OF looks beast mode
    RP looks meh
    IF looks dicey

    Prospects, to me, seem real good, maybe great if you look at/below AA.
    Payroll is in a decent spot…not 189-BS, not 250-sick either.

  12. Tanuki Tanaka (Formerly Bob Buttons) says:

    8 because I’ve had a good night’s sleep and a good breakfast so I’m pretty optimistic right now.

    Probably will be a 7 if I voted after waiting around at the bus stop for what feels like two eternities.

  13. Jim Is A (Bored) Peckerhead says:

    1, as in the number of inches of wet, slushy snow we’re getting after the prognosticators spent all weekend predicting 5-8 and an excuse to leave work early.

    Weather men and the people predicting an interesting super bowl had a bad weekend.

    • CS Yankee says:

      Funny how more people voted a 1 than a 2.

      Poll should shake out something like;

      1) Should mean that you have given up on baseball and maybe even life
      2) Means that you think they are the same as the Cubs who can’t even put in a new scoreboard.
      3) Astros level of payroll, play for the first choice in next years draft. Business ROE is king.
      4) Marlins, K-mart menality…everything must go.
      5) Mets, poor billionaires who if it wasn’t for the commish they would have been Ebay-ed.
      6) KC, Milwaukee or another dozen or so of good, but great is the real enemy.
      7) A legit contender every year.
      8+) A very well run team that’ll overcome most challenges.

  14. adeelmd says:

    Agree with Jimenez & Drew, possible add Koon (if he were ok with a relief role). I consider these “luxury” signings, meaning only do them if Yankees can get them on below market deals. Doubt that will happen with Boris clients, but its getting late and I wouldn’t be surprised if people would be more willing to take a short term contract on a playoff caliber team to improve their market.

    IE, Jimenez is not going to get 100 million or even a 75 million contract (50 is a BEST case scenario); but two good years on a team can change that.

    • The Great Gonzo says:

      Do you mean Suk-min Yoon? Because I am a little uncomfortable with John & Suzyn saying ‘Koon’ 98 times every 5th day.

      Also, I would not be opposed to a Yoon signing, so long as its pretty low risk deal.

      • Jorge Steinbrenner says:

        There’d be a reference to some 1930′s showtune, and then it’s really all downhill from there.

        • The Great Gonzo says:

          Counterpoint, this might be just what the doctor ordered to get them off the air finally. I might be in support of signing this ‘Koon’ fellow.

          • The Great Gonzo says:

            Also of note, I am showing restraint by not adding the remaining list of possible free agents that could get Ma & Pa off the air…

  15. YankeeFan91 says:

    If we sign ubaldo and add another reliever I’m at a 9.

  16. JGYank says:

    6.5. The Yanks improved, but are still old and injury prone and have a couple holes to fill. They have to rely on comeback years from CC Tex and Jeter and still have huge contracts limiting our payroll flexibility, but they’re clearly willing to spend and might not be done adding. The farm needs a bounce back year and it would help if it can produce a ML ready RP. A lot could go wrong, but the talent is there and I like the additions they’ve made. This team has a ton of potential and the outfield and probably the rotation should be solid. They are definitely going to be competitive this year and I think they have a good shot at a WC and possibly even the east if things break right. I can’t wait for ST to start and am craving to watch Tanaka on the mound.

    • I'm a looser and a trader baby so why don't you kill me? says:

      It’s funny as I agree completely with everything you said but land at a 5 nonetheless. Of the laundry list of issues you mentioned a handful will have to go right before I notch up to 6-7.

  17. AllyinCt says:

    7, but I’d be 8 if we ever sign Jeff Baker…lol.

  18. Paddy's Pub says:


    Shit ton of money spent to make this a 3rd place team. No farm system to speak of. Infield has the potential to be a complete disaster.

    • Jim Is A (Bored) Peckerhead says:



    • The Great Gonzo says:

      The troll is strong in this one

    • TWTR says:

      To prove your not a troll, make the positive case, because there is one.

    • jjyank says:

      Life must be so much fun when only the negative side of things is taken into account.

    • Paddy's Pub says:

      Sorry I hurt your feelings, guys.

      I should’ve known better than to express an opinion. That’s totally on me and I accept the consequences.

      What I should’ve done is talked about ALL the positive things that went into my confidence number being a 4… because that’s obviously such a great score. Allow me to redact and do over:


      Loved the Ellsbury signing. Elite money for an elite player. That’s how it’s done. Farm system in for a HUGE rebound year with all two of their top 100 prospects. Not just one of them. Both should have big years. This team is filled with recent homegrown players like Gardner, Nova, Robertson and… and… other guys too. And if the entire infield stays healthy for the entire season, and Derek Jeter can produce offensively like he’s in his early 30s, and something tells me Jeter might be a little rusty defensively, but if he can go back to the Gold Glove level defender he was before his ankle injury, and if wrist surgery didn’t rob the power from an already declining player in Teixeira, and if Brian Roberts and Kelly Johnson have monster career years, WATCH OUT. This could be one of the greatest Yankee infields in history.

  19. lou says:

    Before the Tanaka signing I was at a 4 givin holes in the rotation and the infield seems to be a mess. I moved it up to a 6 after the Tanaka signing but the Yankees still lack an infield. If the Yankees could go out and get two every day players to punch in at 2b and 3b I’d prob move it up to an 8 and that’s where I would stand until I would see something come outta Yankee camp.

    • lou says:

      I feel that if the Yankees go out an sign another FA pitcher it makes them a better them. As Phelps, Warren could go to the pen and it actually might open a door for a trade for infield help during the season. Yankees spent a boat load of money so far so why stop at a terrible infield and it’s not like there is complete junk to sign there are still a few very good FA’s.

  20. jarak says:

    Get Baily or Hanrahan, Rodney too Benitez like. Jeff Baker would make me happier. Still a 7.

  21. Chip Rodriguez says:

    8. I’d be a 7, but Jayson Nix is now with the Rays, so yay!

  22. qwerty says:

    Just buy a couple of aging and overpriced free agents and all of a sudden fan confidence in the future is up. LOL. Yankee fans are sooo easy to please.

Leave a Reply

You may use <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> in your comment.

If this is your first time commenting on River Ave. Blues, please review the RAB Commenter Guidelines. Login for commenting features. Register for RAB.