Today’s Crazy Idea: Javy for Werth

Photo Credit: Matt Slocum, AP

The trade deadline really brings out the dumb in people. Stupid trade rumors come with the territory, and we’re certainly no exception. So you’re going to have to forgive me for a second while I throw something out there. Ready for this one? Javy Vazquez for Jayson Werth. Seriously, hear me out before you delete your RAB bookmark.

Buster Olney says that the Phillies are talking to a bunch of teams about possible matches for Werth, and are looking for what he calls “a proven starting pitcher who could be a No. 2 or No. 3 type of guy” in return. Well, Javy fits that bill. You can argue that he’s more of a number four based on his dreadful April, but I’m not going to waste my time with that. The guy’s got a 3.05 ERA (3.94 FIP) in his last ten starts, and the Yankees would have won more than six of those games if they bothered to score more than two runs in three of the four losses.

But there’s a fit here because each team has something the other team needs. The Phils need a starter, and the Yanks could use an extra bat. Furthermore, both players are free agents after the season and are projected to be Type-A free agents, so each team will still get their two extra picks in the epiphany draft of 2011. The money doesn’t match up perfectly – Javy is owed $5.54M the rest of the way, Werth $3.41M – but that’s something that could easily be worked out (I think).

What would the Yankees be getting in Werth? Basically a righthanded hitting version of Nick Swisher, that’s what. Werth’s triple-slash line sits at .279/.365/.518 (.378 wOBA), which is perfectly in line with his performance over the last two seasons. There’s no fluke, it’s an established level of performance. Werth has also shown that the friendly confines of Citizen’s Banks Park aren’t the cause for his success, he’s wOBA’d .389 and .374 on the road in the past two years. His three year UZR in right sits at +17.5, and he can even play center in a pinch, not that the Yankees would need him too. Want steals? You got them too. Werth has swiped 44 bags in 49 tries over the last three years (89.8%). The guy does pretty much everything.

The Yankees could use him in a four man outfield/designated hitter rotation with Brett Gardner and Curtis Granderson and Swisher, adding some considerable length to their lineup while assuming avoiding the risk of taking on a huge contract. Well, that last part isn’t entirely true, because you’re giving up a quality innings eater, which is risky by default. The team would have to feel comfortable with someone like Sergio Mitre or Ivan Nova or maybe even Dustin Moseley taking the ball every fifth day, which might not sound so appealing given the team’s shaky bullpen. They do have options however, so the answer to that final rotation just might be there.

Remember, Ruben Amaro Jr. hasn’t exactly distinguished himself as an astute general manager. He gave three year contracts to 30-something’s Raul Ibanez and Placido Polanco, two year deals to Ross Gload, Danys frickin’ Baez, and 46-year-old Jamie Moyer, traded Cliff Lee for peanuts only to have interest in reacquiring him six months later, gave Ryan Howard that completely unnecessary extension, plus a whole bunch of other questionable moves. Amaro seems to be very much stuck in the early-00’s way of doing things; big names, big contracts, poorly thought out trades. A Werth-Javy swap is unlikely, but not completely insane. I think. Of course, Werth would have to lose the Baseball Jesus look if a trade did happen, which would be a shame.

In all seriousness, the Yanks can use the extra bat, and they do have four other quality starters in the rotation to rely on. They’d be robbing Peter to pay Paul, which is always sketchy when you’re talking about starting pitching. So what do you think, good idea? Bad idea?

Mailbag: Vazquez, Rule 5 Draft, Gaudin, Cash

We received some positive feedback following last week’s mailbag, so it’s definitely looking like something worth doing. You can send your questions to us at any time via the Submit A Tip box under The Montero Watch in the sidebar, or by just emailing them in to us. This week’s topics: Javy Vazquez and arbitration, the Rule 5 Draft, Chad frickin’ Gaudin, and figuring out what the hell “cash considerations” are…

Do you think that the Yankees will offer Javy Vazquez arbitration after the season? They’ve shied away from the practice in recent years, but you risk getting a good pitcher at a reasonable salary on a one-year deal for two high picks, right? Especially if they lose picks for a Lee or Crawford this offseason. – Dominik

I’ve been thinking about this more and more as the season goes on. My stock answer has been “no,” simply because they haven’t offered anyone arbitration over the last two years, and I had no reason to believe that they would change that approach now. Now I’m not so sure.

There is a difference between Vazquez and guys like Bobby Abreu and Johnny Damon, the notable players that weren’t offered arbitration over the last few years. Those guys were really overpaid (Abreu made $16M his last year with the Yanks, Damon $13M) and stunningly bad on defense, and in Abreu’s case, he was clearly in decline offensively. Their defense negated a ton of their offensive value. Pitchers are different because a) there’s only one aspect of the game to evaluate, and b) quality arms are so damn valuable.

Of course we can’t ignore the red flags. Javy’s velocity is absolutely down this season, likely due to all those miles on his arm, and his strikeouts are down while the walks are up. His FIP (5.02), xFIP (4.62), and tRA (4.97) are the highest they’ve been in more than half-a-decade.  Believe it or not, Vazquez has benefited from some BABIP luck this year (.255), which you can’t count on going forward. That said, he’s still a very capable MLB starter that can easily hold down the fourth spot in any team’s rotation, which is what the Yanks would expect him to do. If he were to accept arbitration, he’s looking a $13-14M, which is certainly overpaying. It is just a one year deal though, and the Yanks can afford the luxury. Remember, there’s no pitching version of Nick Swisher to buy low on to fill that rotation spot.

At this point, yes, I do expect the Yanks to offer Vazquez arbitration. It’s been made clear that the team considered the two 2011 draft picks as part of the deal, and Vazquez comfortably projects to be a Type-A free agent. As you know, they have to offer him arbitration to receive those picks. Next year’s draft class is absurdly deep; a team could realistically walk away with a player that would be a top ten talent in a “normal” year despite picking in the 20-30 range. If there’s ever a draft to have an extra pick, that’s it. The Yanks also can’t lose those picks if they sign Cliff Lee or Carl Crawford or whoever.

Given the uncertainty of Andy Pettitte, plus the possibility of Lee signing an extension after inevitably being traded, offering Vazquez arbitration is a risk worth taking. Then again, I said the same exact thing about other players over the last two years, only to watch the Yanks not offer arbitration to anyone.

Which minor leaguers are eligible for the Rule 5 draft after the season? Of these, who do you think the Yankees will protect?  I’m interested to see what they do with Dellin. – Big B

College players drafted in 2007 and high school players drafted in 2006 are eligible for the Rule 5 draft this year, so that includes Zach McAllister, Dellin Betances, Ryan Pope, Bradley Suttle, Austin Krum, Justin Snyder, and Brandon Laird. Some holdovers from last year include George Kontos, Lance Pendleton, and Josh Schmidt. It’s tough to figure out exactly when players signed off the international market, so I usually just skip them when discussing the Rule 5 draft.

So how many 40-man roster spots are opening up after the season? I count nine: Chad Gaudin, Sergio Mitre, Chan Ho Park, Andy Pettitte, Mariano Rivera, Javy Vazquez, Derek Jeter, Marcus Thames, and Nick Johnson. Both Juan Miranda and Jon Albaladejo will be out of options next season, so they could be gone as well. Wilkin DeLaRosa and Dustin Moseley are imminently DFA’able, so I would count on them being gone as well. Mo and Jeter are obviously coming back, so let’s call it 11 total spots opening up after the season.

You have to figure that at least two of those spots are going to starting pitchers, two or three more are going to relievers, and two or three more are going to position players. So for all intents and purposes, let’s assume the team will have four 40-man spots to use for protecting prospects from the Rule 5 Draft.

McAllister and Laird are no-brainers, they have to be protected otherwise they will be lost. Their success at Double-A all but guarantees that. Suttle, Krum, Snyder, Pendleton, and Schmidt aren’t high priority guys, so they can go unprotected. Those last two spots come down to Betances, Pope, and Kontos.

Betances has been absolutely fantastic this year since coming back from elbow surgery (34 IP, 13 H, 2 R, 2 ER, 6 BB, 39 K), and non-contending teams will take a big arm like that and see if he can’t stick in the bigs all year. Pope has been fantastic since shifting to the bullpen (27.2 IP, 3.09 FIP, 30-6 K/BB ratio, .223 AVG against) and is a viable relief option for next season. If nothing else, he’s a guy that will always be on call in Triple-A. Kontos is coming off elbow surgery like Betances, though he’s had some success at the higher level.

I think Pope gets protected just because you can’t let such a close to the big leagues reliever go for nothing. The Yanks will need the inventory. If the Yanks don’t believe Betances can make it through the entire 2011 season on some team’s 25-man roster, they won’t protect him. They did the same thing with Ivan Nova. They could gamble on him going to camp with some team only to have him be offered back at some point. Of course Betances is a much different prospect because he has such enormous upside, so they may not be willing to risk it. Me? I’d protect him. Too risky to lose a guy the team invested so much time and money ($1M signing bonus plus all the costs associated with his rehab and surgery). Kontos is the cost of doing business, I was never a huge fan anyway.

Why is Chad Gaudin so bad this year? He was somewhat “decent” last year, and was supposed to be in the mix for the 5th starter job in ST. I don’t think we expected him to win any Cy Youngs, but mediocrity should not have been too much to ask. – Anonymous

I’m kinda surprised that Gaudin has been so dreadful. I never expected him to be awesome, but I figured he could replicate the 4.68 xFIP he posted with the Yanks last year. Instead, we’ve got a 5.60 xFIP after Gaudin put up a 3.94 xFIP in Oakland. And think, the righty has had some serious BABIP (.244) and strand rate (83.3%) luck with the Yanks.

The obvious problem is all the homeruns. Gaudin has served up nine long balls in 33.2 IP this year after giving up just 14 in 147.1 IP last year. His fly ball rate has climbed close to 10% from last year and sits at 44.6% in 2010, and his HR/FB rate is through the roof at 20%. For comparison’s sake, the league average is around 10.6% and he was at 9% last year. It’s a combination of bad luck and bad pitching. Yes, he should give up more homeruns because he’s giving up more fly balls, but not that many more homers.

Gaudin’s slider is letting him down this year (4.57 runs below average per 100 thrown after several years of being above average by a run or more), so perhaps he’s hiding an injury. Or maybe he just stinks.

MAILBAG! When a player gets traded for “cash considerations” what, exactly, does that mean? Is there a list of guidelines defining what is and is not, can and cannot be deemed cash considerations? Is there a deadline on when the cash has to be delivered? I’m thinking that it means they need to work out a deal and can’t haggle the money but are close enough where they say eff it we’ll figure it out. I am hoping, however, that there is some sort of structure to it. – Justin

I have no idea, but Keith Law does, so I asked him. His response: “Undisclosed [amount] but fixed at the time of the deal. It’s really just a straight sale, usually for ten or twenty grand.”

Simple enough. I assume it’s delivered immediately, or at a time specified when the deal is made.

Hello, Mark. So nice to see you.

Photo credit: Seth Wenig/AP

Sure, it’s the year of the grand slam, but that’s not the only thing powering the Yankees offense. They’re getting huge contributions from players who, while good, weren’t expected to hit quite this well. Brett Gardner, Robinson Cano, and Nick Swisher have put together superb first half and have been key components of the Yankees’ offense. In fact, they represent the Yankees top three offensive performers in terms of wOBA, beating out the two guys who inhabit the middle of the order, Mark Teixeira and Alex Rodriguez.

If, before the season, you said that Cano, Swisher, and Gardner were hitting better than Tex and A-Rod, I’d have thought that both had hit poorly before going on the DL. That would have been one of the only plausible explanations. Instead it has been a matter of both hitters, while excellent at times, simply hitting poorly for stretches. Both have had hot streaks, but they’ve counterbalanced those with some cold streaks that have played a big part in run-scoring droughts. Even so, with the contributions of Cano, Swish, and Gardner, the Yankees have scored the second most runs per game in the AL. If they score eight tonight they’ll be tied for the league lead with Boston.

For Tex in particular it has been a rough season. His current wOBA, .348, is nearly 40 points lower than his career average of .387. His power is the most noticeably missing component of his game, as his .198 ISO sits far below his career average of .250. Yet his peripherals seem fine. His walk rate is actually above where it was last year, and his strikeout rate is right in line with the norms. He’s not hitting any fewer line drives, and even his plate discipline numbers are decently in line. In fact, he’s actually making more contact on pitches within the strike zone, both compared to his career and compared to the league average. I would think that he’d get more hits because of it, but his BABIIP is about 50 points below his career rate.

Teixeira’s season started in frustrating fashion for the second straight year, as he hit .136/.300/.259 through the end of April. He destroyed the White Sox to start off May, and then even hit three homers in a game against Boston a few days later. All in all it wasn’t a bad month, .280/.366/.475, but Tex did struggle at times, slumping mid-month. But then June started off slow again. He went 3 for 24 with one double to start the month, bringing his season totals to .211/.326/.363. Worse, his struggles culminated on June 5 with a five-strikeout game. Everything seemed to be working against Teixeira.

That five-strikeout game, however, might have been the turning point for Tex. He did go 0 for 4 the next day, but even counting that Tex has hit .295/.400/.581 in his last 125 PA, rates far more in line with the performance he posted last season. Teixeira, 30, is also at an age where we it’s not out of the ordinary for him to hit better than his career numbers. If he continues hitting like he is now — that is, to the level he hit during the course of 2009 — his numbers should look just fine by the end of the year.

Right now Teixeira has 381 PA. If he reaches the 707 he had last year he’ll get another 326 PA this season. If he continued at the pace he’s been at since the five-strikeout game, he’d pick up 81 more hits, 159 more total bases, 42 more walks, eight more HBP (probably out of line), and 2 more sac flies. Add them to his current totals, and here’s how Tex’s season would look at the end, given 707 PA and 598 AB:


While that’s not the Teixeira we saw tear up the American League last year, it’s certainly acceptable given his first half struggles. At that point the focus will be on his torrid second half production, rather than the peaks and valleys of his first half.

The best part is that it’s safely within the realm of possibility that Tex continues this pace. The numbers are only slightly better than the ones he produced last season, and actually right in line with the .313/.390/.601 line Tex hit in the second half of last season. He is, as they say, a second half hitter. In his career he has a .870 OPS in the first half and a .968 mark in the second.

If it feels like we’ve waited forever for Teixeira to turn it around, it’s because we have. We know he starts slow, but this year he just couldn’t get into a rhythm. In the path month it appears he’s found that. He has hit in 24 of the 28 games since the five-strikeout affair, and while the majority of them are one-hit games, he’s made up for that by hitting the ball hard. His season numbers won’t approach the bar he set last season, even the bar he set for his career, but given his first half struggles, I think that if he continues producing we can safely say that all is forgiven.

Burnett solid again as Yanks complete sweep

This game followed a pleasant arc. It started off frustrating, with the Yankees loading the bases with one out in the first only to squander the situation. They then blew a first and second situation in the second, so it started to feel like one of those games. That the A’s jumped out to a 1-0 lead didn’t help. But from the fourth inning on everything went smoothly. They did strand a few more baserunners, but with the lead already in hand and Good A.J. on the mound it didn’t really matter. The Yanks easily completed the sweep with a 6-2 win.

Biggest Hit: Teixeira caps the rally

Photo credit: Ben Margot/AP

The Yanks had a few chances in the first three innings to put some runs on the board against Gio Gonzalez, but stranded all their runners each time. In the first it was the bases loaded and one out followed by two strikeouts. In the second both Brett Gardner and Ramiro Pena singled with one out, but Jeter killed them with a double play. In the third Swisher led off with a double, took third on a fly ball, and watched as A-Rod and Jorge struck out. Opportunities with runners in scoring position: seven. Yankee runs: zero.

Even in the fourth it seemed like more of the same. Marcus Thames opened the inning with a single, but Francisco grounded one to Mark Ellis and ruined it. But then Brett Gardner drew a six-pitch walk. WIth Pena up he swiped second, and then scored to tie the game when Ramiro Pena singled. A wild pitch and a Derek Jeter single gave the Yankees the lead. Nick Swisher followed that with a walk, putting two on with two out for Teixeira.

It took just one pitch for him to open up the game. Gonzalez dealt a 92 mph fastball that got neither down enough nor away enough. Tex hit it deep to center, clearing the wall and giving the Yankees a 5-1 lead. It’s the second straight game in which a middle of the order bat came through with a game-changing home run.

Biggest Pitch: Crisp gives the A’s a lead

Photo credit: Ben Margot/AP

He looked like Good A.J. right from the beginning. Through two innings A.J. Burnett had retired all six batters he faced, two on swinging strikeouts. With two outs in the third he had thrown just 32 pitches. But then he walked Cliff Pennington and let him steal second. Coco Crisp followed that with a single to give the A’s an early lead. It was no biggie, though. Burnett got Daric Barton to end the frame.

A half inning later the Yanks gave Burnett a big lead, and he never put it in question. He struck out only one more and allowed five more baserunners, but the A’s weren’t making great contact. Of the 13 balls the A’s put in play from the fourth through the seventh, eight were on the ground, and two were pop ups. It would have been nice to see some more strikeouts, but all considered it was a second straight good start for Burnett.

Most surprisingly, Burnett threw nine changeups. He didn’t generate any swinging strikes, but he did throw it six times for a strike. He said he started throwing it more last game. I’m not sure it’s a difference maker, but it sure hasn’t hurt.

Speaking of difference makers, between innings the YES cameras showed Burnett palling around with Dave Eiland. Of course they did. It’s a story. Causation? Maybe. Certainly can’t rule it out. It’s just so odd that a 33-year-old pitcher would completely fall apart without the pitching coach he’s had for just a year and a few months out of a 12-year career.

Swish makes the case

Photo credit: Ben Margot/AP

There’s been plenty of campaigning to Send Swish to the All-Star game. A 3 for 4 night with a walk, a double, and a homer helps his case for sure. Not as much as the ballot stuffers, of course, but it helped nonetheless. He got a chance to do even more damage in his last at-bat, but ended up flying weakly to center on what appeared to be a hittable pitch.

All-Star game or not, Swish has had a hell of a first half. He’s hitting .299 right now, which is significantly above his career average. He’ll need to go 6 for 16 this weekend against Seattle to head into the break with a .300 batting average.


It was a good idea to get Marcus Thames out of the field when Gonzalez came out of the game, but damn, Curtis Granderson really isn’t doing anything. The Yanks will face three lefties this weekend, and I figure Granderson will play. It’s not like he’s hitting righties much better right now.

After a pair of homers last night A-Rod was the only starter without a hit last night. He did, however, manage to look foolish while falling down on a misjudged foul pop.

The team was just 3 for 13 with runners in scoring position, but when one of those is a three-run home run it’ll do.

That makes it five straight for the Yanks with four left until the break.

Graph and chart

Box and graphs.

Next Up

The Yanks move northward to Seattle, with Andy Pettitte going against Jason Vargas in the fourth of the six straight 10 p.m. starts.

Miranda’s hot streak continues in SWB win

Make sure you scroll down for tonight’s game thread.

Both Kelvin Duran (“65 runner with true centerfield skills and a bit of pop out of a smallish frame; a sleeper worth watching”) and Corban Joseph (“showing impressive power and patience”) got some love in Kevin Goldstein’s Minor League Update today (sub. req’d). KG also said that Adam Warren has been sitting “91-94 comfortably” this year, calling him a “solid No. 4. projection, maybe a bit more.”

Triple-A Scranton (7-2 win over Rochester)
Reid Gorecki, CF: 0 for 4, 1 BB, 2 K
Reegie Corona, 2B: 0 for 5
Eduardo Nunez, 3B: 1 for 3, 2 R, 1 2B, 1 BB, 1 HBP – the pitch got him in the left wrist, but he stayed in the game
Juan Miranda, 1B: 3 for 4, 2 R, 1 2B, 1 HR, 1 RBI, 1 BB – the walk was intentional … 13 for 23 (.565) with three doubles & four homers since coming off the DL … call him up, pls
Jesus Montero, C: 2 for 4, 1 R, 1 RBI, 1 BB, 1 PB – he was walked intentionally too … 4-10 K/BB ratio in his last nine games
Jorge Vazquez, DH: 1 for 5, 1 2B, 3 RBI, 1 K
Chad Huffman, RF, Eric Bruntlett, SS & Justin Christian, LF: all 1 for 4 – Huffman doubled, scored & threw a runner out at second … Bruntlett scored & committed a fielding error
David Phelps: 6 IP, 4 H, 1 R, 0 ER, 0 BB, 5 K, 10-2 GB/FB – 63 of his 95 pitches were strikes (66.3%) … 22-3 GB/FB ratio in his two starts with SWB
Mark Melancon: 2 IP, 2 H, 1 R, 1 ER, 2 BB, 2 K, 0-3 GB/FB – 19 of 39 pitches were strikes (48.7%) … man, what the hell is going on here?
Zach Segovia:1 IP, zeroes, 1 K, 0-1 GB/FB – eight of his ten pitches were strikes

[Read more…]

Game 84: So long, California

Photo Credit: Ben Margot, AP

With the exception of next week’s All Star Game, the only way the Yankees are going back to California this year is in the playoffs. You gotta love getting this games over for selfish reasons, meaning no more of these damn 10pm ET start times. By this time next week, it’ll all be over with.

The Yanks already have this series in the bag and are essentially playing with house money tonight, but that doesn’t mean it’s not a big start for A.J. Burnett. The enigmatic righthander started to right the ship last time out following a dreadful June, but he’s not out of the woods yet. The A’s hardly have a powerhouse offense, so tonight gives A.J. a chance to build some confidence and hopefully start a mid-summer streak like the one that saw him go 8-2 with a 2.08 ERA and .209/.316/.308 batting line against last year.

Here’s tonight’s starting nine, which gets really ugly after the top five…

Jeter, SS
Swisher, RF
Teixeira, 1B
A-Rod, 3B
Posada, DH
Thames, LF
Cervelli, C
Gardner, CF
Pena, 2B

And on the mound, it’s A.J. Burnett.

Another 10:05pm ET start, with YES carrying to broadcast. Enjoy.