Yanks lose Sabathia, lose 4-3 to Indians on Andy Pettitte Day

Yuck. Sunday afternoon started with the Yankees retiring No. 46 and dedicating a plaque in Monument Park in honor of Andy Pettitte, but the fun stopped there. They dropped the thoroughly disappointing series finale to the Indians by the score of 4-3.

(Al Bello/Getty)
(Al Bello/Getty)

Bum Knee
The Yankees, who are already thin on rotation depth, lost their leader in innings pitched Sunday afternoon. CC Sabathia exited the game with right knee pain in the third inning, after allowing two runs on a Carlos Santana two-run home run. It was a no joke homer. CC missed out over the plate with an 88 mph nothingball and Santana hit it into the visitor’s bullpen in the first inning. Statcast says it traveled 430 feet.

Sabathia walked four batters in 2.2 innings and looked out of sorts all afternoon. It was clear from the get-go this was going to be an ugly start. His velocity was down even compared to his other starts on normal rest, and Sabathia struck out just one batter, the last one he faced. He threw the pitch, got Yan Gomes to swing and miss, then trainer Steve Donohue came out and Sabathia left the game. It was not good. The Yankees are running out of rotation caliber arms.

A Missed Opportunity
With no outs in the third inning, the Yankees had two runners on base and a 3-0 count on No. 3 hitter Carlos Beltran. They needed the Indians to make an error to score that inning. Beltran swung at the 3-0 pitch and hit it to the warning track for the first out. He hit it well, but Trevor Bauer leads the AL in walks and had thrown six of his last seven pitches out of the zone. Odds of him throwing three strikes before one ball were low. Not sure I like swinging 3-0 there.

Jacoby Ellsbury advanced to third on Beltran’s fly ball, then scored on Brett Gardner‘s stolen base attempt. Gomes made a high throw to second, the ball deflected off Fransisco Lindor’s glove at the apex of his jump, and hopped away from the infield. Ellsbury was able to trot in for the run. Brian McCann and Greg Bird both struck out looking to strand Gardner at second. That inning went from potentially great to a letdown in a hurry. Huge moment in the early innings.

(Al Bello/Getty)
(Al Bello/Getty)

Bullpen Marathon
Once Sabathia was out of the game, Joe Girardi did that thing where he uses his entire bullpen in reverse order of his trust in the relievers. Nick Rumbelow replaced Sabathia and was charged with a run in two innings. A Chase Headley throwing error set the rally up in the fifth — Headley made a poor throw but Bird won’t see an easier hop the rest of the year, it was right at his chest and he whiffed — before Gardner and John Ryan Murphy teamed up for a damage-limiting double play.

The Tribe had runners on the corners with no outs, Santana hit a lazy fly ball to left, and Gardner was able to throw Mike Aviles out at home. Murphy did a great job coming out in front of the plate to catch the throw, then leaning back to apply the tag in one motion. Pretty slick play. Rumbelow intentionally walked pinch-hitter Jason Kipnis, then Branden Pinder came in and walked the next two batters, the second with the bases loaded. That was the run charged to Rumbelow. Blargh.

Pinder allowed a single and walked another batter in the sixth, but did not allow a run. He got two quick outs in the seventh before allowing a triple to Abe Almonte. Next up on the trust depth chart: Chasen Shreve. He struck out Jerry Sands to end the inning. All things considered, one run in 4.1 innings from the soft part of the bullpen is pretty good. The Indians had a ton of base-runners — 16 in the first six innings! — but never broke it open.

(Al Bello/Getty)
(Al Bello/Getty)

The Comeback
The Yankees didn’t get much of anything going against Bauer after that third inning. He retired eleven of 13 batters after that inning and it wasn’t until the seventh that New York had any kind of serious threat. The game-tying rally started with a Stephen Drew walk — he fell behind 0-2 and came back to draw the walk — and continued with an Ellsbury double to right with one out. They were in business.

Between the walk and the double, Alex Rodriguez pinch-struck out for Murphy, which was a weird decision. Girardi gave up the DH with that move, and it was only the seventh inning of a two-run game. Plus he had a short bench because Mark Teixeira‘s banged up. Oh well, I guess we wouldn’t complain if A-Rod homered. Anyway, Gardner struck out for the second out of the inning, then Beltran blooped a game-tying ground rule double to left.

Prior to Ellsbury’s double, the Yankees were hitless in ten at-bats with men in scoring position. Ellsbury’s double was smoked to right field but Beltran’s double was the definition of “hit it where they ain’t.” It was just beyond the reach of the outfielder and just inside the foul line. Perfectly placed. That was the big hit the Yankees were struggling to get earlier this series.

(Al Bello/Getty)
(Al Bello/Getty)

The Letdown
Once the game was tied, Girardi went to Dellin Betances in the top of the eighth, and he promptly walked the No. 9 hitter on four pitches. That’s okay! Only because McCann threw the pinch-runner out trying to steal second. Phew. Unfortunately, Lindor tomahawked a 3-2 fastball into the short porch for a go-ahead solo home run. The pitch was up in the zone but Dellin usually gets away with it. Not against Lindor though. Man is that kid impressive. The Indians took the 4-3 lead.

The Yankees did get a runner on base with one out in the eighth, but Didi Gregorius flew out and Drew stuck out on three pitches in a non-competitive at-bat. It was pathetic. Took two breaking balls for called strikes then swung over a pitch that nearly hit him in the foot. The Yankees went down 1-2-3 in the ninth, though Ellsbury should have walked. Home plate ump Tom Woodring called what should have been ball four strike three. His zone was brutal all day:

Tom WoodringLeftovers
The Yankees had five hits total. Ellsbury singled and doubled, Beltran doubled, and both Headley and Bird singled. They did draw six walks though, including three by Gardner and two by Drew. Gregorius had the other walk. The offense went 1-for-8 with runners in scoring position and geez, I don’t even remember eight at-bats with men in scoring position. Seems like a lot.

Justin Wilson tossed a scoreless ninth after Betances gave up the go-ahead run. Andrew Miller was warming up as well, but apparently down a run is less important than tied, so Wilson pitched. Six Yankees pitchers combined to walk ten (!) batters in nine innings. It’s the first time they’ve walked ten in a nine-inning game since June 2010.

And finally, the Yankees went 2-5 against the last place Indians this year, and four of the losses were by one run. That doesn’t make it any easier to swallow. They’ve done a really bad job of beating up on bad teams. That is a big reason why the AL East lead disappeared.

Box Score, WPA Graph & Standings
You can find the box score and video highlights here and here, respectively. Here are the updated standings and postseason odds, as well as our Bullpen Workload and Announcer Standings pages. Now here’s the loss probability graph:

Source: FanGraphs

Up Next
The four-game series with the Indians is finally over. The Astros are coming to the Bronx next for the final series in this ten-game homestand. Nathan Eovaldi and Scott Feldman will be the pitching matchup Monday night. RAB Tickets can get you in the door if you want catch any of the three games against Houston at Yankee Stadium.

Update: CC Sabathia exits Sunday’s start with right knee pain

(Stephen Dunn/Getty)
(Stephen Dunn/Getty)

2:41pm: Sabathia left the game with right knee pain and will have an MRI, the Yankees announced. That’s the knee with the degenerative condition Sabathia has had surgically repaired three times — including a season-ending clean out procedure last summer — and drained twice already this season. Not good news.

2:12pm: CC Sabathia left Sunday afternoon’s start with an unknown injury in the third inning. He struck out Yan Gomes, walked around the mound slowly, then Joe Girardi and trainer Steve Donohue came out to talk to him. Sabathia didn’t lobby to stay in the game or throw any test pitches. He went right to the clubhouse. Here’s the video.

One thing we’ve learned about Sabathia in recent years is that he will pitch hurt. He pitched with a bone spur in his elbow a few years ago, has pitched through on and off knee trouble throughout his career, and even pitched through a Grade II hamstring strain two years ago. For Sabathia to leave like that, he must really be hurt.

The Yankees have not yet announced any sort of update on Sabathia, so stay tuned. Michael Pineda (forearm) is due to come off the DL on Wednesday and Bryan Mitchell is making progress after being hit in the face by a line drive, so the team can fill the rotation spot. Hopefully it’s nothing serious. We’ll see.

Game 123: Andy Pettitte Day

Yesterday afternoon the Yankees retired No. 20 and dedicated a plaque in Monument Park in honor of Jorge Posada, and today they’ll do the same for Andy Pettitte. No. 46 is officially coming out of circulation. This weekend honoring two all-time great Yankees continues today with Andy Pettitte Day.

Pettitte is arguably the best starting pitcher in franchise history and I don’t think I know a single person who doesn’t love Andy. He is the franchise’s all-time leader in strikeouts (2,020) and is third in innings (2,796.1), wins (219) and pitching WAR (51.6). Andy is certainly the team’s best starter during the expansion era, if nothing else.

Hall of Famer? I’d say Pettitte is borderline at best. He is a five-time World Series champ and was a rotation stalwart during the most recent Yankees dynasty, but his candidacy will be hurt by his performance-enhancing drug ties. Either way, Andy’s going into Monument Park, and deservedly so. Monument Park was built for guys like Pettitte.

Just like yesterday, fans have been asked to be in their seats by noon for the pregame ceremony, though the actual ceremony probably won’t start until 12:15pm or 12:30pm ET or so. YES will have the whole thing, as always. As for this afternoon’s game, here is Cleveland’s lineup and here is New York’s lineup:

  1. CF Jacoby Ellsbury
  2. LF Brett Gardner
  3. RF Carlos Beltran
  4. DH Brian McCann
  5. 1B Greg Bird
  6. 3B Chase Headley
  7. SS Didi Gregorius
  8. 2B Stephen Drew
  9. C John Ryan Murphy
    LHP CC Sabathia

It’s a bit cloudy in New York today and there is some rain in the forecast, but not much. Nothing that will ruin the ceremony or cause a postponement. The game is scheduled to begin at 1:05pm ET and you can watch on YES. Enjoy the ceremony and the game.

Injury Updates: Mark Teixeira (leg) did some light running and took batting practice for the first time since the foul ball. It seems unlikely he will play tomorrow … Bryan Mitchell (face) threw a bullpen session. He could make a minor league rehab appearance next, then come off the DL … Alex Rodriguez is healthy. Joe Girardi said he is trying to “refresh” him with two straight days off.

Roster Update: Garrett Jones, who was designated for assignment a few days ago, has been unconditionally released. He’ll probably hook on somewhere and serve as an extra lefty bench bat in September.

The Speed of the Game

It’s Friday night and I’m standing in left-center at Teufel Field. It’s the bottom of the first inning and there are runners on first and second with one out and the fourth hitter¬†for the opposing team is at the plate with a 1-1 count (thank you, speed up rules). Our pitcher sets on the mound, rears his arm back, and arcs the ball towards home plate. The batter swings and sends a sinking line drive in my direction, slightly to my left. Eyes squinted in the less-than-idea lighting, I sprint towards the ball charging forward, sliding at the last second, securing the second out before popping up and trying (and failing) to double up the runner at second. This play could’ve happened at least three times in the amount of time it took me to write this and for you to read it. The game is fast, and that’s just slow-pitch softball. On Saturday afternoon at Yankee Stadium, I got even more education on the speed of the game.


For the first time, I sat in the Legends seats–Section 14B, Row 2. As someone who played ball growing up and has watched and attended countless games, viewed from all over various in-stadium locations, I certainly knew how quick the game could be, but being so close hammered the point home (rudely at times, like Abraham Almonte’s screaming foul liner that buzzed our collective tower). ¬†From Didi Gregorius‘s speed to the velocity of the pitches delivered by Luis Severino, Danny Salazar, Dellin Betances, and Andrew Miller, “fast” was the best way to describe yesterday.

With regards to that ‘micro-level’ speed, sitting so close to the action only furthered my appreciation for just how incredibly difficult baseball can be. The way hitters can react quickly enough to not just hit the ball, but hit it with authority, driving it all over the place, never ceases to amaze me. The way infielders can react to sharp ground balls and calmly field them is a near marvel; that they can seemingly flick their wrists and throw the ball harder than I could overhand is another feat that leaves me speechless. Because the players aren’t zooming around the field like they would be in basketball, hockey, soccer, or football, we don’t necessarily think of baseball as a speed sport, but it is unavoidably so.

On the ‘macro-level’ of speed, there was the pregame ceremony for Jorge Posada. As I watched him receive his plaques and gifts, I couldn’t believe almost four calendar years have passed since Jorge suited up for the Yankees. While his former teammates lined the infield grass, I remembered playing Wiffle Ball with friends in my front yard, imitating the batting stances of the men I was looking at–Derek Jeter, Paul O’Neill, Tino Martinez, Bernie Williams, Posada himself… Obviously, many years have passed since then, but the memory didn’t–and still doesn’t–seem all that distant. Like the thrown and batted balls, like the lighting-fast pitches, the memories of players passed reminds us that the game moves quickly no matter how you look at it. We could all do well to slow down and appreciate it, from the tiny bursts of speed on the basepaths, to the (hopefully) magnificent careers blossoming in front of us.

DotF: Aaron Judge’s monster game leads Scranton to a win

Triple-A Scranton (11-5 win over Lehigh Valley)

  • CF Ben Gamel: 1-5, 1 R, 1 RBI, 3 K — threw a runner out at third
  • 2B Rob Refsnyder: 2-5, 3 RBI, 1 SB — had been in a 3-for-21 (.143) rut
  • LF Jose Pirela: 0-4, 1 R, 1 RBI
  • DH Gary Sanchez: 1-5, 1 R, 1 HR, 3 RBI, 2 K — 17th homer of the year leaves him one shy of his career high, set back in 2012 … he’s third in the minors in homers among catchers (two others are tied at 19)
  • RF Aaron Judge: 3-3, 1 R, 1 2B, 1 HR, 1 RBI, 2 BB, 1 SB — monster game … he’s been struggling of late, but this is a nice little reminder of the kind of impact he can have
  • C Austin Romine: 3-4, 1 R, 1 2B, 2 RBI — had been in a 4-for-30 (.133) slump
  • RHP Kyle Davies: 6.1 IP, 9 H, 4 R, 4 ER, 2 B, 4 K, 6/3 GB/FB — 60 of 102 pitches were strikes (59%)
  • RHP Caleb Cotham: 0.2 IP, 0 H, 0 R, 0 ER, 2 BB, 1 K, 1/0 GB/FB — eleven of 19 pitches were strikes (58%)
  • RHP Andrew Bailey: 2 IP, 3 H, 1 R, 1 ER, 0 BB, 1 K, 2/0 GB/FB — 18 of 24 pitches were strikes (75%) … have to think he’ll be a September call-up as long as he stays healthy

[Read more…]